Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    440 Madison Ave, New Milford, NJ 07646
    Sunday
    5:30 AM - 2:30 PM
    Monday - Friday
    5:30 AM - 3:30 PM
    Saturday
    5:30 AM - 2:30 PM

    BorderLine Bagels

    4.9 (156 ratings) • Breakfast and Brunch • $
      •  More info
    440 Madison Ave, New Milford, NJ 07646
    Tap for hours, info, and more
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    $ • Breakfast and Brunch • Group Friendly
    • Recommended
      • Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
      • Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
      • Rainbow bagel with Funfetti cream cheese
      • Strawberry Smoothie
      • Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
        3 slices of ham , egg and american cheese
      • Taylor Ham and Cheese
        6 slices of trenton pork roll and double cheese
      • Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
        Breaded Chicken Cutlet
      • Fruit cup Cantalope
        1/2 container of fresh fruits
      • Rice Pudding
      • Fajita Panini
        Grilled chicken, salsa, hot&sweet peppers, pepper jack and cheddar cheese
      • Buffalo Panini
        Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce & blue cheese
      • Bagel with cream cheese
      • Buttered bagel
      • Big Breakfast platter
        2 eggs any style, choice of meat & home fries & toast
      • Steak, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
      • 2Eggs and Cheese Sandwich
        double egg and cheese
      • Double Egg Sandwich
      • Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
        sausage pattie, egg and american cheese
      • Hot Roast Beef with Horse radish sauce
        Toasted Onion Roll ,Grilled Roast Beef with fried onions & melted cheddar, horse radish sauce
      • Bobo
        Bacon Egg & Cheese with Home Fries
      • Turkey Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich
        Turkey Bacon , egg and american cheese
      • South West spicy Turkey Wrap
        Boar's head crack pepper turkey, chipotle mayo, Jalapenos, tomatoes, sauteed onions & pepper with coby jack cheese
      • Strawberry Banana Smoothie
        16oz fresh strawberry and banana smoothie
      • Super Value Deal #1
        Take a Break with crazy inflation Borderline Offers our customers with Super Deal
        Butter Bagel and Coffee
        Fresh Baked bagels with finest butter & Fresh Brewed Colombian Supreme Coffee
        Choice of fresh Daily baked Bagels and 12 oz Coffee
        "No Substitution or Changes can be made for this Deal"
    • Side Orders
        • Side Order Home Fries
          served in paper cup
        • Hash Brown
          golden crispy hash browns
        • French Fries
          straight Cut Idaho potato fries
        • side order Bacon
          6 strips of hotel grade bacon
        • Home Fries with onions & peppers
          Red skin Home fries (not spicy at all!!)
      • Omelettes
          • Western Omelette
            Diced ham, green bell pepper, and onion
          • Spinach Omelette
            3 eggs with baby spinach Add Parmesan cheese to perfect it
          • Meat and Cheese Omelette
            PICK YOUR OWN COMBINATION
          • CREATE YOUR OWN OMELETTES
            make your own unique omelette
        • Special
            • Tuna Melt
              Albacore tuna salad on a toasted rye bread with melted Cheddar cheese.
            • Protein Wrap
              4 egg whites, baby spinach, diced Boar's Head oven gold turkey, onion, and green pepper. whole wheat tortilla
            • Hungry Man
              3 eggs, ham, sausage, bacon, and American cheese on hero.
            • Breakfast Burrito
              3 eggs, onion, green pepper, home fries, and ham.
            • Super Value Deal #1
              Take a Break with crazy inflation Borderline Offers our customers with Super Deal
              Butter Bagel and Coffee
              Fresh Baked bagels with finest butter & Fresh Brewed Colombian Supreme Coffee
              Choice of fresh Daily baked Bagels and 12 oz Coffee
              "No Substitution or Changes can be made for this Deal"
          • Pastries
              • Cheese Danish
              • Crumb Cake
                choice of plain or marble
              • Cinnamon Roll
              • Muffins
                corn, blueberry, banana nut, cranberry nut, raisin oats,
              • Plain Pound Cake
              • Lemon Iced Loaf Pound Cake
              • Marble Pound Cake
              • Black & White Cookie
              • Chocolate Chip Cookie
              • Belgian Waffle
                230 Cal.
                Authentic Belgian waffle
            • Coffee & Tea
                • Strawberry Smoothie
                  16 oz Fresh made smoothies
                • Hot Coffee 12 oz
                  Fresh brewed colombian supreme
                • Hot Coffee 16 oz
                  Fresh brewed colombian supreme
                • Hot Coffee 20 oz
                  Fresh brewed colombian supreme
                • Coffee to go Box
                  serves up to 10 cups. 96oz of fresh brewed coffee with cups, lids, sweeteners and stir sticks.
                • Iced Coffee Small
                  Colombian Supreme Ice Coffee 16 oz
                • Iced Coffee Large
                  Colombian Supreme 24 oz ice coffee
                • Iced Hazelnut small
                  Java Joe's Hazelnut iced coffee
                • Iced Hazelnut Large
                  Java Joe's brand Hazelnut
                • Iced French Vanilla coffee Large
                  Java Joe brand French Vanilla
                • Iced French Vanilla coffee small
                • Iced Decaf Large
                • Iced Decaf small
                • Hot decaf coffee 20 oz
                  java Joe brand colombian
                • Hot decaf coffee 12 oz
