Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    The Good Steer
    Too far to deliver

    The Good Steer

    4.3
    (40)
      •  
    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday - Monday
    12:00 PM - 08:00 PM
    Tuesday
    Closed
    Wednesday - Saturday
    12:00 PM - 08:00 PM
    ¢¢ • American • Desserts • Family Friendly

    2810 Middle Country Rd, Lake Grove, NY 11755 • More


    • Picked for you

      • The Original Burger Supreme

        Over one third pound of lean, ground, and char broiled steer burger on a toasted Martin's seeded or unseeded roll. Garnished with onion rings with Idaho fries, coleslaw, and pickle chips.
        $12.95
      • Classic Cheese Dream Supreme Burger

        A steer burger topped with sliced tomato, cheese dream sauce and bacon strips. With Idaho fries, and French fried onion rings.
        $17.95
      • Malted Milk Shake

        Malted milkshake vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry.
        $7.50
      • Good Turkey Club

        A double-decker dandy of sliced roasted turkey, crisp bacon, sliced tomato, lettuce, and mayonnaise on sliced European white toast. Served with made-here red skin potato salad or Idaho fries and Idaho fries or sweet potato fries.
        $17.45
      • Fried Chicken Tenders

        Dipped in blue point lager batter and fried golden crunchy or breaded with buttermilk and herbs. With honey mustard or your choice of buffalo style with blue cheese, side brushed with hickory barbeque sauce garlic, butter, olive oil dressing, and parmesan sprinkle.
        $12.95
    • Specials

      • Double Cut Prime Rib

        A 20oz Cut of Slow Roasted, Tender, Juicy Steer Beef. Really "Good" served with your choice of side.
        $46.00
      • Buffalo Calamari

        Deep Fried Golden Brown and coated in a Spicy, Buttery Buffalo Sauce.
        $8.00
      • Garlic Calamari

        Deep Fried Golden Brown and tossed in an Olive Oil, Butter and Garlic Dressing with a Parmesan Sprinkle with made here Marinara for Dipping
        $8.00
      • Fried Calamari

        Deep Fried Golden Brown with made here Marinara for Dipping
        $8.00
    • Appetizers, Soups and Snacks

      • Garlic Fry Basket

        Idaho fries tossed with a garlic butter and olive oil dressing. Topped with a sprinkle of romano cheese.
        $7.95
      • Potato Skins

        Deep fried idaho potato skins or fries topped with cheese dream sauce and bacon bits. Sour cream on the side.
        $9.45
      • Fried Chicken Tenders

        Dipped in blue point lager batter and fried golden crunchy or breaded with buttermilk and herbs. With honey mustard or your choice of buffalo style with blue cheese, side brushed with hickory barbeque sauce garlic, butter, olive oil dressing, and parmesan sprinkle.
        $12.95
      • Rib Sampler

        Over one pound of pork spare ribs.
        $10.95
      • Rochester Wings

        Slowly smoked over hickory wood. Finished with a zesty sauce. Celery sticks, hot sauce, and made bleu cheese dressing.
        $10.95
      • Mozzarella Sticks

        Deep fried mozzarella cheese sticks. Served with marinara sauce.
        $8.95
      • Crispy Fried Buffalo Chicken Tender

        Tossed with a buttery hot sauce. Served with bleu cheese dressing and celery sticks.
        $12.95
      • Crispy Fried Garlic Chicken Tenders

        Coated with our Garlic, Butter and Olive Oil Dressing and a sprinkle of Romano Cheese!
        $12.95
      • You've Got Some Quesadilla

        A flour tortilla filled with three melted cheese. Creole sauce and sour cream on the side.
        $9.25
      • Nachos

        Tortilla chips with cream sauce, melted shredded cheeses, chopped peppers, red onion, diced tomatoes, olives, and jalapenos. Topped with creole sauce and sour cream.
        $11.95
      • It's Chili in Here

