Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    BorderLine Bagels
    Too far to deliver

    BorderLine Bagels

    4.8
    (309)
      •  
    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday
    05:30 AM - 02:30 PM
    Monday - Friday
    05:30 AM - 03:30 PM
    Saturday
    05:30 AM - 02:30 PM

    440 Madison Ave, New Milford, NJ 07646 • More


    • Picked for you

      • Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        3 crispy bacon, egg and American Cheese No cheese order, we will add extra strip of bacon
        $5.25
      • Bagel with Cream Cheese

        with our store whipped cream cheese
        $2.85
      • Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        3 slices of taylor ham ,egg and american cheese
        $5.25
      • side order Bacon

        6 strips of hotel grade bacon
        $3.99
      • Fresh Nova and Cream Cheese

        sliced Nova Scotia on a bagel with cream cheese
        $9.99
    • Recommended

      • Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        3 slices of ham , egg and american cheese
        $5.25
      • Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        3 crispy bacon, egg and American Cheese No cheese order, we will add extra strip of bacon
        $5.25
      • Taylor Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        3 slices of taylor ham ,egg and american cheese
        $5.25
      • Taylor Ham and Cheese

        6 slices of trenton pork roll and double cheese
        $5.50
      • Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

        Breaded Chicken Cutlet
        $5.99
      • Fruit cup Cantalope

        1/2 container of fresh fruits
        $3.75
      • Rice Pudding

        $2.99
      • Fajita Panini

        Grilled chicken, salsa, hot&sweet peppers, pepper jack and cheddar cheese
        $7.99
      • Buffalo Panini

        Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce & blue cheese
        $7.99
      • Bagel with cream cheese

        $2.85
      • Buttered bagel

        $2.50
      • Big Breakfast platter

        2 eggs any style, choice of meat & home fries & toast
        $9.99
      • Parmigian panini

        Breaded chicken, marinara sauce & fresh mozzarella
        $7.99
      • Steak, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        $6.00
      • 2Eggs and Cheese Sandwich

        double egg and cheese
        $4.00
      • Double Egg Sandwich

        $3.25
      • Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        sausage pattie, egg and american cheese
        $5.25
      • Italiano Panini

        Grilled chicken, sweet peppers, basil pesto sauce & fresh mozzarella
        $7.99
      • Rainbow bagel with Funfetti cream cheese

        Kids favorite
        $4.00
      • Hot Roast Beef with Horse radish sauce

        Toasted Onion Roll ,Grilled Roast Beef with fried onions & melted cheddar, horse radish sauce
        $7.99
      • Bobo

        Bacon Egg & Cheese with Home Fries
        $6.50
      • Turkey Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich

        Turkey Bacon , egg and american cheese
        $5.75
      • Soup of The Day

        12 oz Fresh made Soup of the Day Lentil, Chicken Noodle, Cream Potato, New England Clam Chowder, Split Pea, Cream of Broccoli
        $3.95
      • South West spicy Turkey Wrap

        Boar's head crack pepper turkey, chipotle mayo, Jalapenos, tomatoes, sauteed onions & pepper with coby jack cheese
        $7.99
    • Side Orders

      • Side Order Home Fries

        served in paper cup
        $2.99
      • Hash Brown

        golden crispy hash browns
        $1.50
      • French Fries

        straight Cut Idaho potato fries
        $3.50
      • side order Bacon

        6 strips of hotel grade bacon
        $3.99
      • Home Fries with onions & peppers

        Red skin Home fries (not spicy at all!!)
        $2.99
    • Omelettes

      • Western Omelette

        Diced ham, green bell pepper, and onion
        $6.50
      • Spinach Omelette

        3 eggs with baby spinach Add Parmesan cheese to perfect it
        $6.50
      • Meat and Cheese Omelette

