Location and hours

2216 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

Every Day
08:00 AM - 04:00 PM

Benkert's Bakery

4.9 (30 ratings) • American • $

• More info

2216 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720

Tap for hours, info, and more

Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.

$ • American • Breakfast and Brunch • Desserts • Group Friendly

Picked for you
- Rainbow Cookies
  Traditional rainbow cookies sold by the pound.
- Cookie Trays
  Assorted Italian cookies.
- Red Velvet Cake
  Our rich red velvet cake, with a creamy cream cheese filling, and icing garnished with red velvet cake crumbs.
- Strawberry Short Cake
  Our moist yellow cake, with a strawberry preserve filling, topped in whipped cream with a strawberry garnish, and yellow cake crumbs around the sides.
- Small Pastry Platter
  18 assorted small pastries.
Cakes
- Death by Chocolate Cake
  Chocolate cake with fudge filling iced in a rich chocolate ganache topped with chocolate curls and powder sugar.
- Fudge Crunch Cake
  Chocolate cake with a creamy chocolate fudge filling and icing and chocolate crunches around the sides.
- All Chocolate Layer Cake
  Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream filling and iced in chocolate fudge.
- Seven Later Cake
  7 layers of our moist yellow cake with chocolate buttercream filling and chocolate fudge icing.
- Half and Half Layer Cake
  2 layers of yellow cake and one layer of chocolate cake with vanilla and chocolate buttercream.
- Chocolate Cheese Supreme Cake
  2 layers of chocolate cake and one layer of our creamy marble cheesecake with a chocolate butter cream filling and iced in chocolate fudge.
- White Fudge Layer Cake
  Our moist yellow cake with a chocolate buttercream filling and a chocolate fudge icing.
- German Chocolate Cake
  A chocolate cake, with a sweet honey coconut filling iced in chocolate fudge with a honey coconut garnish on top.
- Red Velvet Cake
  Our rich red velvet cake, with a creamy cream cheese filling, and icing garnished with red velvet cake crumbs.
- Carrot Cake
  A traditional carrot cake, with a creamy cream cheese filling, and icing garnished with Napoleon cake crumbs.
- Blackout Layer Cake
  A chocolate cake, with a dark chocolate pudding filling, and our rich chocolate ganache icing.
- Zebra Layer Cake
  A chocolate cake, with a layer of chocolate fudge filling, a layer of vanilla buttercream filling, and iced in vanilla buttercream with chocolate sprinkles around the sides.
- Cannoli Cake
  A rum soaked yellow cake, with creamy cannoli filling topping in whipped cream with a toasted almond garnish.
- Strawberry Short Cake
  Our moist yellow cake, with a strawberry preserve filling, topped in whipped cream with a strawberry garnish, and yellow cake crumbs around the sides.
- Black Forest Cake
  A rum soaked chocolate cake, with a black cherry filling, topped in whipped cream with chocolate curls, cherry garnish, and chocolate cake crumbs around the sides.
- Shadow Layer Cake
  2 layers of chocolate cake, 1 layer of yellow cake, with a vanilla buttercream filling, and icing with a hard chocolate drop on top of cake decorated with assorted colors of flowers.
- Mocha Layer Cake
  2 layers of yellow cake, 1 layer of chocolate cake, with a mocha buttercream filling, and icing with chocolate sprinkles around the sides.
- Maple Walnut Layer Cake
  A yellow cake, with a maple flavored buttercream filling, and icing with a walnut garnish.
- Chocolate Raspberry Layer Cake
  Our rich chocolate cake, with a raspberry filling iced in chocolate buttercream with a chocolate ganache drizzle, and chocolate sprinkles around the sides.
- Balloon Layer Cake
  Our moist yellow cake, with a vanilla buttercream filling, icing decorated with buttercream balloons, and rainbow sprinkles.
- Oreo Layer Cake
  A chocolate cake, with an Oreo buttercream filling iced in vanilla buttercream with an Oreo garnish, and chocolate crunchies around the sides.
- Whipped Cream Birthday Cake
  A yellow cake with a choice of strawberry or chocolate pudding filling with whipped cream icing.
- Chocolate Delight Birthday Cake
  A chocolate cake, with chocolate pudding filling, and chocolate fudge icing.
- Rainbow Layer Cake
  A traditional rainbow cookie in cake form iced in chocolate fudge.
Cup Cakes
- Unicorn Cupcake
  A yellow cake with a multi colored buttercream swirl in a unicorn cupcake holder, unicorn horn, and ears.
- Sunflower Cupcake
  Yellow cake with a yellow buttercream icing and a fudge dollop to look like a sunflower.
- Cannoli Cupcake
  A chocolate chip cupcake with cannoli cream icing dipped in chocolate ganache.
- Funfetti Cupcake
  A funfetti cake with vanilla buttercream icing with confetti sprinkles.
- Rose Cupcake
  A chocolate cupcake dipped in a hard chocolate with a buttercream rose on top.
- Kids Cupcake
  A yellow cake with vanilla buttercream icing airbrushed in a variety of colors.
Cheesecakes
- Plain Cheesecake
  A creamy New York style cheesecake.
- Tropical Fruit Cheesecake
  Our creamy New York style cheesecake topped with a variety of fresh fruit.
- French Apple Cheesecake
  A creamy cheesecake with sliced apples inside topped with crumbs and powder sugar with a cinnamon sugar apple garnish.
- Cannoli Cheesecake
  Our creamy New York style cheesecake topped with cannoli cream and cannoli shells with a chocolate ganache drizzle.
- Lindy Fudge Cheesecake
  A creamy marble cheesecake with a chocolate fudge swirl topping.
- Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
  A creamy cheesecake with chocolate chips inside topped with with chocolate fudge.
- Oreo Cheesecake
  A creamy cheesecake with pieces of Oreo inside topped with vanilla buttercream and pieces of Oreo.
- Black Forest Cheesecake
  Our creamy marble cheesecake with black cherry, chocolate fudge, and chocolate buttercream garnishes.
- Strawberry Cheesecake
  Our traditional New York style cheesecake with fresh strawberries with a strawberry glaze on top.
- Fruit Cheesecake
  Our traditional New York style cheesecake with blueberry, cherry, and pineapple preserves on top.
- Italian Cheesecake
  A cookie dough crusted cheesecake made with ricotta cheese.
- Brooklyn Cheesecake
  A creamy cheesecake make with pineapples and sour cream.
Cookies
- Cookie Trays
  Assorted Italian cookies.
- Rainbow Cookies
  Traditional rainbow cookies sold by the pound.
- Large Black and White Cookies
- Large Linzer Tarts
- Rainbow Cookie Box
Pastries
- Small Pastry Platter
  18 assorted small pastries.
- Large Pastry Platter
  48 assorted small pastries.
- Large Napoleone's
- Small Cannolis
- Large Cannolis
- Small Custard Eclairs
- Large Custard Eclairs
- Large Whipped Cream Eclairs
- Brownies with Walnuts
- Brownies with M&M
- Cannoli Dip Platter
  12" platter with Cannoli "chips" and Cannoli filling as the Dip
Holiday Items
- Apple Pie
- Cherry Pie
- Blueberry Pie

