Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Bagel Express Sayville
    Too far to deliver

    Bagel Express Sayville

    4.3
    (52)
      •  
    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday
    06:00 AM - 01:00 PM
    Monday - Saturday
    06:00 AM - 01:30 PM

    217 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782 • More


    • Picked for you

      • Bakers Dozen Bagels

        13 Pieces.
        $9.69
      • Flavored

        $6.59
      • Build Your Own Sandwich

        $7.99
      • Turkey Club

        Oven Gold turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Patriot

        Turkey, roast beef, deluxe ham, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
    • Platters

      • American Platter

        Eggs, onions, bacon, and American cheese.
        $6.59
      • Calorie Counter Platter

        Egg whites, turkey, and alpine lace Swiss cheese.
        $6.59
      • Greek Platter

        Egg whites, spinach, feta cheese, and onions.
        $6.59
      • Mexican Platter

        Eggs, bacon, Swiss, tomato, and jalapeno peppers.
        $6.59
      • Moon Struck Platter

        Fried eggs, cooked in a bagel basket, topped with spinach or roasted peppers.
        $6.59
      • Potato and Egg Platter

        Eggs, onions, and fries.
        $6.59
      • Vegan Platter

        Eggs, mushrooms, grilled onions, and peppers.
        $6.59
      • Western Platter

        Eggs, peppers, ham, American cheese, and onion.
        $5.69
      • French Toast Platter

        Made with eggs, cinnamon white bread on French toast bagel.
        $6.59
      • Pancakes Platter

        Three Stacks.
        $5.69
      • Pancakes with Fruit Platter

        Three stack with fruit.
        $7.59
      • The Ultimate Paleo Chicken-Vegetable Platter

        The ultimate paleo chicken-vegetable platter grilled chicken, grilled vegetable, tomato with stacks scoop of cranberry chicken salad, and choice of dressing.
        $7.99
      • Rocky Mountain BBQ Chicken Melt Platter

        Grilled chicken cutlet with BBQ sauce, bacon bits, grilled onions, melted provolone served on a mountain of french fries.
        $8.49
      • Spicy Melt Platter

        Spicy Mexican grilled chicken sauteed onions, peppers, and melted pepper jack cheese over fries.
        $8.49
        Spicy
    • Egg Sandwich

      • Eggs Sandwich

        Served with choice of a small coffee, tea or OJ.
        $3.59
      • Eggs and Cheese Sandwich

        Served with choice of a small coffee, tea or OJ.
        $3.79
      • Eggs and Meat Sandwich

        Served with choice of a small coffee, tea or OJ.
        $3.59
      • Eggs, Cheese, and Meat Sandwich

        Served with choice of a small coffee, tea or OJ.
        $4.69
    • Mini Bagels

      • Half Dozen Mini Bagel

        $4.88
      • Bakers Dozen Mini Bagel

        13 Pieces.
        $9.59
      • Mini Bagel

        $0.69
      • Mini with Butter Bagel

        $1.89
      • Mini with Flavored Bagel

        $2.59
      • Low Fat Cream Cheese Bagel

        $2.59
      • Mini with Lox Spread Bagel

        $2.89
      • Mini with Plain Cream Cheese Bagel

        $2.19
      • Mini with Sliced Nova and Cream Cheese Bagel

        $7.59
      • Mini with White Fish Salad Bagel

        $6.59
    • Specialty Salads

      • Caesar Salad

        Romaine lettuce, shredded asiago cheese and croutons. Served with choice of dressing.
        $6.59
      • Chef Salad

        Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber topped with deluxe ham, swiss cheese, and turkey breast. Served with choice of dressing.
        $7.59
      • Greek Salad

        Romaine lettuce, tomato, feta cheese, red onion, and black olives. Served with choice of dressing.
        $7.59
      • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

        Grilled chicken, Romaine lettuce, shredded Asiago cheese, and croutons. Served with choice of dressing.
        $7.59
      • Tossed Salad

        Iceberg lettuce, tomato, and cucumber. Served with choice of dressing.
        $5.69
      • Buffalo Salad

        Mixed greens, red peppers, green peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, red onions, cherry peppers, and olives topped with our spicy buffalo chicken salad, served with ranch or blue cheese dressing.
        $8.49
      • Spicy Caesar Salad

