Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    217 Jericho Turnpike, Floral Park, NY 11001
    Every Day
    07:00 AM - 07:30 PMDessert
    07:00 AM - 07:00 PMCustom Order

    Buttercooky Bakery (217 Jericho Turnpike)

    4.7 (200+ ratings) • Breakfast and Brunch • $
      •  More info
    217 Jericho Turnpike, Floral Park, NY 11001
    Tap for hours, info, and more
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    $ • Breakfast and Brunch • Desserts • Bakery • Group Friendly
    • Picked for you
      • Tres Leche
      • Strawberry Shortcake
      • Tart - Fresh Fruit
      • Carrot Cake - Individual Slice
      • Cannoli
    • Custom Order
        • Custom Order
          YOU MUST CALL THE STORE FIRST FOR THIS OPTION! Enter your name/order info in special instructions
      • Showcase Cakes
        • Flower Celebration Cake - Chocolate
        • Flower Celebration Cake - Vanilla
        • Strawberry Shortcake
        • Carrot Cake
        • Fruit Salad Cake
        • Cannoli Cake
        • 7 Layer Cake - Small
        • 7 Layer Cake - Individual Slice
        • Black Forest
        • Mocha Cake
        • Shadow Cake - Chocolate
        • Shadow Cake - Vanilla
        • NY Cheesecake Strawberry - Individual Size
        • Large Fruit Torte
        • Candles
        • 7-Layer Cake Large
          Seven thin layers of Vanilla Cake alternating with a thin layer of Chocolate Buttercream and topped with hard chocolate icing
        • Cheesecake - Italian
        • Cheesecake - NY Style 7"
        • Cheesecake - NY Style 7" topped with Strawberries
        • Cheesecake - NY Style 10"
      • Cupcakes & Cake Pops
        • Chocolate Cake Pop
        • Vanilla Cake Pop
        • Red Velvet Cake Pop
        • Oreo Cake Pop
        • Chocolate Classic Cupcake
        • Carrot Cake Cupcake
        • Seasonal/Holiday Theme Cupcake Vanilla
          images are representations and may vary from what is actually available
        • Candles
        • Vanilla Classic Cupcake
          decoration may vary
        • Red Velvet Cupcake
      • Cookies by the Pound
        • Assorted Butter Cookies (on a platter and wrapped in cello)
      • Mousse Cakes
        • Chocolate Mousse Cake
        • Chocolate Tiramisu
        • Traditional Tiramisu
        • Tiramisu - Individual Slice
        • French Strawberry Shortcake
        • Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse
        • Pistachio & Raspberry Mousse
        • Red Velvet
        • Oreo Mousse
        • Large Fruit Torte
        • Tres Leches - Individual Size
        • Tres Leche
        • Candles
        • Silk & Satin
          Layers of Chocolate Cake, NY Cheesecake and Chocolate Mousse with a Chocolate Ganache Icing
      • Individual Pastries & Slices
        • Tart - Cappuccino
        • Tart - Fresh Fruit
        • Tart - Lemon Meringue
        • French Pastry - Salted Caramel
        • French Pastry - Creme Brulee
        • Eclair - Whipped Cream
        • Eclair - Custard
        • Carrot Cake - Individual Slice
        • 7 Layer Cake - Individual Slice
        • Tiramisu - Individual Slice
        • Napoleon - Individual Slice
        • NY Cheesecake Strawberry - Individual Size
        • Tres Leches - Individual Size
        • Lobster Tail
        • Cannoli
        • Tart - Blueberry
        • French Pastry - Vanilla Bean Mousse
        • Crumb Cake - Individual Slice
        • Strawberry Shortcake - Individual Size
      • Jumbo Cookies & Sweets
        • Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
        • Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie
        • Chocolate Chip Cookie
        • Linzer Tart
        • Brownie
        • Brownie - Oreo
        • French Macaroons - Dozen
          We handpick 12 of our most popular flavors
          flavors may vary from image
        • Classic Chocolate Cupcake
        • Classic Vanilla Cupcake
        • Black/White Cookie
        • Philly Fluff
      • Breakfast Pastries
        • Danish - Cheese
        • Danish - Cheese with Almonds
        • Danish - Pecan
        • Danish - Pecan Iced
        • Danish - Apricot
        • Danish - Prune
        • Apple Turnover - Small
        • Apple Turnover - Large
        • Blueberry Turnover - Small
        • Cherry Crumb Turnover - Small
        • Peach Boat
        • Muffin - Blueberry
        • Muffin - Corn
        • Muffin - Bran
        • Croissant - Plain
        • Croissant - Almond
        • Croissant - Chocolate
        • Croissant - Nutella
        • Cigar - Chocolate
        • Cigar - Raspberry
        • Apple Boat
        • Muffin - Apple Crumb
        • Crumb Cake - Individual
        • Elephant Ear