Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    79 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Every Day
    12:00 PM - 02:45 AM

    Penny Pub

    4.7 (108 ratings) • American • $$
      •  More info
    79 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Tap for hours, address, and more
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    $$ • American • Bar Food • Burgers • Family Friendly
    • Food
      • Side of Bacon
        $1.50
      • Add Chicken
        $3.00
      • Add Steak
        $4.00
      • Boneless Wings
        $12.00
      • Buffalo Chicken Tots
        $13.50
      • Carrots, Celery, Bleu Cheese
        $5.95
      • Cheesecake
        $8.95
      • Chicken Caesar Salad
        $13.95
      • Chicken Quesadilla
        $13.00
      • Chicken Tenders
        $10.50
      • Chicken Tenders Full Tray
        $75.00
      • Chipotle Chicken Sandwich
        $14.95
      • Churros Con Chocolate
        $8.95
      • Cinco De Mayo Tacos
        $6.00
      • Corn beef Quesadilla (1)
        $14.00
      • Corned Beef Eggrolls
        $11.00
      • Cottage Pie
        $13.00
      • Dublin Dip
        $16.95
      • Extra Cheese
        $1.00
      • Fish & Chips
        $14.95
      • Fried Pickles
        $10.50
      • Full Tray Wings
        $165.00
      • Grilled Chicken BLT
        $13.95
      • Half Tray Wings
        $84.00
      • Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese
        $11.50
      • Hotzarella Sticks
        $10.50
      • House Salad
        $10.50
      • Irish Grilled Cheese
        $11.95
      • Irish Nachos
        $13.50
      • Jalapeno Poppers
        $10.95
      • Late Night Fries
        $10.50
      • Mozzarella Sticks
        $10.50
      • Penny Pretzels
        $10.50
      • Penny Reuben
        $14.95
      • Quesadilla
        $9.95
      • Side of sauce
        $0.50
      • Soup
        $9.00
      • Steak Fries
        $7.00
      • The B.E.C.
        $12.95
      • The Penny Burger
        $12.95
      • Tots
        $8.00
      • Waffle Fries
        $8.00
      • Wings - Small (8)
        $12.00
      • Wings - Large (16)
        $22.00
    • N/A Beverages
      • Cherry Pepsi
        $2.50
      • Cranberry Juice
        $2.50
      • Diet Pepsi
        $2.50
      • Energy Drink
        $5.00
      • Ginger Ale
        $2.50
      • Orange Juice
        $3.00
      • Pepsi
        $2.50
      • Pink Lemonade
        $2.50
      • Seltzer
        $2.50
      • Seltzer With Cranberry Juice
        $2.50
      • Sierra Mist
        $2.50
      • Tonic
        $2.50