Frequently asked questions

What is the address of Benkert’s Bakery in Centereach?

Benkert’s Bakery is located at: 2216 Middle Country Rd , Centereach

Is the menu for Benkert’s Bakery available online?

Yes, you can access the menu for Benkert’s Bakery online on Postmates. Follow the link to see the full menu available for delivery and pickup.

What are the most popular items on the Benkert’s Bakery menu?

The most ordered items from Benkert’s Bakery are: Brownies with M&M,Large Black and White Cookies,Large Cannolis.

Does Benkert’s Bakery offer delivery in Centereach?

Yes, Benkert’s Bakery offers delivery in Centereach via Postmates. Enter your delivery address to see if you are within the Benkert’s Bakery delivery radius, then place your order.

Can I get free delivery from Benkert’s Bakery?

Delivery fees for Benkert’s Bakery vary. Just enter your delivery address to see the delivery fee for your location. You could always get free delivery from Benkert’s Bakery with Postmates Unlimited.

Can I pick up my order from Benkert’s Bakery?

Postmates offers pickup from many restaurants in your city. To see if you can pick up your order from Benkert’s Bakery, add items to your cart and look for the ‘pickup’ option at checkout.

Can I schedule a delivery order from Benkert’s Bakery?

Some restaurants on Postmates allow you to schedule a delivery to show up at your location when you want it. At checkout, look for the option to select a delivery time. If it’s there, that means you can schedule your delivery from Benkert’s Bakery.