Baked By Melissa - Garden City
4.9 x (110+) • American • Breakfast and Brunch • Desserts • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
630 Old Country Rd
Get it delivered to your door.
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday
11:00 AM - 6:30 PM
Monday - Thursday
10:00 AM - 7:30 PM
Friday - Saturday
10:00 AM - 8:30 PM
Cupcakes
- The Party Safe O.G. Cupcakes$41.00 • 100% (3)The Party Safe Original Greats, no nut flavors included*. Includes seven of our most-loved signature flavors, all iced by hand & topped with ingredients like Oreo® cookie pieces and semi-sweet chocolate chips, chosen to compliment each magical bite. *These cupcakes do not contain peanuts. However, all of our products are made in a bakery that processes peanuts, tree nuts, and other allergens. *All of our products are baked in a kitchen where nut ingredients are used.
Flavors Included
4 x Tie-Dye
4 x Cookie & Cream
4 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
4 x Red Velvet
3 x Cookie Dough
3 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
3 x Mint Cookie#3 most liked - Tie-Dye Cupcake 12-Pack$22.00Melissa's Tie-Dye cupcakes are utterly simple and hypnotizingly delicious. Try the famous vanilla tie-dye cupcake, iced with smooth and creamy vanilla icing and dusted with magical rainbow sugar crystals.
Flavors Included 12 x Tie Dye - Latest and Greatest Cupcakes$41.00 • 84% (13)Our best-seller! This cupcake pack is our go-to sampler for dessert lovers looking to try a little bit of everything. THE LATEST: our 3 seasonal cupcakes plus our monthly Mini of the Month! THE GREATEST: our 8 must-have original flavors!
Flavors Included
2 x Tie-Dye
2 x Cookie & Cream
2 x PB&J (contains nuts)
2 x Cookie Dough
2 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
2 x Red Velvet
2 x Mint Cookie
2 x Fudge Brownie
2 x Pumpkin Pie
2 x Chocolate Marshmallow
3 x Cookies & Milk#1 most liked - The O.G. Cupcakes$41.00 • 100% (7)Stick to the classics with our eight original cupcake flavors that have been around since day one. 25 cupcakes baked to fluffy perfection, hand-stuffed, iced and topped with magical ingredients like semi-sweet chocolate chips, minty cookie butter and real Oreo® cookies.
Flavors Included
4 x Tie-Dye
3 x Cookie & Cream
3 x Peanut Butter & Jelly
3 x Cookie Dough
3 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
3 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
3 x Red Velvet
3 x Mint Cookie - Fan Favorites 25 Pack$41.00Six exclusive flavors, handcrafted with love. This limited-edition 25-pack of cupcakes includes six beloved flavors including Cookie Butter Brownie, Blondie, and S’mores! Available for a limited time only.
Flavors Included
5 x Chocolate & Sprinkles
4 x Blondie
4 x Cookie Butter Brownie
4 x Electric Tie-Dye
4 x S'mores
4 x Vanilla & Sprinkles - All the Flavors 50 Pack$74.00Taste a bite of everything! This cupcake 50-Pack includes one Latest & Greatest 25-Pack (feat. the Mini of the Month, three seasonal flavors, and all eight OGs) and the limited-edition Fan Favorites 25-Pack with beloved flavors like Cookie Butter Brownie, Blondie, and S’mores!
Flavors Included
5 x Chocolate & Sprinkles
4 x Blondie
4 x Cookie Butter Brownie
4 x Electric Tie-Dye
4 x S'mores
4 x Vanilla & Sprinkles
2 x Tie-Dye
2 x Cookies & Cream
2 x PB&J (contains nuts)
2 x Cookie Dough
2 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
2 x Red Velvet
2 x Mint Cookie
2 x Fudge Brownie
2 x Pumpin Pie
2 x Chocolate Marshmallow
3 x Cookies & Milk#2 most liked - Party Safe OG 6-Pack$14.25All of our signature flavors, minus the peanuts: Tie Dye, Cookies and Cream, Cookie Dough, Triple Chocolate Fudge, Red Velvet, Mint Cookie, Chocolate Chip Pancake. Note, all cupcakes are made in a bakery that processes peanuts, tree nuts, and other allergens
- Fan Favorite 6-Pack$14.25Flavors Included
1 x Chocolate & Sprinkles
1 x Blondie
1 x Cookie Butter Brownie
1 x Electric Tie-Dye
1 x S'mores
1 x Vanilla & Sprinkles
Birthday
- Electric Tie Dye Layer Cake (Serv 8-12)$69.00*Stored frozen for transit. Please bring to room temp 1 hour before serving*
This cake will take your birthday celebration to the next level. Made with 3 layers of Melissa's signature Electric Vanilla Tie-Dye Cake, loads of vanilla buttercream icing, and tie-dye cake crumble topping. It's everything you know and love about Baked by Melissa, packed into a cake! Serving Suggestion: Serves 8 - 12 people. - Groovy Birthday Gift Box 25-Pack$51.00 • 100% (5)The sweetest birthday gifts come in small packages! And you have options—this gift is best if you're looking for more variety! Choose one 25-Pack from any of the below assortments to send in our groovy Happy Birthday gift box. BEST FOR GIFTING A SPECIALTY ASSORTMENT!
