Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Buttercooky Bakery
    Too far to deliver

    Buttercooky Bakery

    4.5
    (59)
      •  
    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday
    06:30 AM - 06:30 PMDesserts
    06:30 AM - 05:00 PMDesserts
    07:00 AM - 04:00 PMBreakfast & Lunch
    Monday - Thursday
    06:30 AM - 06:30 PMDesserts
    07:00 AM - 04:00 PMBreakfast & Lunch
    Friday - Saturday
    06:30 AM - 07:30 PMDesserts
    07:00 AM - 04:00 PMBreakfast & Lunch

    495 New York Ave, Huntington, NY 11743 • More


    • Picked for you

      • Lobster Tail Pastry

        Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious bavarian cream
        $5.25
      • Strawberry Shortcake

        $5.25
      • Plain Croissant

        $4.25
      • Oreo Cheesecake

        $5.25
      • Napolean Slice

        Gorgeously golden crispy layers of puff pastry filled with rich custard pastry cream, finished with a glossy royal icing
        $5.25
    • Coffee Station (Hot, Cold, Draft)

      Flavors: Hazelnut, Vanilla, Almond, Caramel, Chocolate Syrup, Vanilla Syrup Choice of Milk: Whole Milk, Skim, Almond Milk, Fat Free Milk

      • Small Coffee

        $2.50
      • Medium Coffee

        $2.50
      • Large Coffee

        Large Coffee
        $3.00
      • Espresso

        $2.15
      • Large Iced Coffee

        $3.00
      • Small Tea

        $2.75
      • Large Tea

        $3.00
      • Cappuccino

        $3.50
      • Latte

        $4.00
      • Americanao Coffee

        $3.50
      • Macchiato

        $3.50
      • Mocha Coffee

        $4.00
      • Hot Chocolate Bomb

        $6.50
      • Herbal Tea

        $3.50
      • Cold Brew on Draft

        $5.00
      • Iced Latte

        $4.50
      • Nitro Coffee on Draft

        $6.95
    • Cold Beverages

      • V8

        $3.00
      • Pure Leaf Tea

        $3.00
      • Pure Leaf Unsweetened Tea

        $3.00
      • Pellegrino

        $3.00
      • Figi Water

        $3.00
      • Poland Spring

        $2.00
      • Cranberry Juice

        $3.00
      • Grape Juice

        $3.00
      • Apple Juice

        $3.00
      • Orange Juice

        $3.00
      • Sparkling Ice Black Raspberry

        $3.50
      • Nesquik Chocolate Milk

        $3.00
      • Coco-Cola

        $3.00
      • Diet Coke

        $3.00
      • Sprite

        $3.00
    • Breakfast Pastries

      • Plain Croissant

        $4.25
      • Chocolate Croissant

        $4.75
      • Nutella Croissant

        $4.75
      • Almond Croissant

        $4.75
      • Caramel Croissant

        $4.75
      • Pistachio Croissant

        $4.75
      • Raspberry Cheese Croissant

        $4.75
      • Apple Croissant

        $4.75
      • Pecan Croissant

        $4.75
      • Cronut (Jelly Filled Fried Croissant)

        $4.95
      • Pecan Danish

        $3.75
      • Cinnamon Raisin Danish

        $3.75
      • Apricot Danish

        $3.75
      • Prune Danish

        $3.75
      • Raspberry Danish

        $3.75
      • Blueberry Danish

        $3.75
      • Pineapple Danish

        $3.75
      • Cheese Danish

        $3.75
      • Almond Danish

        $3.75
      • Lemon Danish

        $3.75
      • Bluberry Muffin

        $3.95
      • Corn Muffin

        $3.95
      • Banana Pecan Muffin

        $3.95
      • Cranberry Walnut Muffin

        $3.95
      • Chocolate Chip Muffin

        $3.95
      • Lemon Poppy Muffin

        $3.95
      • Brand Muffin

        $3.95
      • Peach Boat Puff Pastry

        $4.50
      • Blueberry Scone

        $3.75
      • Chocolate Chip Scone

        $3.75
      • Cranberry Walnut Scone

        $3.75
      • Raisin and Pecan Scone

        $3.75
      • Almond Horns

        $4.50
      • Chocolate Cigars (Puff Pastry Dough)