        Hot blackened grilled chicken on top of our classic caesar salad.
        $8.49
        Spicy
      • Mediterranean Salad

        Marinated grilled chicken, feta, cucumbers, peppers, olives, and tomato.
        $8.49
      • Healthy Choice Spinach and Grilled Chicken Salad

        Grilled chicken served warm with sun-dried cranberries, walnuts, spinach, and balsamic.
        $8.49
      • Tuna Salad

        Tuna salad on a large tossed green salad.
        $8.49
      • Chicken Salad

        Chicken salad on a large tossed green salad.
        $8.49
      • Egg Salad

        Egg salad on a large tossed green salad.
        $7.59
    • Spreads (By the Pound)

      • Butter

        $4.88
      • Flavored

        $6.59
      • Low Fat Cream Cheese

        $6.59
      • Nova Lox Spread

        $8.49
      • Nova Salmon Sliced

        $23.59
      • Plain Cream Cheese

        $5.69
      • White Fish

        $14.09
    • Bagels

      • Bakers Dozen Bagels

        13 Pieces.
        $9.69
      • Bagel

        $0.99
    • Side Orders and Additions

      • Two Strips of Bacon

        $1.39
      • Cheese Slice

        $0.39
      • Egg White

        $0.99
      • Egg

        $0.99
      • Ham

        $1.59
      • Home Fries

        $3.69
      • Jelly

        $0.39
      • Onion Slice

        $0.28
      • Pickle Slice

        $0.39
      • Sausage Patty

        $1.59
      • Spinach

        $0.39
      • Toast

        $1.39
      • Tomato

        $0.39
      • Turkey Breast

        $1.59
    • Build Your Own Sandwich

      • Build Your Own Sandwich

        $7.99
    • Hot Heros with Fries

      • Holy Guacamole

        Grilled blackened chicken, bacon, Cheddar, lettuce, tomato and guacamole on a hero served with fries.
        $8.49
      • Chicken Asiago

        Sliced buffalo chicken breast, bacon, melted asiago, and chipotle ranch on a hero served with fries.
        $8.49
      • Honey Mustard Hero

        Grilled honey mustard chicken with melted swiss on a hero with fries.
        $8.49
      • Super Spicy Steak Hero

        Cajun spiced steak, sauteed onions peppers and mushrooms, 4 pepper cheese, chipotle sauce with fries.
        $7.29
        Spicy
      • Vegetarian Hero

        Fried eggplant, mozzarella cheese, sun-dried tomato, and balsamic dressing with fries.
        $8.49
      • The Fat Cowboy

        Roast beef, melted Cheddar, cooked onions, bacon and BBQ sauce on hero with fries.
        $8.49
      • The Fat Philly

        Steak, onions, peppers, mushrooms, American cheese on hero with fries.
        $8.49
      • The Sticky Finger

        Chicken tenders, melted pepper jack cheese and honey mustard on hero with fries.
        $8.49
    • Panini

      • Bacon Lovers Chicken Panini

        Chicken cutlet, melted American cheese, crispy bacon topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • Fratelli's Head Supreme Panini

        Prosciutto pepperoni, provolone cheese, ham, and sun-dried tomato, brushed with olive oil. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • Boar's Head Supreme Panini

        Prosciutto pepperoni, provolone cheese, ham, and sun-dried tomato, brushed with olive oil. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • South Of The Border Panini

        Peppermill turkey breast, melted pepper jack cheese, field greens, tomato, salsa, and guacamole. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • Continental Panini

        Deluxe ham, melted brie cheese, field greens, and french dressing. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • Grilled Portobello Delight Panini

        Grilled portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella cheese, balsamic vinaigrette dressing, and fresh basil. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • Milano Panini

        Oven roasted beef with melted Colby jack cheese, field greens, tomato, and horseradish sauce. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • Sun-drenched Turkey Breast Panini

        Sun-dried tomato, roasted turkey breast, asiago cheese, Bermuda onion, and Romaine lettuce. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • The Natural Panini

        Fresh peppers, cucumbers, zucchini, gorgonzola cheese, lettuce, tomato, and cucumber dressing. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
      • Tuscan Chicken Panini

        Seared chicken breast topped with pesto mayonnaise, field greens, and Bermuda onion. Served with side salad. Hot melted sandwiches on focaccia bread and available as a wrap or on a hero.
        $7.99
    • Classic Sandwiches