        Made with three beans and good steer beef. Topped with melted mozzarella or sour cream.
        $7.45
      • L.I. Clam Chowder Pint

        $7.95
      • Delicious French Onion Soup

        Baked with a French bread crouton and topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
        $6.95
      • L.I. Clam Chowder Quart

        $15.95
      • Garlic Calamari

        Deep Fried Golden Brown and tossed in an Olive Oil, Butter and Garlic Dressing with a Parmesan Sprinkle with made here Marinara for Dipping
        $8.00
      • Fried Calamari

        Deep Fried Golden Brown with made here Marinara for Dipping
        $8.00
      • Creme of Turkey Soup (Sunday Only) - Pint

        $7.95
      • Creme of Turkey Soup (Sunday Only) - Quart

        $15.95
    • Sandwiches and Wraps

      • Nashville Barbecue Beef Sandwich

        Pulled beef brisket, Hickory smoked overnight and piled high on a toasted roll or wrap with BBQ sauce and onion rings. Cheese dream sauce served on the side. Served with idaho fries.
        $14.45
      • Nashville BBQ Pork Sandwich

        Pulled Iowa pork Hickory smoked overnight and piled high on a toasted roll or wrap with BBQ sauce and onion rings. Cheese dream sauce served on the side. Served with idaho fries.
        $14.45
      • Nashville BBQ Chicken Sandwich

        Pulled light and dark meat chicken Hickory smoked overnight and piled high on a toasted roll or wrap with BBQ sauce and onion rings. Cheese dream sauce served on the side. Served with idaho fries.
        $14.45
      • Philly Cheese Steak Wrap

        Thinly sliced prime rib of beef and French fries, onion rings rolled in a warm wrap with melted Swiss cheese, and steak sauce. Served with idaho fries.
        $15.95
      • Grilled Deli Delight with Corned Beef or Turkey

        Sliced cured-here corned brisket. Layered with sauerkraut and Swiss cheese in a warm wrap or on grilled rye bread. Served with red skin potato salad or idaho fries. Sandwiches served with Idaho fries or sweet potato fries.
        $17.95
      • Open Faced Roasted Beef Croissant

        With potato and onion ring garnish. Served with French dip and Idaho fries.
        $17.95
      • Cheese and Turkey Melt Sandwich

        Sliced roasted turkey, grilled on a whole wheat bread with Swiss cheese, tomatoes, and Russian dressing. Served with Idaho fries.
        $14.25
      • Chicken Breast Sandwich

        Choose garlic and oil grilled or batter dipped deep fried chicken breast. Served on a toasted roll with lettuce, tomato, and Idaho fries.
        $13.95
      • Good Turkey Club

        A double-decker dandy of sliced roasted turkey, crisp bacon, sliced tomato, lettuce, and mayonnaise on sliced European white toast. Served with made-here red skin potato salad or Idaho fries and Idaho fries or sweet potato fries.
        $17.45
      • BQGC

        BBQ Grilled Cheese Your Choice of BBQ Pulled Beef Brisket, Pork Butt or light and dark meat Chicken on Grilled Thick Sliced White Bread with our Three Cheese Blend, Chopped Pickles and Onion Rings and Cole Slaw.
        $16.95
      • Grilled Deli Delight with Corned Turkey

        Sliced cured-here corned roasted turkey. Layered with sauerkraut and Swiss cheese in a warm wrap or on grilled rye bread. Served with red skin potato salad or idaho fries. Sandwiches served with Idaho fries or sweet potato fries.
        $17.95
    • Good Steer Burgers

      • The Original Burger Supreme

        Over one third pound of lean, ground, and char broiled steer burger on a toasted Martin's seeded or unseeded roll. Garnished with onion rings with Idaho fries, coleslaw, and pickle chips.
        $12.95
      • Twin Double Supreme Burger

        Twin burgers on a toasted English muffin. One Cheese Dream Sauce, the other with bacon. French fries and Onion Rings.
        $20.00
      • Classic Cheese Dream Supreme Burger

