Postmates
Log in
Sign Up
Log in

Delivery

or

Pickup

Your current address is too far from this place.
×
Categories

My Sugar Pie

Bakery

30-45 min
40 East Pine Street (NaN mi)
More Info

Open Hours

Order Delivery until 2:30 PM
Monday
12:00 PM-6:00 PM
Tuesday
12:00 PM-6:00 PM
Wednesday
12:00 PM-6:00 PM
Thursday
12:00 PM-6:00 PM
Friday
12:00 PM-6:00 PM
Saturday
12:00 PM-3:00 PM
Sunday
Closed

Fruit Pies

Appie Pie

Apple pie is an American classic with fresh apples, cinnamon and sugar.
$28.00
0

Mom’s Original Dutch Apple Pie

This signature pie is big with layers of fresh apples, cinnamon and sugar topped with a buttery crumb topping.
$29.00
0

Mixed Berry Lattice Crust

Blueberries, blackberries and red raspberries mix well together in this pie.
$28.00
0

Dutch Mixed Berry

Blueberries, blackberries and red raspberries mix well together with a buttery crumb topping in this pie.
$29.00
0

Blackberry Pie Lattice Crust

Plump, juicy blackberries make this an incredible pie.
$31.00
0

Dutch Blackberry Pie

Plump, juicy blackberries make this an incredible pie.
$32.00
0

Go Blueberry Pie Lattice Crust

$29.00
0

Dutch Go Blueberry Pie

The juicy, blueberry filling in this pie is topped with a sugary, crumb topping.
$30.00
0

Cherry Pie Lattice Crust

Large, tart cherries combine with the sugary crisp crust.
$29.00
0

Dutch Cherry

Tart cherries in the filling are topped with a buttery crumb crunch topping in this pie. The combination of tart and sweet is heavenly.
$30.00
0

Peach Pie Lattice Crust

Fresh peaches in the filling of this pie are topped with the classic crisscrossed.
$27.00
0

Dutch Peach Pie

Fresh, juicy peaches in the filling of this pie are topped with Kelly’s mom’s buttery, crumb topping.
$28.00
0

Peach Blueberry Lattice

Juicy peaches and bursting blueberries are a wonderful combination in this pie.
$28.00
0

Dutch Peach Blueberry Pie

Ripe peaches and fresh blueberries mixed together and covered with mom’s dutch crumb topping make for an incredible end-of-summer pie. Ingredients peaches, blueberries, sugar, flour, vegetable shortening, butter, tapioca, cornstarch, salt and soy lecithin.
$29.00
0

Peach Praline

Fresh peach filling covered with chopped pecans and buttery crumb topping.
$30.00
0

Pineapple Pie Lattice Crust

Crushed pineapple is wonderful in this sweet treat.
$25.00
0

Dutch Pineapple Pie

Crushed sweet pineapple filling and topped with mom’s original buttery crumb topping.
$26.00
0

Black Raspberry Lattice Crust

The black raspberries are extremely juicy.
$33.00
0

Dutch Black Raspberry

Pie is filled with juicy black raspberries and topped with our butter-filled crumb topping.
$34.00
0

Red Raspberry Kisser Pie Lattice Crust

Juicy red raspberries make this fruit pie very tart. We add a sugary, criss-crossed top crust to compliment this tart pie.
$29.00
0

Dutch Red Raspberry Kisser Pie

Pie are tart and go well with the buttery crumb topping.
$30.00
0

Rhubarb Pie Lattice Crust

Tart flavor combined with the sugary crust is refreshing and delicious.
$28.00
0

Dutch Rhubarb Pie

Rhubarb filling in this pie is topped with my mom’s buttery crumb crunch topping.
$29.00
0

Strawberry Pie Lattice Crust

Fresh strawberries and the crispy, sugary crust make this pie.
$28.00
0

Dutch Strawberry Pie

Strawberry filling in this pie is topped with a buttery crumb crunch.
$29.00
0

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Lattice Crust

Fresh strawberries and rhubarb are amazing in this pie.
$29.00
0

Dutch Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Strawberries and rhubarb in the pie filling are topped with a buttery crumb crunch in this crowd pleaser.
$30.00
0

Cream Pies

Banana Cream Pie

Fresh sliced bananas combined with rich vanilla cream are the base for this meringue topped delicious pie.
$29.00
0

Butterscotch Cream Pie

This is the pie that Kelly had instead of cake for her birthday growing up. It has a light, butterscotch flavor in the filling and is covered with mile-high meringue.
$29.00
0

Chocolate Cream Pie

Creamy chocolate filling is covered with lightly golden meringue in this chocolate pie.
$30.00
0

Chocolate & Peanut Butter Cream Pie

.56 lbs
$30.00
0

Coconut Cream Pie

The coconut is mixed into the rich and creamy vanilla filling. It is topped with meringue and toasted coconut.
$29.00
0

French Silk & Whipped Cream

4.25 lbs.
$32.00
0

Lemon Meringue

Perfectly tart lemon pie topped with meringue for your enjoyment.
$29.00
0

My Elvis Pie PB & Banana Cream

4.25 lbs.
$29.00
0

Peanut Butter Cream Pie

Peanut butter is crumbled into the vanilla cream filling. The top of the pie is meringue with peanut butter crumbled on top of it.
$30.00
0

Vanilla Cream Pie

Rich vanilla cream is topped with meringue.
$28.00
0

Other Favorites

Chocolate Chip I Love You pie

Cookie, warm and gooey on the inside and very rich.
$25.00
0

My Kentucky Pie

Combination of bourbon, chocolate chips, and pecans in our flaky crust.
$29.00
0

Key Lime

4.25 lbs.
$29.00
0

Pecan Pie

Along with pumpkin pie pecan pie. Filling is buttery and rich and the pecans make it the perfect traditional pie.
$29.00
0

Pumpkin Pie

Pumpkin pie is creamy.
$27.00
0

Sugar Cream Hoosier Sugar Pie

This sugar cream pie is decadent and very rich. Unlike the vanilla cream pie on our list, the sugar cream pie does not have a meringue top. Butter, sugar and cream.
$27.00
0

Order anything

Tell us what you want and we will send a Postmate to get it for you.
Add an item
Describe what you're looking for. Learn more

Explore Nearby Areas

Postmates

Postmates

©2020 Postmates IncTermsPrivacy