        PICK YOUR OWN COMBINATION
        $7.50
      • CREATE YOUR OWN OMELETTES

        make your own unique omelette
        $8.99
    • Special

      • Protein Wrap

        4 egg whites, baby spinach, diced Boar's Head oven gold turkey, onion, and green pepper. whole wheat tortilla
        $7.50
      • Hungry Man

        3 eggs, ham, sausage, bacon, and American cheese on hero.
        $7.50
      • Breakfast Burrito

        3 eggs, onion, green pepper, home fries, and ham.
        $7.50
      • Tuna Melt

        Albacore tuna salad on a toasted rye bread with melted Cheddar cheese.
        $6.99
      • Cheese Burger Deluxe

        1/2 lb beef patty, American cheese, lettuce & tomato, burmuda onions ,ketchop & mayo serve with french fries
        $7.99
    • Pastries

      • Cheese Danish

        $2.50
      • Crumb Cake

        choice of plain or marble
        $2.50
      • Cinnamon Roll

        $2.50
      • Muffins

        corn, blueberry, banana nut, cranberry nut, raisin oats,
        $2.50
      • Plain Pound Cake

        $2.50
      • Lemon Iced Loaf Pound Cake

        $2.50
      • Marble Pound Cake

        $2.50
      • Black & White Cookie

        $2.50
      • Chocolate Chip Cookie

        $2.50
    • Coffee & Tea

      • Hot Coffee 12 oz

        Fresh brewed colombian supreme
        $1.75
      • Hot Coffee 16 oz

        Fresh brewed colombian supreme
        $2.00
      • Hot Coffee 20 oz

        Fresh brewed colombian supreme
        $2.25
      • Coffee to go Box

        serves up to 10 cups. 96oz of fresh brewed coffee with cups, lids, sweeteners and stir sticks.
        $18.99
      • Iced Coffee Small

        Colombian Supreme Ice Coffee 16 oz
        $2.50
      • Iced Coffee Large

        Colombian Supreme 24 oz ice coffee
        $2.99
      • Iced Hazelnut small

        Java Joe's Hazelnut iced coffee
        $2.75
      • Iced Hazelnut Large

        Java Joe's brand Hazelnut
        $3.50
      • Iced French Vanilla coffee Large

        Java Joe brand French Vanilla
        $3.50
      • Iced French Vanilla coffee small

        $2.75
      • Iced Decaf Large

        $3.25
      • Iced Decaf small

        $2.50
      • Hot decaf coffee 20 oz

        java Joe brand colombian
        $2.25
      • Hot decaf coffee 12 oz

        java Joe brand colombian
        $1.75
      • Hot decaf coffee 16 oz

        java Joe brand colombian
        $2.00
      • Hot Tea 20oz

        choice of lipton, green tea, peppermint, mango passion, pomegranate raspberry
        $2.25
      • Hot Tea 12oz

        choice of lipton, green tea, peppermint, mango passion, pomegranate raspberry
        $1.75
      • Hot Tea 16oz

        choice of lipton, green tea, peppermint, mango passion, pomegranate raspberry , decaf lipton
        $1.99
    • Green Salads & Fruits

      • Traditional Greek Salad

        Feta cheese, black olive, Mixed field greens, diced cucumber, ripe tomatoes, green peppers, carrots, oregano leaves, oil&vinegar
        $7.99
      • Chef Salad

        Romaine lettuce, turkey, ham ,roast Beef, swiss, tomato
        $7.99
      • Grilled Chicken Ceasar Salad

        Romaine lettuce, Bermuda onions, carrots, green peppers, tomato, cucumber & ceasar dressing
        $7.99
      • Garden Salad

        Mix greens, tomato, onion, cucumber, green pepper and carrots
        $4.99
      • Fruit cup HoneyDew