        A steer burger topped with sliced tomato, cheese dream sauce and bacon strips. With Idaho fries, and French fried onion rings.
        $17.95
    • Beef

      • Tastefully Tender

        Marinated sliced Skirt Steak on grilled garlic toast. Served with Cole Slaw side.
        $28.95
      • NY Shell Steak

        A 12oz boneless cut of dry aged USDA Choice or better Shell Steak, juicy flavorful Char-Broiled. Served with your choice of Potato or Rice.
        $31.95
      • Marinated NY Shell Steak

        1 12oz boneless cut of dry aged USDA Choice or better Shell Steak. Marinated, juicy and flavorful Char-Broiled. Served with your choice of Potato or Rice.
        $31.95
    • Chicken

      • Crunchy Chicken Tenders

        Choose from honey mustard dipping sauce or spice it up buffalo style. Served with Cole slaw and a side.
        $21.00
    • The Salad Side

      • Market Salad

        Mixed greens, crisp iceberg, romaine lettuce with diced tomato, raw red onion, shaved carrots, pepper rings, and garlic, herb, and oil croutons.
        $8.95
      • Caesar Salad

        Chilled romaine lettuce with made here Caesar dressing. Croutons and Parmesan sprinkle.
        $9.25
      • Fresh Chicken Salad Wrap

        White meat chicken salad, prepared with Hellman's mayonnaise, rolled in a wrap with diced tomatoes, chopped bacon, and lettuce. Served with sweet potato fries.
        $13.95
    • Good Sides

      • Basket of World Famous French Fried Onion Rings

        $6.95
      • Baked Idaho Potatoes

        with sour cream and butter
        $3.90
      • Baked Idaho Potatoes with Dream Sauce and Bacon Bits

        Loaded with Cheese Dream sauce and bacon bits.
        $4.95
      • Garlic Fry Basket

        Idaho fries tossed with seasoned garlic butter and olive oil dressing. Topped with a sprinkle of romano cheese.
        $6.95
      • Basket of Idaho Fries

        $6.95
      • Basket of Sweet Spuds

        Sweet potato fries.
        $6.25
      • Redskin Potato Salad

        $3.95
      • Fresh Side Caesar Salad

        $5.25
      • Baked Macaroni and Cheese

        Imported pasta baked in a crock with four cheese. Topped with seasoned breadcrumbs or plain.
        $5.65
      • Nashville Country Baked Beans

        $3.95
      • Fresh Steamed Broccoli

        $5.65
      • World Famous Coleslaw

        $3.95
      • Farmer Salad

        Choice of dressing.
        $4.50
      • Pitcher of Cheese Dream Sauce

        $3.45
      • Seasoned Steamed Rice

        $3.25
      • Mashed Potatoes

        $3.75
    • Beverages & Shakes

      • Poland Spring Water 16.9oz bottle

        16.9 oz.
        $2.55
      • Diet Coke 12oz Can

        $2.25
      • Coca-Cola®

        Coca-Cola Soda
        $2.25
      • Sprite®

        Lemon Lime Soda
        $2.25
      • Malted Milk Shake

        Malted milkshake vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry.
        $7.50
    • Desserts

      • Warm Wonderful Brownie

        $6.95
      • Rice Pudding

        $5.95
      • New York Style Cheesecake

        $7.25
      • Apple Crisp

        $6.95
      • Bag of Famous Amos Cookies

        $2.25
      • Over and Under Pound Cake with Hot Fudge and Ice Cream

        $6.95
      • Apple Pie

        A slice of Baked Here Apple Pie.
        $4.95
    • Good BarBeCue

      • Chicken and Ribs

        A Half Smoked Chicken and a Half Rack of BBQ Pork Ribs. Served with Cole Slaw and your choice of Potato, Rice or Baked Beans.
        $23.95
      • BBQ Pork Rib Dinner 1/2 Rack