        $3.75
      • Raspberry Cigar (Puff Pastry Dough)

        $3.75
      • Jelly Donuts

        $2.95
      • Boston Cream Donut Vanilla Icing

        $2.95
      • Boston Cream Chocolate Donut

        $2.95
      • Vanilla Frosted Donut

        $2.75
      • Chocolate Donut

        $2.75
      • Vanilla French Cruller Donut

        $2.75
      • Chocolate French Cruller Donut

        $2.75
      • Powdered Cruller Donut

        $2.75
      • Apple Turnover

        $3.15
      • Cherry Turnover

        $3.15
      • Blueberry Turnover

        $3.15
      • 1lb Assorted Rugelach

        Apricot, Chocolate and Raspberry
        $18.95
      • Prune Hamantaschen

        $3.95
      • Apricot Hamantaschen

        $3.95
      • Raspberry Hamantaschen

        $3.95
      • Crumb Cake

        $3.50
      • Crumb Bun

        $3.25
      • Marble Crumb Cake

        $3.50
      • Palmier (Elephant Ear Cookie)

        $4.00
      • Pretzel

        $4.25
      • Apple Strudel

        $15.95
      • Sugar Free Pastry

        Apple, Cherry, Blueberry
        $4.25
    • Breakfast Rings

      • Pecan Ring

        $14.95
      • Chocolate Horn Ring

        $14.95
      • Apple Horn Ring with Almonds

        $14.95
      • Cheese Ring

        $14.95
      • Almond Paste Ring with Icing

        $14.95
      • Fruit Ring

        $14.95
      • Crumb Ring

        $14.95
      • Blueberry Pudding Ring

        $14.95
      • Plain Pudding Ring

        $14.95
    • Brownies

      • Fudge Brownie

        $3.95
      • Oreo Brownie

        $4.50
      • Pecan Brownie

        $4.50
    • Bread

      • Salt Stick

        $0.95
      • Bagel

        Plain Sesame Poppy
        $1.50
      • Whole Wheat Bread

        $5.50
      • White Bread

        $5.50
      • Kaiser Roll

        Plain Sesame Poppy
        $0.95
      • Semolina

        $5.50
      • Rye Bread Large No Seeds

        $6.50
      • Rye Bread Large

        Seeds
        $6.50
      • Egg Rolls

        Plain Sesame Poppy
        $0.95
      • Pumpernickel Round

        $5.50
      • Italian Bread

        $2.95
      • French Baguette

        $3.50
      • Cinn Raisin Loaf

        $6.50
      • Challah Bread

        $6.50
      • Rustic Sourdough

        $6.50
    • Mousse Cakes

      Serves 5-7 people

      • Chocolate Mousse

        Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, a dark chocolate pencil and chocolate cake crumbs
        $33.95
      • Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse

        Hazelnut and chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, hazelnut whipped ganache, chocolate triangles and toasted hazelnuts
        $33.95
      • Vanilla Bean

        Light and airy vanilla bean mousse with a liquid vanilla sauce center set atop almond sponge cake lightly marinated in almond flavored syrup, finished with white chocolate triangles and crunchy wafers
        $32.95
      • Salted Caramel

        Creamy salted caramel mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, lightly coated in caramel ganache and finished with a chocolate disk, white chocolate circles & enclosed with white chocolate/cocoa
        $33.95
      • Tiramisu

        Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder and enclosed with lady fingers
        $33.95
      • Oreo Mousse

        Rich and creamy vanilla mousse loaded with chunks of oreo set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with vanilla whipped ganache and two oreo crusted cream puffs
        $33.95
      • Pistachio Raspberry Mousse

        Pistachio Mousse and raspberry crémeux set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, lightly coated in pistachio ganache finished with melted dollops of chocolate glaze, pistachio nuts and a fresh fruit berry
        $33.95
      • Red Velvet

        Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop a thin moist velvet cake, finished with white chocolate red velvet sprayed curls and velvet cake crumbs
        $33.95
      • Silk and Satan (Chocolate Mousse & NY Cheesecake)

        Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous new york style cheesecake set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with a nest of chocolate ganache, gold dusted lines and lathered in roasted almond slices
        $33.95
      • Raspberry Chocolate Mousse

        $33.95
      • Charlotte Royale Cake

        Vanilla Cake Bavarian Cream Filling White Ganache with Fruit on Top
        $33.95
    • Tarts

      • Strawberry Tart

        Strawberry compote with mascarpone cream cheese crémeux in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell topped with a vanilla shortbread biscuit & finished with dollops of strawberry jam and a fresh strawberry
        $5.25
      • Lemon Meringue Tart

        Citrusy lemon filling in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell, topped with fluffy vanilla meringue
        $5.25
      • Salted Caramel Chocolate Mousse Tart

        Rich chocolate ganache and a liquid salted caramel center in a buttery chocolate sablé tart shell, topped with chocolate mousse lightly coated in caramel ganache & chocolate crunchies and finished with a chocolate disk and cocoa powder
        $5.25
      • Vanilla Bean Tart

        Almond sponge cake lightly marinated in almond flavored syrup with a liquid vanilla sauce center in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell topped with light and airy vanilla bean mousse & finished with white chocolate triangles and crunchies
        $5.25
      • Apple Crumb Tart

        Fresh diced apples doused in soft cinnamon and sugar in a vanilla sablé tart shell topped & baked with golden buttery crumble
        $5.25
      • Fresh Fruit Tart

        Silky rich custard cream in a dark chocolate dipped buttery vanilla sablé tart topped with strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, blackberries, mandarin oranges and kiwi
        $5.25
      • Cappuccino Tart

        Luscious creamy cappuccino mousse infused with chocolate mousse set atop a thin soft chocolate cake
        $5.25
      • Blueberry Tart

        Refreshing vanilla mousse in a buttery vanilla sablé tart shell, topped with fresh blueberries
        $5.25
    • Pastries

      Serving 1-2 people

      • Raspberry Vanilla Cremeux

        $5.25
      • Chocolate Mousse

        $5.25
      • Charlotte Royale

        $5.25
      • New York Cheesecake with Strawberry

        $5.25
      • New York Cheesecake

        $4.95
      • Oreo Cheesecake

        $5.25
      • Raspberry Cheesecake

        $5.25
      • Red Velvet

        $5.25
      • Silk & Satan

        $5.25
      • Saint Honore'

        $5.25
      • Smores Cream Puff

        $5.25
      • Strawberry Shortcake

        $5.25
      • Black Forest

        $5.25
      • Crème Brulee

        $5.25
      • Key Lime Pie

        $5.25
    • Eclairs & Finger Pastries

      • Pistachio Finger Pastry

        Pistachio mousse and chocolate mousse dipped in crunchy pistachio wafer white chocolate set atop a buttery chocolate sablé cookie, finished with pistachio whipped ganache, pistachio nuts & fresh raspberries
        $5.25
      • Hazelnut Mousse Finger Pastry

        Hazelnut mousse dipped in crunchy hazelnut wafer chocolate set atop a buttery chocolate sablé cookie, finished with hazelnut whipped ganache
        $5.25
      • Oreo Mousse Éclair

        Rich and creamy vanilla mousse loaded with chunks of oreo set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with chocolate ganache and an oreo
        $5.25
      • Custard Éclair

        $4.95
      • Whipped Cream Éclair

        $4.95
      • Peanut Butter Chocolate Éclair

        $5.25
      • Cannoli Éclair

        $5.25
    • Buttercream Cakes

      Serving 5-7 people

      • Carrot Cake

        Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist layers of carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and extra lush cream cheese icing, a marzipan carrot and lathered in toasted coconut flakes
        $25.00
      • Mocha Cake

        Silky coffee buttercream set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake ever-so-lightly coated in apricot jam then soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee, finished with a dollop of coffee buttercream, chocolate espresso beans and lathered in toasted almond slices
        $25.00
      • Chocolate Shadow Cake

        Rich chocolate buttercream set atop thin layers of soft chocolate cake, finished with a top coat of dark chocolate ganache dripping down the side of the smooth chocolate buttercream icing, in turn presenting our look of a drip cake!
        $25.00
      • Vanilla Shadow Cake