        1/2 container of fresh fruits
        $3.75
      • Fruit Cup Pineapple

        1/2 lb container of fresh fruits
        $3.75
    • Cream Cheese by pound

      • Plain Cream Cheese By 1/2 LB

        Philladelphia crm cheese
        $4.00
      • Flavor Cream Cheese By 1/2 LB

        vegetable, scallion, olive, strawberry, Cinnamon Walnut Raisin, Lox Spread
        $4.99
      • Fresh sliced Nova by pound

        nova lox by 1/4 pound each order
        $12.00
    • Beverages

      • Sodas

        20 oz bottle
        $2.25
      • Diet Sodas

        20 oz bottle
        $2.25
      • Snapple

        16oz bottle all natural
        $2.25
      • Tropicana Juice

        12 oz bottle
        $2.49
      • Tropicana Family Size

        1/2 Gallon Original 100% pure juice Bottle
        $6.99
      • Nesquik chocolate

        14oz bottle
        $2.75
      • Yoohoo

        16 oz bottle
        $2.25
      • Naked Juice

        100% natural 15.2 oz bottle
        $4.50
      • Milk

        Valley Farms
        $2.00
      • Half&Half

        Cream O land
        $2.85
      • Bai

        18 oz bottle 1g sugar no Artificial sweeteners
        $2.75
      • Poland spring Waters

        $1.25
      • FiJI Water

        natural Artesian water
        $1.99
      • Joe Tea

        20 oz bottle
        $2.50
      • Gatorade

        20 oz bottle
        $2.25
      • REd Bull

        8.4 oz can
        $3.00
      • Vitamin Water

        16 oz bottle
        $2.50
      • V8

        Original 100% Vegetable Juice 12oz Bottle
        $2.50
      • Monster Energy

        16 oz Can
        $3.50
      • Belvoir Organic Ginger Beer

        8.4 oz
        $3.50
      • Coco Well Coconut Water

        11.2 oz
        $2.50
      • Fentimans Ginger Beer

        10 oz bottle
        $2.50
      • Martinellis Apple Juice

        10 oz bottle
        $2.50
    • Chips

      • Dirty Chips

        2oz bags all natural kettle cooked with peanut oil chips
        $2.00
      • Deep River

        2 oz kettle boiled chips
        $2.00
      • Wise Chips

        1.25 - 1.5oz bags
        $1.25
      • Popcorn Indiana kettlecorn

        4 oz Bag kettle corn
        $3.50
      • Sahale Mango tango almond

        1.5 oz bage
        $2.50
    • Classic Sandwiches

      • Ham Sandwich

        thinly sliced boar's head deluxe ham
        $5.99
      • Turkey Sandwich

        oven gold boar's head turkey
        $5.99
      • Roast Beef Sandwich

        Boar's Head Roast Beef
        $6.25
      • Pastrami Sandwich

        new york style boar's head pastrami
        $6.49
      • Tuna Salad Sandwich

        Albacore white tuna salad with Hellmann's Real mayonnaise
        $5.99
      • Chicken Salad Sandwich

        Diced Chicken breast with lite celery with lite mustard powder with mayonnaise
        $5.99
      • Egg Salad Sandwich

        Made with fresh boiled eggs and mayonnaise with lite white pepper
        $4.99
      • Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

        Breaded Chicken Cutlet
        $5.99
      • Bologna Sandwich

        Boar's Head Bologna
        $4.99
      • Cheese Sandwich

        pick your choice of American, Cheddar, Swiss, Provolone
        $4.25
    • Borderline Famous Signature Sandwiches

      • Atlantic City Wrap Sandwich

        Melted Pepper-Jack cheese on Breaded chicken, lettuce, bacon, onion, tomato with Ranch
        $7.99
      • Manhattan Wrap Sandwich

        Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, roast red pepper, fresh mozzarella with honey mustard.
        $7.99
      • Meditarranean Wrap Sandwich

        Grilled chicken, black olive, roast red pepper, feta cheese, tomato, and Baby spinach with balsamic vinaigrette.
        $7.99
      • Chicken Quesadilla Sandwich (Best Seller)

        Diced Grilled Chicken, onion, pepper, and Pepper Jack cheese with Special dressing.
        $7.99
      • Chicken Supreme Sandwich

