Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
    Every Day
    11:00 AM - 09:45 PM

    Middle island pizza

    4.6 (15 ratings) • Pizza • $
      •  More info
    586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
    Tap for hours, info, and more
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    $ • Pizza • Pasta • Seafood
    • Picked for you
        • Neapolitan Pizza
          Hand-tossed round crust.
        • Meatball Parmigiana Hero
        • Grandma Pizza
          Thin crust, pan-cooked topped with chunky tomato sauce, fresh garlic, oregano, mozzarella, and Romano cheese.
        • Sicilian Pizza
          Pan cooked thick crust.
        • Pasta Bolognese
          Hearty meat sauce.
      • Antipasti
          • Arancini Di Casa
            Our homemade rice ball filled with ground beef, peas, sauce, and cheese, topped with pomodoro sauce and warm ricotta mozzarella sticks.
          • Mozzarella Sticks
            6 battered mozzarella sticks served with pomodoro sauce.
          • Napoleon Eggplant Tower
            Breaded eggplant, sauteed baby spinach, ricotta, pomodoro sauce, and melted mozzarella.
          • Baked Clams
            6 whole top neck clams and seasoned bread crumbs.
          • Italian Chicken Wings
            6 wings in a choice of buffalo, BBQ, teriyaki, Francese, marsala, garlic parmesan, or plain.
          • Chicken Finger Platter
            3 chicken fingers, French fries, and honey mustard dipping sauce.
          • Mussels
            Prince Edward Island mussels served in a choice of San Marzano plum tomato sauce, a spicy marinara, or white wine sauce.
          • Fried Calamari
          • Buffalo Style Calamari
            Served with blue cheese dipping sauce.
          • Zucchini Sticks
            Thick cut zucchini breaded and golden fried served with pomodoro sauce.
          • Stuffed Mushrooms
            5 stuffed with crab meat broiled in garlic white wine sauce.
          • Italian Breaded Shrimp
            5 shrimp served with pomodoro dipping sauce.
          • Broccoli And Cheese Fritters
            8 mixture of Cheddar cheese, broccoli, bacon, battered, and crispy fried.
          • Hot Antipasto (2)
            2 baked clams, two shrimp, two stuffed mushrooms, and two eggplant rollatini.
          • Garlic Bread with Melted Mozzarella Cheese
            Italian bread topped with butter, garlic, herbs, and melted mozzarella.
          • Asparagi Fritti
            3 asparagus rolled with lightly smoked ham and provolone cheese then breaded and pan-fried. Served with pomodoro dipping sauce.
          • French Fries
            Large order crispy French fries.
          • Mini Fried Cheese Ravioli (8)
            Served with pomodoro dipping sauce.
          • small side of sauce
        • Soups
            • Pasta Fagioli Soup
              Ditalini pasta, cannellini beans, garlic, crushed tomato, basil, and tomato broth.
            • Vegetable Minestrone Soup
              Assorted chopped vegetables, red beans, and tomato broth.
            • Seafood Bisque Soup
              Shrimp, scallops, and crab meat in a light sherry bisque.
            • Escarole and White Bean Soup
              Escarole, white cannellini beans, and roasted garlic broth.
            • Baby Tortellini and Spinach Soup
              Baby tortellini, baby spinach, and chicken broth.
            • Chicken Noodle Soup
              Chicken, assorted chopped vegetables, and chicken broth.
          • Insalate
              • Italian House Salad
                Blend of chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce. Grape tomato, red onions, cucumbers, roasted peppers, and Kalamata olives. Served with our house tomato vinaigrette dressing.
              • Greek Salad
                Crumbled feta cheese, blend of chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce. Grape tomato, red onions, cucumbers, roasted peppers, and Kalamata olives. Served with our house tomato vinaigrette dressing.
              • Cold Antipasto Salad
                Chopped provolone, salami, ham, pepperoni, blend of chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce, grape tomato, red onions, cucumbers, roasted peppers, and Kalamata olives. Served with our house tomato vinaigrette dressing.
              • Grilled Chicken Salad
                Chopped marinated grilled chicken, blend of chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce, grape tomato, and red onions. Cucumbers, roasted peppers, and Kalamata olives. Served with our house tomato vinaigrette dressing.
              • Crispy Chicken Salad
                Crispy chicken. Shredded mozzarella cheese, blend of chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce, grape tomato. Red onions, cucumbers, roasted peppers, and Kalamata olives. Served with our house tomato vinaigrette dressing.
              • Spinach Gorgonzola Salad
                Baby spinach, grape tomato, red onions, sun-dried cranberries, Gorgonzola, candied pecans, and raspberry vinaigrette.
              • Buffalo Chicken Salad
                Chopped romaine, celery sticks, topped with buffalo style chicken, served with blue cheese dressing.
              • Tri-Color Salad (Large)
                Mixed greens, grape tomato, cucumbers, Kalamata olives, onions, roasted peppers, Asiago cheese, and balsamic vinaigrette.
              • Monterey Salad
                Fresh baby spinach, toffee pecans, mandarin oranges, strawberries, shredded Monterey cheese, and balsamic dressing.