        Ever-so-light buttercream set atop thin layers of soft vanilla cake, finished with a top coat of sweet white chocolate ganache dripping down the side of the silky buttercream icing in turn presenting our look of a drip cake!
        $25.00
      • Funfetti Cake

        Smooth and silky buttercream set atop thin layers of vanilla funfetti cake, baked golden and moist, finished with sweet white chocolate ganache dripping down the side of the silky buttercream icing and enclosed with funfetti dots
        $25.00
      • Chocolate Flower Cake

        Light and rich chocolate pudding set atop thin layers of moist chocolate cake, iced in creamy chocolate fudge, finished with three carefully handcrafted buttercream flowers, sprinkles and chocolate cake crumbs
        $25.00
      • Vanilla Flower Cake

        Alternating layers of rich chocolate buttercream and creamy vanilla buttercream set a top thin layers of moist vanilla cake, iced in vanilla buttercream, finished with three carefully handcrafted buttercream flowers, sprinkles and vanilla cake crumbs
        $25.00
      • Blackout Cake

        A combination of light chocolate pudding and rich chocolate fudge set atop thin layers of moist chocolate cake, iced in rich chocolate ganache then lathered in chocolate cake crumbs, finished with a dollop of chocolate buttercream and a glazed red cherry
        $25.00
      • Mini Birthday Cake Vanilla

        Vanilla Rich chocolate buttercream set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake, iced in smooth vanilla buttercream, finished with a carefully handcrafted buttercream flower, funfetti sprinkles and vanilla cake crumbs
        $14.95
      • Mini Birthday Cake Chocolate

        Rich chocolate buttercream set atop thin layers of soft chocolate cake, iced in chocolate buttercream, finished with a carefully handcrafted buttercream flower, funfetti sprinkles and chocolate cake crumbs
        $14.95
      • Seven Layer Cake

        Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with dark chocolate ganache and chocolate cake crumbs
        $23.95
      • Rainbow Log Cake

        Rainbow cake with raspberry jam filling Chocolate Fudge icing
        $23.95
    • Whipped Cream Cakes

      Our showcase 7” cakes are a delicious dessert and an excellent celebratory addition. To personalize any cake listed below, you may add a written inscription on either the cake or on a chocolate plaque. You will be delighted with our wide selection!

      • Tres Leche

        Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries
        $33.95
      • Strawberry Shortcake

        Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in strawberry syrup, finished with whipped cream icing and topped with fresh strawberries
        $25.00
      • Fresh Fruit Salad

        Silky smooth custard and pillowy-soft whipped cream set atop our specially Italian crafted airy cake sponge loaded with freshly chopped strawberries, bananas, peaches, and pineapples, finished with a lattice whipped cream deco and a glazed red cherry
        $25.00
      • Black Forest Cake

        A combination of whipped cream and chocolate whipped cream infused with sour black cherry filling found set in between two pieces of chocolate cake and one piece vanilla cake all soaked in sour black cherry syrup, finished with dark chocolate shavings, dollops of whipped cream, sour black cherries and lathered in chocolate cake crumbs
        $25.00
      • Brown Derby

        Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped bananas and strawberries set atop thin layers of chocolate cake, finished with a combination of whipped cream swirls and fresh strawberries and lathered in chocolate cake crumbs
        $25.00
      • Cannoli Cake

        Our signature cannoli filling set atop layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with a light coating of whipped Cream Icing and a crispy fried shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese with toasted almonds
        $25.00
    • Cheesecakes

      • New York Cheesecake

        $21.95
      • Strawberry Cheesecake

        $23.95
      • Oreo Cheesecake

        $23.95
      • Marble Cheesecake

        $23.95
      • Fudge Cheesecake

        $23.95
      • Mixed Berry Cheesecake

        $26.95
      • 10" Cheesecake

        $33.95
    • Cake Slices

      • Tiramisu Sliice

        Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream & dusted with cocoa powder
        $5.25
      • Napolean Slice

        Gorgeously golden crispy layers of puff pastry filled with rich custard pastry cream, finished with a glossy royal icing
        $5.25
      • Carrot Cake Slice

        Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and extra lush cream cheese icing & a marzipan carrot
        $5.25
      • Seven Layer Slice