        BBQ Pork Ribs, Smoked Low and Slow Overnight. Cut up and brushed with a zesty Hickory BBQ Sauce. Served with Cole Slaw and your choice of Potato or Rice or Baked Beans.
        $21.95
      • BBQ Pork Rib Dinner Full Rack

        BBQ Pork Ribs, Smoked Low and Slow Overnight. Cut up and brushed with a zesty Hickory BBQ Sauce. Served with Cole Slaw and your choice of Potato or Rice or Baked Beans.
        $28.95
      • BBQ 1/2 Chicken

        Smoked with Hickory and Apple Wood and brushed with BBQ Sauce. Served with Made Here Red Skin Potato Salad and Cole Slaw, Lettuce and Sliced Tomato.
        $21.00
    • 1/2 Trays - Party Sizes

      • 1/2 Tray of Onion Rings

        1/2 Tray of our World Famous Onion Rings
        $18.95
      • 1/2 Tray Idaho Fries

        $18.95
      • 1/2 Tray Garlic Fries

        Tossed with Garlic Dressing (FYI/Hack, they actually re-heat really "Good" with the Garlic Dressing!)
        $18.95
      • Cole Slaw - Quart (2lb)

        Almost World Famous! Made fresh right here. Same Recipe since 1957!
        $7.25
      • Red Skin Potato Salad - Quart (2lb)

        Made fresh right here with Hellman's Mayonnaise!
        $8.95
      • Macaroni and Cheese - 1/2 Tray

        Made Here with FOUR Cheeses. With or without Seasoned Bread Crumbs.
        $29.95
      • Chicken Wings - 1/2 Tray

        40 Wings in BBQ Sauce. Served with a pint of made here Blue Cheese Dressing, a half pint of Hot Sauce and Celery Sticks.
        $43.95
      • Ribs - 1/2 Tray

        About 4 racks, with BBQ Sauce
        $49.95
      • Breaded Chicken Tenders - 1/2 Tray

        Fresh Hand Breaded Chicken Tenderloins Fried Golden Brown
        $46.95
      • Batter Dipped Chicken Tenders - 1/2 Tray

        Chicken Tenderloins Dipped in our Blue Point Toasted Lager Beer Batter and Fried Golden Brown
        $46.95
      • Garlic Chicken Tenders - 1/2 Tray

        Fresh Chicken Tenderloins Fried Golden Brown Tossed in our Garlic and Oil, Butter and Herb Dressing with a sprinkle of Grated Parmesan Cheese.
        $46.95
      • Buffalo Chicken Tenders - 1/2 Tray

        Fresh Chicken Tenderloins Fried Golden Brown and tossed in our Buttery Spicy Buffalo Sauce.
        $46.95
      • Marinated Skirt Steak - 1/2 Tray

        15 3oz pieces of our Marinated Skirt Steak on a bed of our World Famous Onion Rings.
        $49.95
      • Dream Sauce - Pint

        A bigger side of Our Creamy Cheezy Dream Sauce
        $13.50
      • Dream Sauce - Quart

        A bigger side of Our Creamy Cheezy Dream Sauce
        $22.95
    • Just Chicken and Ribs

      • 1/2 Roasted Chicken

        A fresh Roasted Half Chicken on it's own. Can be ordered Hot and Ready or Cold to Heat and Eat. Order a few and keep them in the fridge!
        $8.95
      • 1/2 BarBeQue Chicken

        Our House Smoked Half Chicken Brushed with BarBeQue Sauce on it's own. Can be ordered Hot and Ready or Cold to Heat and Eat. Order a few and keep them in the fridge!
        $8.95
      • Full Rack of Pork Back Ribs

        A full cut rack (about 11 pieces) of our Slow Smoked Pork Ribs finished in a tangy BBQ Sauce
        $20.00
      • 1/2 Fried Chicken

        4 piece 1/2 Fried Chicken (Leg, Thigh, Breast & Wing)
        $8.95