      • Chicken Salad Bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Chicken Salad Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Chicken Salad Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Chicken Salad Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Egg Salad Bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • Egg Salad Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • Egg Salad Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • Egg Salad Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • Grilled Cheese Bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $5.69
      • Grilled Cheese Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $5.69
      • Grilled Cheese Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $5.69
      • Grilled Cheese Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $5.69
      • Nutella Bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • Nutella Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • Nutella Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • Nutella Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • PB and J bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • PB and J Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • PB and J Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • PB and J Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $3.79
      • Tuna Salad Bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Tuna Salad Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Tuna Salad Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • Tuna Salad Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $7.99
      • BLT Bagel Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • BLT Roll Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • BLT Wrap Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • BLT Sliced Bread Sandwich

        Served with side salad.
        $6.59
      • BBQ Chicken Salad Sandwich

        $7.99
      • Buffalo Chicken Salad Sandwich

        $7.99
      • Egg White Salad Sandwich

        $6.59
    • Specialty Sandwiches

      • Boone Sandwich

        Breaded chicken cutlet, American cheese, bacon, and Russian dressing. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Wolfie

        Breaded chicken cutlet, fried eggplant, Provolone cheese, roasted peppers, and pesto mayonnaise. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Caesar

        Grilled chicken caesar salad. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Popeye

        Grilled chicken, spinach, and Swiss cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Turkey Club

        Oven Gold turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Tex Mex

        Peppermill turkey, Pepper Jack cheese, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion, and guacamole. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Honeymoon

        Honey maple turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, sun-dried tomato, and onion. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $6.79
      • Patriot

        Turkey, roast beef, deluxe ham, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • 3 Village

        Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, roasted peppers, olive oil, and vinegar. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Say Cheese

        Mozzarella cheese, tomato and pesto cheese, sun-dried tomato, and balsamic. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Vegetarian

        Fried eggplant, mozzarella cheese, sun-dried tomato, and balsamic. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • The Beast

        Hot roast beef and melted mozzarella cheese on toasted garlic bread. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Pastrami Melt

        Hot pastrami, melted swiss cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Reuben

        Hot pastrami, melted Swiss cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Philly Cheese

        Hot chopped steak, mushrooms, onions, and melted mozzarella cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • The Gasm

        Breaded chicken cutlet, American cheese, bacon, and coleslaw. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $6.79
    • Specialty Wraps

      • Boone Sandwich

        Breaded chicken cutlet, American cheese, bacon, and Russian dressing. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Wolfie

        Breaded chicken cutlet, fried eggplant, Provolone cheese, roasted peppers, and pesto mayonnaise. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Caesar

        Grilled chicken caesar salad. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Popeye

        Grilled chicken, spinach, and Swiss cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Turkey Club

        Oven Gold turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Tex Mex

        Peppermill turkey, Pepper Jack cheese, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomato, onion, and guacamole. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Honeymoon

        Honey maple turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, sun-dried tomato, and onion. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Patriot

        Turkey, roast beef, deluxe ham, American cheese, lettuce, and tomato. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • 3 Village

        Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, roasted peppers, olive oil, and vinegar. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Say Cheese

        Mozzarella cheese, tomato and pesto cheese, sun-dried tomato, and balsamic. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • Vegetarian

        Fried eggplant, mozzarella cheese, sun-dried tomato, and balsamic. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • The Beast

        Hot roast beef and melted mozzarella cheese on toasted garlic bread. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Pastrami Melt

        Hot pastrami, melted swiss cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Reuben

        Hot pastrami, melted Swiss cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $7.99
      • Philly Cheese

        Hot chopped steak, mushrooms, onions, and melted mozzarella cheese. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
      • The Gasm

        Breaded chicken cutlet, American cheese, bacon, and coleslaw. Served with side salad, made on a bagel, roll, wrap, white, wheat or rye.
        $8.49
    • Specialty Smoothies

      • Smoothies

        Bagel express of Sayville makes their specialty healthy smoothies with only fruits and vegetable.
        $6.09
    • Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

      • Zumex Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice

        Fresh squeezed orange juice nothing added only fresh orange with mild orange pulp.
        $3.29
    • Beverage

      • Nitro Cold Brew

        $3.79
      • Snapple

        16 oz.
        $2.29
      • Poland Spring Water

        One L.
        $2.79
    • Tate's Cookies

      • Tate's Cookies

        $5.69
    Spend $20, Save $5