        Rich chocolate buttercream sandwiched between seven layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with dark chocolate ganache
        $5.25
      • Lobster Tail Pastry

        Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious bavarian cream
        $5.25
      • Cannoli

        Our signature cannoli filling set atop layers of moist vanilla cake, enclosed by a thin ring of rainbow cookies, finished with a light coating of raspberry jam and a crispy fried shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese
        $3.95
      • Chocolate Cannoli

        Our signature cannoli filling set atop layers of moist vanilla cake, enclosed by a thin ring of rainbow cookies, finished with a light coating of raspberry jam and a crispy fried shell filled with sweet ricotta cheese
        $3.95
      • Philly Fluff (Cream Cheese Pound Cake)

        $16.95
    • Large Pies

      5-7 People

      • Key Lime Pie

        $24.95
      • Fruit Tart

        $32.95
      • Lemon Merengue Pie

        $22.95
      • Apple Pie

        $21.95
      • Blueberry Pie

        $21.95
      • Cherry Pie

        $21.95
      • Apple Crumb Pie

        $21.95
      • Fresh Blueberry Torte

        Vanilla Torte Vanilla Mousse Filling Fresh Blueberries Napoleon Crumbs
        $30.95
    • Small Pies

      • Tres Leche Bowl

        Vanilla Cake Soaked in three milks Custard and Caramel Filling Whipped Cream Icing with Fresh Fruit on top
        $8.95
      • Blueberry Pie

        $6.25
      • Apple Pie

        $6.25
      • Cherry Pie

        $6.25
      • Brownie Tart

        Brownie with Ganache icing in Tart Shell
        $6.25
      • Pecan Tart

        $6.25
    • Cookies by Weight

      • 1lb Rainbow Cookies

        $23.95
      • 1lb Pignoli Cookie

        $25.95
      • 1lb Lemon Drop Cookies

        $23.95
      • 1lb Anisette Cookies

        $19.95
      • 1lb Assorted Italian Biscotti

        $19.95
    • Cookie Trays

      • Cookie Tray

        One lb.
        $22.95
      • Assorted Biscotti

        One lb. Cranberry walnut, double chocolate, and pistachio.
        $22.95
      • Sugar Free Cookie Box

        One lb.
        $21.95
      • Cookie Tray

        $30.00
    • Gluten Free Items

      • Cheese Cake

        $5.25
      • Macaroons

        $2.50
      • Almond Horns

        $4.00
      • Creme Brulee

        $5.25
      • Gluten Free Cookie

        Chocolate Chip or Sugar
        $2.95
      • Gluten Free Muffin

        $4.25
    • Large Cookies

      • Rainbow Cookie

        $3.50
      • Chinese Cookie

        $3.50
      • Peanut Butter Cookie

        $3.50
      • Oatmeal Cookie

        $3.50
      • Chocolate Chip Cookie

        $3.50
      • Sugar Cookie

        $3.50
      • Black & White

        $4.95
      • M & M Cookie

        $4.95
      • Linzer Tart

        $4.95
    • Cake Pop

      • Rainbow Sprinkle Cake Pop

        $2.95
      • Chocolate Sprinkle Cake pop

        $2.95
      • Red Velvet Cake pop

        $2.95
      • Carrot Cake Pop

        $2.95
      • Oreo Cake Pop

        $2.95
    • Custom Order ( Cake, Bread, Cupcakes, Cookies, etc..)

      • Custom Order

        Please call the store first to place your order. Enter the invoice number in special instructions. (631) 424 -4034
        $5.00
    • Cupcakes

      • Classic Cupcake

        Vanilla or Chocolate Cupcake With Sprinkles and Cherry on Top
        $3.00
      • Carrot Cupcake

        $3.00
      • Red Velvet Cupcake

        $3.00
      • Flower Cupcake

        Vanilla or Chocolate Cupcake Pink or Purple Roses
        $3.00
      • Elmo Cupcake

        $3.00
      • Cookie Monster Cupcake

        $3.00
      • Minnie Mouse Cupcake

        $3.25
      • Mickey Mouse Cupcake

        $3.25
      • Hostess Cupcake

        $3.00
      • Oreo Cupcake

        $3.00