                  java Joe brand colombian
                • Hot decaf coffee 16 oz
                  java Joe brand colombian
                • Hot Tea 20oz
                  choice of lipton, green tea, peppermint, mango passion, pomegranate raspberry
                • Hot Tea 12oz
                  choice of lipton, green tea, peppermint, mango passion, pomegranate raspberry
                • Hot Tea 16oz
                  choice of lipton, green tea, peppermint, mango passion, pomegranate raspberry , decaf lipton
                • Strawberry Banana Smoothie
                  16oz fresh strawberry and banana smoothie
                • Super Value Deal #1
                  Take a Break with crazy inflation Borderline Offers our customers with Super Deal
                  Butter Bagel and Coffee
                  Fresh Baked bagels with finest butter & Fresh Brewed Colombian Supreme Coffee
                  Choice of fresh Daily baked Bagels and 12 oz Coffee
                  "No Substitution or Changes can be made for this Deal"
              • Green Salads & Fruits
                  • Traditional Greek Salad
                    Feta cheese, black olive, Mixed field greens, diced cucumber, ripe tomatoes, green peppers, carrots, oregano leaves, oil&vinegar
                  • Chef Salad
                    Romaine lettuce, turkey, ham ,roast Beef, swiss, tomato
                  • Grilled Chicken Ceasar Salad
                    Romaine lettuce, Bermuda onions, carrots, green peppers, tomato, cucumber & ceasar dressing
                  • Garden Salad
                    Mix greens, tomato, onion, cucumber, green pepper and carrots
                  • Fruit Cup Pineapple
                    1/2 lb container of fresh fruits
                • Cream Cheese by pound
                    • Plain Cream Cheese By 1/2 LB
                      Philladelphia crm cheese
                    • Flavor Cream Cheese By 1/2 LB
                      vegetable, scallion, olive, strawberry, Cinnamon Walnut Raisin, Lox Spread, Cucumber & Dills
                    • Fresh sliced Nova by pound
                      nova lox by 1/4 pound each order
                    • CUCUMBER & DILL CREAM CHEESE BY 1/2 LB
                      SUMMER FLAVOR
                      CUCUMBER & DILL FLAVOR CRM CHEESE
                  • Beverages
                      • Sodas
                        20 oz bottle
                      • Diet Sodas
                        20 oz bottle
                      • Snapple
                        16oz bottle all natural
                      • Tropicana Juice
                        12 oz bottle
                      • Tropicana Family Size
                        1/2 Gallon Original 100% pure juice Bottle
                      • Nesquik chocolate
                        14oz bottle
                      • Yoohoo
                        16 oz bottle
                      • Naked Juice
                        100% natural 15.2 oz bottle
                      • Milk
                        Valley Farms
                      • Half&Half
                        Cream O land
                      • Bai
                        18 oz bottle 1g sugar no Artificial sweeteners
                      • Poland spring Waters
                      • FiJI Water
                        natural Artesian water
                      • Joe Tea
                        20 oz bottle
                      • Gatorade
                        20 oz bottle
                      • REd Bull
                        8.4 oz can
                      • Vitamin Water
                        16 oz bottle
                      • V8
                        Original 100% Vegetable Juice 12oz Bottle
                      • Monster Energy
                        16 oz Can
                      • Belvoir Organic Ginger Beer
                        8.4 oz
                      • Coco Well Coconut Water
                        11.2 oz
                      • Fentimans Ginger Beer
                        10 oz bottle
                      • Martinellis Apple Juice
                        10 oz bottle
                      • Strawberry Banana Smoothie
                        16oz fresh strawberry and banana smoothie
                      • Super Value Deal #1
                        Take a Break with crazy inflation Borderline Offers our customers with Super Deal
                        Butter Bagel and Coffee
                        Fresh Baked bagels with finest butter & Fresh Brewed Colombian Supreme Coffee
                        Choice of fresh Daily baked Bagels and 12 oz Coffee
                        "No Substitution or Changes can be made for this Deal"
                    • Chips
                        • Dirty Chips
                          2oz bags all natural kettle cooked with peanut oil chips
                        • Deep River
                          2 oz kettle boiled chips
                        • Wise Chips
                          1.25 - 1.5oz bags
                        • Popcorn Indiana kettlecorn
                          4 oz Bag kettle corn
                        • Sahale Mango tango almond
                          1.5 oz bage
                      • Classic Sandwiches
                          • Ham Sandwich
                            thinly sliced boar's head deluxe ham
                          • Turkey Sandwich
                            oven gold boar's head turkey
                          • Roast Beef Sandwich
                            Boar's Head Roast Beef
                          • Pastrami Sandwich
                            new york style boar's head pastrami
                          • Tuna Salad Sandwich
                            Albacore white tuna salad with Hellmann's Real mayonnaise
                          • Chicken Salad Sandwich
                            Diced Chicken breast with lite celery with lite mustard powder with mayonnaise
