Postmates
Log in

Delivery

or

Pickup

Your current address is too far from this place.
×
Categories
$2.99 Delivery
INFATUATION APPROVED
Dessert

Milk Bar

495 added to favorites

25-40 min
561 Columbus Ave (NaN mi)
More Info

Open Hours

Monday
9:00 AM-11:00 PM
Tuesday
9:00 AM-11:00 PM
Wednesday
9:00 AM-10:30 PM
Thursday
9:00 AM-11:00 PM
Friday
9:00 AM-12:00 AM
Saturday
9:00 AM-12:00 AM
Sunday
9:00 AM-11:00 PM

Soft Serve

Cereal Milk™ Soft Serve

made with milk, cornflakes, brown sugar and a pinch of salt. it’s like the milk at the bottom of a bowl of cornflakes!
$5.99
0

Cereal/Compost Twist Soft Serve

Cereal milk and Compost soft serve twisted together!
$5.50
0

Compost Soft Serve

A sweet and salty soft serve version of our favorite Compost Cookie.
$5.50
0

Shakes

Crunchy Cereal Shake

Our cereal milk™ shake with cornflake crunch blended in!
$6.53
0

B'day Cake Shake

Our cereal milk™ shake blended with b’day truffles!
$6.53
0

ChocolateBday Cake Shake

Our cereal milk™ shake blended with hot fudge, and chocolate bday truffles
$6.53
0

MilkQuakes™

Regular Strawberry & Corn MilkQuake™

Pickled strawberry jam and corn cookies blended with cereal milk™ soft serve!
$9.00
0

Regular B'day MilkQuake™

B'day cake truffles and rainbow sprinkles blended into cereal milk™ soft serve!
$9.00
0

Baby-Sized Compost MilkQuake™

$6.00
0

Baby Sized B'day MilkQuake™

B'day cake truffles and rainbow sprinkles blended into cereal milk™ soft serve!
$6.00
0

Baby-Sized Strawberry & Corn MilkQuake™

Pickled strawberry jam and corn cookies blended with cereal milk™ soft serve!
$6.00
0

Compost MilkQuake

$9.00
0

Baby-Sized Chocolate Bday Quake

$6.00
0

Regular Chocolate Bday Quake

$9.00
0

Cookies

Cornflake-Chocolate-Chip-Marshmallow Cookie

our play on the classic chocolate chip cookie with crunchy cornflakes, gooey marshmallows & mini chocolate chips!
$2.75
0

Corn Cookie

a milk bar cult favorite - the familiar flavors from cornbread transform into a sweet, buttery cookie!
$2.75
0

Blueberry & Cream™ Cookie

a cookie that tastes like the top of a blueberry muffin-we take our sugar cookie dough, add bits of milk crumbs & morsels of dried blueberries!
$2.75
0

Confetti Cookie

Just like the milk bar b'day truffles and layer cake, this sugar cookie is full of birthday sprinkles, birthday crumbs and that familiar old fashioned vanilla flavor!
$2.75
0

Chocolate Chocolate Cookie

chocolate cookie dough, chocolate crumbs and a hint of salt makes this dense and fudgy cookie taste just like a very chocolatey brownie!
$2.75
0

3 Cookies

Blueberry & Cream Cookie,,Chocolate Chocolate Cookie, and a Cornflake Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cookie
$7.50
0

6 Cookies & Tin

$16.00
0

12 Cookies

$26.50
0

Compost Cookie

Packed with pretzels, potato chips, coffee, oats, butterscotch, and chocolate chips. This cookie strikes the perfect balance between salty and sweet.
$2.75
0

Gluten Free Fruity Marshmallow Cookie

Crispy, chewy, light, AND gluten free! Filled with gooey marshmallows and fruity cereal. A gluten free, fruity version of our Cornflake Marshmallow cookie.
$2.75
0