- Happy Birthday Cupcakes & Candles 25-Pack$49.95Wish them a Happy Birthday with cupcakes & candles! This sweet gift comes fully equipped with 25 handcrafted, mini cupcakes in 12 flavors and our ‘Happy Birthday’ candle set! Cupcake flavors include our ever-changing Mini of the Month, 3 seasonal cupcake flavors and all 8 of Melissa's Original Greats.
Flavors Included
2 x Tie-Dye
2 x Cookie & Cream
2 x PB&J (contains nuts)
2 x Cookie Dough
2 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
2 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
2 x Red Velvet
2 x Mint Cookie
2 x Fudge Brownie
2 x Pumpkin Pie
2 x Chocolate Marshmallow
3 x Cookies & Milk - Groovy Birthday Gift Box 50-Pack$84.00"Choose 2 assortment packs to fill your groovy birthday gift box! The best birthday present to send to celebrate any friend or family, near and far!
Gifts & Parties
- Party Safe Original Greats Cupcakes 100-Pack$139.00The sweetest way to celebrate every occasion, no nut flavors included*. Includes seven of our most-loved original flavors, that are fit for classrooms and birthday parties alike. Whether they’re craving a little Cookies & Cream or going for classic Tie-Dye, there are plenty more where that came from. *These cupcakes do not contain peanuts. However, all of our products are made in a bakery that processes peanuts, tree nuts, and other allergens.
Flavors Included
16 x Tie-Dye
16 x Cookie & Cream
16 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
16 x Red Velvet
16 x Cookie Dough
12 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
12 x Mint CookiePopular - Latest & Greatest Cupcakes 100-Pack$139.00A 100 bite-size cupcake sampler of 12 unique, hand-crafted cupcake flavors. Our most-loved originals, the ever-changing delicious Mini of the Month, and new seasonal flavors. The perfect party pack for your next celebration!
Flavors Included
8 x Tie-Dye
8 x Cookie & Cream
8 x PB&J (contains nuts)
8 x Cookie Dough
8 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
8 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
8 x Red Velvet
8 x Mint Cookie
8 x Fudge Brownie
8 x Pumpkin Pie
8 x Chocolate Marshmallow
12 x Cookies & Milk - All the Flavors 100 Pack Cupcakes$139.00One of everything on the menu, and then some. Stock up on 100 bite-size cupcakes in all 18 flavors on the menu! This party pack includes two Fan Favorite 25-Packs (including Cookie Butter Brownie, Blondie, and S’mores!), and two Latest & Greatest 25-Packs (with three seasonal flavors, all eight OGs, plus the Mini of the Month). PRO TIP: All our treats stay fresh in the freezer for up to two weeks, so stock up! Flavors Included
10 x Chocolate & Sprinkles
8 x Blondie
8 x Cookie Butter Brownie
8 x Electric Tie-Dye
8 x S'mores
8 x Vanilla & Sprinkles
4 x Tie-Dye
4 x Cookies & Cream
4 x PB&J (contains nuts)
4 x Cookie Dough
4 x Triple Chocolate Fudge
4 x Chocolate Chip Pancake
4 x Red Velvet
4 x Mint Cookie
4 x Fudge Brownie
4 x Pumpkin Pie
4 x Chocolate Marshmallow
6 x Milk & Cookies
Specialty
- Vegan Latest & Greatest$54.00Our best-selling cupcake assortment goes VEGAN! Curated by Melissa herself, the Vegan Latest & Greatest is your one-stop-shop for every vegan cupcake flavor on the menu. Each assortment includes 25 vegan cupcakes featuring six vegan cupcake flavors all handcrafted using the most delicious dairy-free vegan ingredients.
Flavors Included
5 x Vegan Strawberry
4 x Vegan Peanut Butter (contains nuts)
4 x Vegan Chocolate Vanilla Chip
4 x Vegan Triple Chocolate Chip
4 x Vegan Dark Chocolate Coconut
4 x Vegan Maple Cinnamon Bun
*Vegan cupcakes contain coconut. Peanut Butter flavor also contains peanuts.Popular - The Oh My Gluten Free Cupcakes$54.00Oh my, gluten free! Six wheatless, handcrafted gluten-free flavors that are fantastically rich and sweet. Now with NEW flavors, including Cookies & Cream, Marshmallow, Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Caramel.
All of our gluten free cupcakes & macarons are made in a separate facility.
Flavors Included
5 x Gluten Free Tie-Dye
4 x Gluten Free Red Velvet
4 x Gluten Free Marshmallow
4 x Gluten Free Cookies & Cream
4 x Gluten Free Cookie Dough
4 x Gluten Free Chocolate Caramel - The Mac 12-Pack$30.50Double-stuffed, bite-size macarons. Our six melt-in-your-mouth flavors are handcrafted with ingredients like dark chocolate, sea salt, hand-whipped Philadelphia cream cheese and more. PS. Macarons are made with almond flour, so they're naturally gluten free!
*All macarons are made with almond flour.
Flavors Included
2 x Sugar Cookie
2 x Double Chocolate
2 x Red Velvet
2 x Cookie Dough
2 x Snickerdoodle
2 x Salted Caramel