                          • Egg Salad Sandwich
                            Made with fresh boiled eggs and mayonnaise with lite white pepper
                          • Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
                            Breaded Chicken Cutlet
                          • Bologna Sandwich
                            Boar's Head Bologna
                          • Cheese Sandwich
                            pick your choice of American, Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone
                        • Borderline Famous Signature Sandwiches
                            • Chicken Quesadilla Sandwich (Best Seller)
                              Diced Grilled Chicken, onion, pepper, and Pepper Jack cheese with Special dressing.
                            • Atlantic City Wrap Sandwich
                              Melted Pepper-Jack cheese on Breaded chicken, lettuce, bacon, onion, tomato with Ranch
                            • Manhattan Wrap Sandwich
                              Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, roast red pepper, fresh mozzarella with honey mustard.
                            • Meditarranean Wrap Sandwich
                              Grilled chicken, black olive, roast red pepper, feta cheese, tomato, and Baby spinach with balsamic vinaigrette.
                            • Chicken Supreme Sandwich
                              Breaded chicken, crispy bacon, and Melted Cheddar cheese with Russian dressing on a Kaiser Roll
                            • Monte Cristo Sandwich
                              Grilled Boar's Head Turkey and Ham with Swiss Cheese on a Toasted Roll
                            • Italian Bomber Sandwich
                              Ham, pepperoni, salami, provolone, roast red pepper, red onion, lettuce, and tomato with oil and vinaigrette.
                            • Hot Roast Beef Special Sandwich
                              With fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers on toasted garlic Roll with honey dijon mustard
                            • Turkey Club Sandwich
                              Boar's Head Turkey with Crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato on 3 layered white toast.
                            • Hot Pastrami Sandwich
                              Grilled Pastrami and Swiss cheese on Rye Toast with Mustard
                            • B.L.T Sandwich
                              Stacks of Crispy Bacons and lettuce, tomatoes on a roll
                            • Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
                              Beef Sirloin thinly sliced steak with Sauteed Onions and Green bell peppers with Melted American Cheese
                          • Bagel with spreads
                            • Bagel with Butter
                            • Bagel with Cream Cheese
                            • Bagel with Flavor Cream Cheese
                              Vegetable, Scallion, Olive, Strawberry, Cinn-Walnut Raisin, Low Fat Veggie, Low Fat Scallion, cucumber & dills
                            • Fresh Nova and Cream Cheese
                              sliced Nova Scotia on a bagel with cream cheese
                            • Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly
                              creamy peanut butter & grape jelly
                            • Muffin
                              ALL YOGURT MUFFINS
                            • Muffin with Butter
                            • Mini Bagel with Butter
                            • Mini Bagel with Flavor Cream cheese
                            • Mini Bagel with Cream cheese
                            • CUCUMBER & DILL CREAM CHEESE BY 1/2 LB
                              SUMMER FLAVOR
                              CUCUMBER & DILL FLAVOR CRM CHEESE
                          • Bagels
                              • Plain Bagel
                              • Sesame Bagel
                              • Poppy Bagel
                              • Everything Bagel
                              • Onion Bagel
                              • Garlic Bagel
                              • Pretzel Salt Bagel
                              • Cinn-Raisin Bagel
                              • Blue Berry Bagel
                              • Whole Wheat Bagel
                              • Egg Bagel
                              • Pumper-Nickel Bagel
                              • Rye Bagel
                              • Multi Grain Bagel
                              • Flagels Bagel
                              • Mini Bagel
                              • Rainbow Bagel
                              • Low Carb Bagel
                                Choice of Plain, poppy, sesame, everything
                            • Breakfast for the Group
                                • Borderline Bagel Platter
                                  15 assorted bagels, 6 assorted pastries with 2 tubs of cream cheese and butter. serves up to 20
                                • Bakers Dozen Value Pack
                                  includes 2 tubs of 1/2 lb cream cheese
                                • Baker's Dozen
                                  Please choose 13 bagels from the following flavors: plain, whole wheat, whole wheat everything, sesame, salt, poppy seed, onion or cinnamon raisin
                                • Breakstone Whipped Butter
                                  All natural Salted
                                • Philladelphia Original
                                  8oz Cream cheese spread
                                • Temptee
                                  NY whipped Cream cheese
                                • Coffee to go Box
                                  serves up to 10 cups. 96oz of fresh brewed coffee with cups, lids, sweeteners and stir sticks.

