Postmates
Log in
Sign Up
Log in

Carlo's Bakery Menu

Merchandise

Red Tote Bag

$2.95
0

Buddy Bundles

5-Pack Cannoli Box

Four classic cannolis and one chocolate-dipped cannoli.
$24.95
0

Buddy's Favorites Box

Two lobster tails and four classic cannolis.
$30.95
0

6-pack Cookie Box

$20.95
0

Cakes

6" Cannoli Cake

Vanilla cake filled with cannoli cream and finished with buttercream, cannoli chips, and Italian colored sprinkles.
$34.95
0

6" Chocolate Fudge Cake

Decadent chocolate cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge frosting, topped with ganache and chocolate sprinkles.
$34.95
0

6" Rainbow Cake

Six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled high with sweet vanilla icing and covered in rainbow sprinkles.
$44.95
0

6" Strawberry Shortcake

Two layers of vanilla cake filled with pure whipped cream and fresh strawberries.
$29.95
0

6" Vanilla Confetti Cake

Vanilla cake with a burst of rainbow sprinkles filled and iced with a sweet buttercream confetti icing.
$34.95
0

6" Carrot Cake

Our classic carrot cake contains chunks of pineapple, chopped walnuts, coconut shavings, and golden raisins. Filled and topped with a sweet cream cheese icing and carrot cake crumbs.
$35.95
0

6" Red Velvet Cake

Red velvet cake filled and decorated with cream cheese frosting. Topped with chocolate ganache and red velvet cake crumbles.
$35.95
0

"Happy Birthday" Fondant Tag

$3.00
0

10" Rainbow Cake

$99.00
0

6" Rainbow Fudge Cake

6" Rainbow Fudge Cake containing six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge frosting, covered in rainbow sprinkles.
$44.95
0

6" Rainbow Strawberry Cake

$34.95
0

6" Black & White Cake

Layers of vanilla and chocolate cake layered with chocolate fudged, iced in buttercream with chocolate and white sprinkles. Serves 6-8.
$29.95
0

Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Our signature soft-baked chocolate chip cookie.
$4.00
0

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Classic soft-baked oatmeal cookie with raisins.
$4.00
0

Double Chocolate Cookie

Soft-baked double chocolate cookie with white chocolate chips.
$4.00
0

M&M Cookie

Soft-baked chocolate chip cookie with chocolate M&Ms.
$4.00
0

Peanut Butter Cookie

Soft-baked peanut butter cookie with peanut butter chips.
$4.00
0

Black & White Cookie

Soft, cake-like cookie covered half and half with vanilla and chocolate icing.
$4.95
0

1LB Butter Cookies

A pound of our mixed traditional Italian butter cookies
$21.95
0

Cake Slices

Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice

Layers of decadent chocolate cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge frosting and topped with chocolate sprinkles.
$8.95
0

Cookies & Cream Cake Slice

Chocolate cake layered with cookies & cream mousse and Oreo cookie pieces.
$8.95
0

Rainbow Cake Slice

Six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled high with a sweet vanilla icing and covered with rainbow sprinkles.
$8.95
0

Red Velvet Cake Slice

Red velvet cake filled and decorated with a sweet cream cheese frosting, covered in cake crumbs.
$8.95
0

Strawberry Shortcake Slice

Vanilla cake filled with pure whipped cream and fresh strawberries.
$8.95
0

Vanilla Confetti Cake Slice

Vanilla cake with a burst of rainbow sprinkles filled and iced with a sweet vanilla buttercream confetti icing.
$8.95
0

Carrot Cake Slice

Our classic carrot cake contains chunks of pineapple, chopped walnuts, coconut shavings, and golden raisins. Filled and topped with a smooth cream cheese icing.
$8.95
0

Rainbow Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice

Six layers of rainbow-colored vanilla cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge frosting, covered in rainbow sprinkles.
$8.95
0

PieCaken Slice

Pecan Pie on the bottom, Pumpkin Pie in the middle, and an Apple Upside-Down Cake on top, all layered together with cinnamon buttercream.
$8.95
0

Strawberry Rainbow Cake Slice

$8.95
0

Pastries

Brownie

Classic, fudge-like brownie topped with chocolate fudge frosting.
$4.50
0

Chocolate-Dipped Cannoli

Crispy Italian shell dipped in chocolate and filled with sweet ricotta cheese, chocolate chips, and hint of cinnamon. Dusted with powdered sugar.
$6.50
0

Classic Cannoli

Crispy Italian shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese, chocolate chips, and a hint of cinnamon, dusted with powdered sugar.
$5.50
0

Lobster Tail

Hand-pulled flaky dough baked to a golden brown, filled with our signature French cream and a hint of Baileys liqueur, topped with powdered sugar.
$6.50
0

Pecan Brownie

Fudge-like brownie topped with caramelized pecans, drizzled with milk and white chocolate.
$5.00
0

Strawberry Eclair

Puff pastry filled with pure whipped cream and fresh, sliced strawberries, topped with powdered sugar.
$6.50
0

Individual Desserts

Individual Classic Cheesecake

Our classic New York style cheesecake made with cream cheese and topped with pure whipped cream.
$8.95
0

Individual Dark Chocolate Mousse

A thin layer of dark chocolate cake filled with light, chocolate mousse, dipped in ganache and topped with milk chocolate drizzle and dark chocolate shavings.
$7.95
0

Individual White Chocolate Mousse

A thin layer of vanilla cake topped with light, white chocolate mousse, dipped in ganache and topped with white chocolate drizzle and marble chocolate shavings.
$7.95
0

Individual Strawberry Cheesecake

$8.95
0

Grab & Go

1lb Italian Butter Cookie Box

One pound of mixed butter cookies.
$21.95
0

4 Signature Lobster Tail Box

4 of our traditional Lobster Tails filled with French cream with a hint of Bailey's Irish Cream.
$19.10
0

Pies

8" Apple Crumb Pie

Perfect apple filling inside a buttery, flaky shell with a buttery crumb topping.
$19.95
0

8" Pumpkin Pie

Creamy, flavorful, perfectly spiced Pumpkin filling inside a buttery, flaky shell on the outside.
$19.95
0

8" Pecan Pie

Piles of Pecans mixed with our family secret ingredients and then packed into a homemade crust make for this perfectly sweet and savory southern classic.
$19.95
0

3-pack Pie Bundle

Save when you order 3 pies of your choice.
$55.95
0

Platters/Trays

Mixed Italian Butter Cookie Tray

Two pounds of assorted butter cookies.
$29.95
0

Seasonal

PieCaken

Pecan Pie on the bottom, Pumpkin Pie in the middle, and an Apple Upside-Down Cake on top, all layered together with cinnamon buttercream. Cake design may vary.
$48.95
0

Stuffed Apple Explosion Cake

This Stuffed Apple Explosion Cake is 4-layers of Autumn colored vanilla sponge cake stacked and frosted in a sweet Cinnamon Buttercream. Topped with Apple Pie filling and garnished with beautifully piped mounds of Buttercream and Autumn colored sprinkles. Cake design may vary.
$44.95
0