$3.99 Delivery

Buttercup Bake Shop

25-40 min
167 Madison Ave (NaN mi)
More Info

Open Hours

8:00 AM-9:00 PM
8:30 AM-10:00 PM
8:00 AM-10:00 PM
8:00 AM-10:00 PM
8:00 AM-11:00 PM
10:00 AM-9:00 PM
10:00 AM-6:00 PM


Banana Pudding with Nilla Wafers

10 oz Signature vanilla pudding layered with fresh bananas and nilla wafers.

Chocolate Pudding Trifle

Chocolate pudding layered with chocolate cake and whipped cream.

Oreo Pudding

Fresh raspberries and gingersnap crumbles wrapped in a blanket of tangy lemon pudding.

Caramel Brownie Cookie Dough Pudding


Hazelnut Nutella pudding


Tiramisu Espresso pudding


Bars and Squares

Walnut Brownie


Assorted Brownies and Bars

Assemble 12 items from the different products buttercup bake shop offers.

Fudge Brownies


Lemon Square


Magic Coconut Bars


Gooey Cookie Bar


Campfire S'mores Bar


Mini Cupcakes

'NO NUT ' Traditional Mini dozen cupcakes

One dozen mini cupcakes with no nuts. Mixed in traditional flavors including red velvet, vanilla, and chocolate.

Specialty Premium Minis

One dozen specialty premium cupcakes of multiple assortments (dark choc peanut butter, Oreo, salted caramel, lemon, rainbow sprinkles, Marble ganache, Twinkie, and more).



Dark chocolate cake with a graham cracker crust, topped with a touched meringue & toasted marshmallow.

ChocVan & ChocChoc Cupcake

Light and fluffy strawberry cupcake made with bits of fresh strawberries, topped with strawberry butter cream and a fresh strawberry slice.

Birthday Cake Cupcake

Vanilla cake batter with a rainbow sprinkles & your choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream.

Salted Caramel

Dulce de Leche cake with Vanilla Caramel swirled buttercream, sprinkled with sea salt.

Cookies N' Cream

Vanilla Cake stuffed with a whole Oreo topped with an Oreo crumb buttercream.

Chunky Monkey

A rich banana cake with a hint of nutmeg, studded with chocolate chips & topped with dark chocolate buttercream.

Expresso Shot

Dark chocolate cake with expresso buttercream.

Lemon Raspberry Meringue

Light lemon cake filled with raspberry jam, topped with a touch meringue.

Apple Pie a La Mode

Apple cinnamon struessel cake topped with an ice-cream scoop style vanilla buttercream.

Apple Pie a La Mode

Apple cinnamon struessel cake topped with an ice-cream scoop style vanilla buttercream.

Humming Bird

Banana pineapple cake with pecans & cinnamon, topped with cream cheese frosting and a caramel drizzle.

A Dozen Assorted Traditional Cupcakes (No Nuts)

12 of our favorite classic cupcakes without any nuts.

Premium A Dozen Assorted Specialty Cupcakes

12 of our top favorite specialty cupcakes mix.

Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter

Dark choc cake with Reese's PB cups inside and PB icing. For all you peanut butter freaks out there.

Pumpkin Spice

Thick pumpkin pie batter, cinnamon, nutmeg, hint of ginger, and more secret stuff we can't tell you about. Just trust us.

Spiced Carrot

Carrot cake with apples & walnuts topped with a spiced cream cheese. Definitely a top favorite.

Devil Dog Cupcake

Chocolate cupcake with meringue frosting.

Red Velvet Cupcake

A vanilla cocoa cupcake frosted with cream cheese frosting.

Van Van & VanChoc Cupcake

Classic Vanilla with your choice of vanilla or chocolate buttercream.

Lemony Lemon Cupcake

A lemony cupcake with fresh lemon zest, lemon buttercream icing.


Bestest Oatmeal Cinnamon Cookie

Oatmeal cinnamon cookie loaded with chocolate chips.

Triple Fudge Cookie

Fudge cookie with 3 types of chocolates!

Salted Caramel Chocolate Chunk

A soft delicious salted chocolate chip caramel cookie. Definitely a favorite.

Chocolate Chip Cookie

A traditional favorite, the chocolate chip cookie.




Note Cards

Gift Note Card

Please write what you would like written in the card by First stating:" This is what I would like written in the card" and then typing the message into the "Special Instructions" text box.



A pack of 24 candles.

A Single Candle


Happy Birthday Candles

15 candles that individually spell out "H A P P Y B I R T H D A Y ! ".

Make It A Gift!

Add A Large Bow To Your Gift!

Make your gift special with a large bow!

Other Options Nearby

All Bakery Delivery In New York City

Explore Nearby Areas


AboutCareersBlogPress & MediaCivic LabsUnlimitedSupportPickup
©2018 Postmates IncTermsPrivacy