                              Frequently asked questions

                              What is the address of BorderLine Bagels in New Milford?

                              BorderLine Bagels is located at: 440 Madison Ave , New Milford

                              Is the menu for BorderLine Bagels available online?

                              Yes, you can access the menu for BorderLine Bagels online on Postmates. Follow the link to see the full menu available for delivery and pickup.

                              What are the most popular items on the BorderLine Bagels menu?

                              The most ordered items from BorderLine Bagels are: Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich, Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich, Low Carb Bagel.

                              Does BorderLine Bagels offer delivery in New Milford?

                              Yes, BorderLine Bagels offers delivery in New Milford via Postmates. Enter your delivery address to see if you are within the BorderLine Bagels delivery radius, then place your order.

                              Can I get free delivery from BorderLine Bagels?

                              Delivery fees for BorderLine Bagels vary. Just enter your delivery address to see the delivery fee for your location. You could always get free delivery from BorderLine Bagels with Postmates Unlimited.

                              Can I pick up my order from BorderLine Bagels?

                              Postmates offers pickup from many restaurants in your city. To see if you can pick up your order from BorderLine Bagels, add items to your cart and look for the ‘pickup’ option at checkout.

                              Can I schedule a delivery order from BorderLine Bagels?

                              Some restaurants on Postmates allow you to schedule a delivery to show up at your location when you want it. At checkout, look for the option to select a delivery time. If it’s there, that means you can schedule your delivery from BorderLine Bagels.