Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    75 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Sunday
    12:05 PM - 8:45 PMMenu
    12:30 PM - 8:30 PMCoyles Homemade Ice Cream
    Monday
    3:05 PM - 8:45 PMMenu
    3:30 PM - 8:30 PMCoyles Homemade Ice Cream
    Tuesday - Thursday
    1:05 PM - 8:45 PMMenu
    1:16 PM - 9:00 PMCoyles Homemade Ice Cream
    Friday
    1:05 PM - 9:44 PMMenu
    1:30 PM - 9:30 PMCoyles Homemade Ice Cream
    Saturday
    12:05 PM - 9:45 PMMenu
    12:30 PM - 9:30 PMCoyles Homemade Ice Cream

    Coyles Homemade Ice Cream

    4.8 (40 ratings) • Dessert:Other • $$
      •  More info
    75 Howells Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    $$ • Dessert: Other • Ice Cream + Frozen Yogurt • Comfort Food • Family Meals
    • Picked for you

      • Banana Boat
      • S'mores treats (box of 4)
        Our Homemade S'mores Ice Cream sandwiched between two Graham Crackers then dipped in Belgian Chocolate.
      • Mini Sundaes (box of 5)
        4 oz. cups of Vanilla and Chocolate ice cream swirl garnished with chocolate syrup, Rainbow Sprinkles, and a cherry!
    • Mains

    • Family Treats

      • Cannoli (box of 5)
        Cannoli shells filled with our Homemade Cannoli ice cream, garnished with chocolate chips.
      • Mini Sundaes (box of 5)
        4 oz. cups of Vanilla and Chocolate ice cream swirl garnished with chocolate syrup, Rainbow Sprinkles, and a cherry!
      • S'mores treats (box of 4)
        Our Homemade S'mores Ice Cream sandwiched between two Graham Crackers then dipped in Belgian Chocolate.
      • Caramel Crisp
        Vanilla Ice Cream sandwiched between two Rice Krispies Treats drizzled with Caramel.
    • Ice Cream Cakes

      • Banana Split Cakes - 8"
        Our most famous cake with 20 of our most famous flavors together with a layer of sliced bananas and our Gourmet Chocolate Crunch. Every slice will reveal a variety of flavors for you and your guests to enjoy!
      • Regular Ice Cream Cakes (Mini)
        Coyles Homemade Vanilla & Chocolate Ice Creams with our Gourmet Chocolate Crunch Center.
      • Vanilla/Chocolate Ice Cream Cake 8"
        8" Serves 8-12
      • Regular Ice Cream Cake - 10"
        10" Serves 15-18
      • Regular Ice Cream Cake - Small Sheet
        Small Sheet Serves 20+
      • Mississippi Mud Cake - 8"
        Homemade Coffee Ice Cream Layered with Chocolate Crunch, Oreo Cookies and Hot Fudge with a Fudge Top and Oreo Crust.
        8" Serves 8-12
      • Sticky Finger Cake - 8"
        Our Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream filled with Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Chocolate Crunch and Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. It's also topped with Hot Fudge and Peanut Butter!
      • Chocolate Raspberry Chip - 8"
        Our Home Chocolate Raspberry Ice Cream layered with Chocolate Chunks and Raspberry Puree on a Homemade Oreo Crust!
      • Chocolate Overload 8"
        Our Homemade Chocolate and Oreo Ice Creams filled with a layer of Pound Cake, Chocolate Chunks and Belgian Chocolate Sauce on a Homemade Oreo Crust.
      • Oreo Cake - 8"
        Our Premium Oreo Ice Cream filled with Broken Oreo Cookies on top of a Homemade Oreo Crust!
        Popular
      • Blend of the Best - 8"
        Our Homemade Oreo and Chocolate Raspberry Chip Ice Creams filled with a layer of Pound Cake, Chocolate Chunks and Raspberry Sauce in a Homemade Oreo Crust.
      • Strawberry Shortcake - 8"
        Our Homemade Strawberry and Vanilla Ice Creams layered with Pound Cake and Strawberry Puree.
    • Specialty Sundaes

      • Sticky Finger Sundae
        Peanut buttersauce, hot fudge, crunch, and reeses peanut butter cups.
        Popular
      • Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae
        Ice cream layered with warm brownies and hot fudge.
      • Fire Islander
        Mint chip, oreo, and cherry vanilla ice creams layered with hot fudge, marshmallow sauce, and crunch.
      • Dirty Banana
        Banana oreo and oreo ice creams layered with sliced banana and hot fudge.
      • Blackout of '65
        Brownie nut fudge, rocky road, and chocolate ice creams layered with hot fudge and black cherries.
      • Heavenly Ash
        Heath bar, vanilla ice creams, layered with marshmallow, and crunchies.
      • Alex's Candy Land
        Cotton candy and crazy vanilla ice creams.
      • Mama K's PB and J
        Vanilla chip and peanut butter oreo ice creams layered with raspberry and peanut butter sauce.
      • Blend of the Best
        Oreo and chocolate ice creams layered with raspberry sauce and chocolate chips.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the address of Coyles Homemade Ice Cream in Bay Shore?

    Coyles Homemade Ice Cream is located at: 75 Howells Rd , Bay Shore

    Is the menu for Coyles Homemade Ice Cream available online?

    Yes, you can access the menu for Coyles Homemade Ice Cream online on Postmates. Follow the link to see the full menu available for delivery and pickup.

    What are the most popular items on the Coyles Homemade Ice Cream menu?

    The most ordered items from Coyles Homemade Ice Cream are: Chubby Chipper Ice Cream Sandwiches (6 pk), Mississippi Mud Cake - 8”, Sticky Finger Cake - 8”.

    Does Coyles Homemade Ice Cream offer delivery in Bay Shore?

    Yes, Coyles Homemade Ice Cream offers delivery in Bay Shore via Postmates. Enter your delivery address to see if you are within the Coyles Homemade Ice Cream delivery radius, then place your order.

    Can I get free delivery from Coyles Homemade Ice Cream?

    Delivery fees for Coyles Homemade Ice Cream vary. Just enter your delivery address to see the delivery fee for your location. You could always get free delivery from Coyles Homemade Ice Cream with Postmates Unlimited.

    Can I pick up my order from Coyles Homemade Ice Cream?

    Postmates offers pickup from many restaurants in your city. To see if you can pick up your order from Coyles Homemade Ice Cream, add items to your cart and look for the ‘pickup’ option at checkout.

    Can I schedule a delivery order from Coyles Homemade Ice Cream?

    Some restaurants on Postmates allow you to schedule a delivery to show up at your location when you want it. At checkout, look for the option to select a delivery time. If it’s there, that means you can schedule your delivery from Coyles Homemade Ice Cream.