6 Gluten Free Fruity Marshmallow Cookies + Tin

A tin of our crispy, chewy, light, AND gluten free cookies! Filled with gooey marshmallows and fruity cereal. A gluten free, fruity version of our Cornflake Marshmallow cookie.
$16.00
0

Cake Truffles

B'day Cake Truffles

Our vanilla rainbow cake, tossed in white chocolate and rolled in rainbow cake crumbs - it's a birthday party in a bite! (Pack of 3)
$6.00
0

3 Packs of Cake Truffles

$16.50
0

Dozen Box of Cake Truffles

Choose from any four packs of truffles. Three truffles in each pack.
$24.00
0

Gluten Free* B'day Truffles

No gluten, no problem. Celebrate 365 with gluten-free vanilla rainbow cake mixed with vanilla infused milk, coated with white chocolate and rolled in gluten-free rainbow cake crumbs. *The gluten free birthday cake and gluten free birthday truffles are NOT certified gluten free. We try our best to avoid cross contamination by baking them in a separate area, but cannot guarantee they won’t come into contact with trace amounts of gluten.
$6.00
0

Chocolate Bday Cake Truffles

$6.00
0

Apple Pie Cake Truffles

A portable, poppable version of our Apple Pie Cake! Brown butter meets our cinnamon apple compote, then gets rolled into round truffles and coated with a thin layer of white chocolate and pie dough sand (a sandier version of pie crust).
$6.00
0

Cakes & Pies

Milk Bar Pie™ Slice

Toasted oat crust, gooey butter filling!
$6.00
0

Milk Bar Pie™ Whole

Toasted oat crust, gooey butter filling! (Eight slices)
$46.00
0

6" Birthday Cake

Everyone's favorite childhood cake re-imagined milk bar style - vanilla rainbow cake layered with rainbow cake crumble and vanilla frosting! unfortunately, we cannot accommodate scripts/personalizations
$49.00
0

6" Chocolate Bday Cake

$49.00
0

6" Apple Pie Cake

Brown butter and cinnamon cake, brown butter cheesecake, apple compote made with diced green apple, pie crumbs and pie frosting. All the flavors you love from an Apple Pie, but with an unexpected Milk Bar twist.
$49.00
0

Breads

Bagel Bomb

Our bagel dough filled with a smoky bacon scallion cream cheese, topped with everything bagel spice. savory & delicious!
$4.36
0

Egg & Cheddar Bomb

Sriracha cream cheese, sandwiched between an organic baked egg omelet, folded inside of our bagel dough, and topped with cheddar cheese & Spanish onion!
$4.90
0

Spinach Artichoke Bomb

The ultimate party snack, reinvented milk bar style! Pumpernickel-rye dough filled with an explosion of spinach-artichoke dip!
$4.90
0

Drinks

Milk Jugs

Still Water

$1.63
0

Sparkling Water

$1.63
0

Combos

Greatest Hits Combo

All of your favorite milk bar classics in one combo! Comes with one slice of Milk Bar Pie, one pack of b'day truffles, a compost® cookie, and a single serving of cereal milk™ soft serve with cornflake crunch!
$20.69
0

Baking Mixes

Compost® Cookie Mix

Makes 12 compost cookies!
$16.00
0

Corn Cookie Mix

Makes 12 corn cookies!
$16.00
0

Blueberry and Cream™ Cookie Mix

Makes 12 blueberry and cream™ cookies!
$16.00
0

Cornflake-chocolate-chip-marshmallow Mix

Makes 12 cornflake-chocolate-chip-marshmallow cookies!
$16.00
0

Confetti Cookie Mix

Makes 12 confetti cookies!
$16.00
0

Cereal Milk Mix

Makes 8 cups of cereal milk!
$5.00
0

Corn Powder

Freeze dried corn ground into a powder. One of our favorite ingredients! Use it for Milk Bar Pie, cereal milk™, and other milk bar treats!
$6.00
0

Other Options Nearby

All Dessert Delivery In New York

Explore Nearby Areas

Postmates

Postmates

©2019 Postmates IncTermsPrivacy