        Breaded chicken, crispy bacon, and Melted Cheddar cheese with Russian dressing on a Kaiser Roll
        $7.99
      • Monte Cristo Sandwich

        Grilled Boar's Head Turkey and Ham with Swiss Cheese on a Toasted Roll
        $7.99
      • Chicken Parmesan Hero

        Chicken cutlet and mozzarella cheese with marinara sauce
        $8.99
      • Italian Bomber Sandwich

        Ham, pepperoni, salami, provolone, roast red pepper, red onion, lettuce, and tomato with oil and vinaigrette.
        $8.99
      • Hot Roast Beef Special Sandwich

        With fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers on toasted garlic Roll with honey dijon mustard
        $7.99
      • Turkey Club Sandwich

        Boar's Head Turkey with Crispy bacon, lettuce, and tomato on 3 layered white toast.
        $7.99
      • Hot Pastrami Sandwich

        Grilled Pastrami and Swiss cheese on Rye Toast with Mustard
        $7.99
      • B.L.T Sandwich

        Stacks of Crispy Bacons and lettuce, tomatoes on a roll
        $6.99
      • Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich

        Beef Sirloin thinly sliced steak with Sauteed Onions and Green bell peppers with Melted American Cheese
        $8.99
    • Bagel with spreads

      • Bagel with Butter

        $2.50
      • Bagel with Cream Cheese

        with our store whipped cream cheese
        $2.85
      • Bagel with Flavor Cream Cheese

        Vegetable, Scallion, Olive, Strawberry, Cinn-Walnut Raisin, Low Fat Veggie, Low Fat Scallion
        $3.75
      • Fresh Nova and Cream Cheese

        sliced Nova Scotia on a bagel with cream cheese
        $9.99
      • Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly

        creamy peanut butter & grape jelly
        $2.75
      • Muffin

        ALL YOGURT MUFFINS
        $2.75
      • Muffin with Butter

        $3.50
      • Mini Bagel with Butter

        $1.50
      • Mini Bagel with Flavor Cream cheese

        $2.50
      • Mini Bagel with Cream cheese

        $1.75
    • Bagels

      • Plain Bagel

        $1.00
      • Sesame Bagel

        $1.00
      • Poppy Bagel

        $1.00
      • Everything Bagel

        $1.00
      • Onion Bagel

        $1.00
      • Garlic Bagel

        $1.00
      • Pretzel Salt Bagel

        $1.00
      • Cinn-Raisin Bagel

        $1.00
      • Blue Berry Bagel

        $1.00
      • Whole Wheat Bagel

        $1.00
      • Egg Bagel

        $1.00
      • Pumper-Nickel Bagel

        $1.00
      • Rye Bagel

        $1.00
      • Multi Grain Bagel

        $1.00
      • Flagels Bagel

        $1.50
      • Mini Bagel

        $0.70
      • Rainbow Bagel

        $1.50
      • Low Carb Bagel

        Choice of Plain, poppy, sesame, everything
        $1.75
    • Breakfast for the Group

      • Borderline Bagel Platter

        15 assorted bagels, 6 assorted pastries with 2 tubs of cream cheese and butter. serves up to 20
        $45.00
      • Bakers Dozen Value Pack

        includes 2 tubs of 1/2 lb cream cheese
        $18.00
      • Baker's Dozen

        Please choose 13 bagels from the following flavors: plain, whole wheat, whole wheat everything, sesame, salt, poppy seed, onion or cinnamon raisin
        $12.00
      • Breakstone Whipped Butter

        All natural Salted
        $5.25
      • Philladelphia Original

        8oz Cream cheese spread
        $4.50
      • Temptee

        NY whipped Cream cheese
        $4.50
      • Coffee to go Box

        serves up to 10 cups. 96oz of fresh brewed coffee with cups, lids, sweeteners and stir sticks.
        $18.99