              • Caprese Salad
                Fresh sliced tomato, fresh-made mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze, and pesto drizzle.
              • Caesar Salad
                Chopped romaine, homestyle croutons, shaved Romano cheese, and Caesar dressing.
            • Heros
                • Chicken Parmigiana Hero
                • Meatball Parmigiana Hero
                • Sausage Parmigiana Hero
                • Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Hero
                • Shrimp Parmigiana Hero
                • Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
                • Sausage and Meatball Parmigiana Hero
                • Sausage and Peppers Parmigiana Hero
                • Philly Cheesesteak Hero
                • Sausage and Egg Hero
                • Peppers and Egg Hero
                • Potato and Egg Hero
              • Pasta
                  • Pasta Alla Vodka
                    Shallots garlic plum tomato, cream, and pecorino Romano cheese.
                  • Pasta Con Vongole
                    Red or white sauce. Whole and chopped baby clams in either a garlic wine Borodino or in San Marzano plum tomato sauce.
                  • Pasta en Rico
                    Shrimp and asparagus, pink chardonnay cream sauce.
                  • Pasta Scarpariello
                    Chicken sausage. Bell peppers, onions, potatoes, and rosemary brown sauce.
                  • Pasta Leonardo
                    Shrimp, Portobello mushrooms, and peas in a flame-roasted pepper cream sauce.
                  • Pasta Bolognese
                    Hearty meat sauce.
                  • Pasta Alfredo
                    Creamy alfredo cheese sauce.
                  • Pasta Alla Grappa
                    Grilled chicken, mushrooms, scallions, shallots, and brown grappa sauce.
                  • Pasta Alla Mama
                    Rigatoni pasta, sliced sausage, meatballs, and warm ricotta.
                  • Pasta Abruzzi
                    Sweet Italian sausage, roasted red peppers, onions, and garlic plum tomato sauce.
                  • Pasta Solari
                    Shrimp. Scallops, flame-roasted red peppers in a creamy seafood pink sauce.
                  • Venetian Pasta
                    Grilled chicken, spinach, mushrooms, Parmigiano Reggiano cheese, and creamy pink sauce Santorini.
                  • Pasta Santorini
                    Shrimp. Baby spinach, creamy plum tomato sauce, and crumbled feta cheese.
                  • Shrimp Marinara
                    Shrimp in a sweet marinara or spicy plum (Fra Diavolo) tomato sauce.
                  • Calamari Marinara
                    Tender calamari in a sweet marinara or (Fra Diavolo) spicy plum tomato sauce.
                  • Prince Edward Island Mussels
                    Served in choice of garlic white wine Borodino, marinara, spicy plum tomato sauce.
                  • Zuppa Di Pesce
                    Calamari, clams, mussels, scallops, shrimps in a plum tomato sauce or garlic white wine sauce.
                  • Pasta Carbonara
                    Robust cream sauce made with pancetta, mushrooms, peas, onions, and Romano cheese.
                  • Pasta Pomodoro
                    Our slow-cooked Italian tomato sauce add meatballs or sliced Italian sweet sausage.
                  • Pasta Primavera
                    Zucchini, squash, carrots, mushrooms, onions, choice of roasted garlic and olive oil, marinara, or creamy alfredo sauce.
                  • Pasta Madeira
                    Grilled chicken, shallots, scallions, cubed fresh mozzarella, and Madeira wine brown sauce.
                  • Pasta Casalinga
                    Grilled chicken, broccoli rabe, sun-dried tomato, Kalamata olives, roasted garlic, and olive oil sauce.
                  • Pasta Alfano
                    Sauteed escarole, grilled chicken, sun-dried tomato, cannellini beans, roasted garlic, and olive oil Borodino.
                  • Pasta Melanzane
                    Sauteed cubed fresh eggplant in a plum tomato sauce and fresh ricotta.
                  • Pasta Palermo
                    Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, Kalamata olive, sun-dried tomato, roasted garlic, and olive oil sauce.
                  • Pasta Rustico
                    Escarole, sausage, cannellini beans, roasted garlic, and olive oil sauce.
                  • Pasta E Gamberi
                    Shrimp, broccoli and sun-dried tomato, roasted garlic, and olive oil sauce.
                  • Pasta Polcioffo
                    Grilled chicken, artichoke hearts, diced tomato, and lemon white wine sauce.
                • Pasta Al Forno
                    • Baked Pasta Campagnola
                      Penne pasta, pomodoro sauce with a hearty blend of ground beef, peas, mushrooms, and ricotta with melted mozzarella.
                    • Baked Pasta Fantasia
                    • Gnocchi
                    • Manicotti
                      3 ricotta free pasta crepes, pomodoro sauce, and melted mozzarella.
                    • Baked Ziti
                    • Baked Cheese Ravioli
                      Jumbo cheese filled ravine pecorino sauce and melted mozzarella.
                    • Stuffed Rigatoni
                      Za rigatoni pasta stuffed with ricotta creamy meat sauce and melted mozzarella stuffed rigatoni Fiorentina.
                  • Pizza
                      • Neapolitan Pizza
                        Hand-tossed round crust.
                      • Sicilian Pizza
                        Pan cooked thick crust.
                      • Crust Cauliflower Crust 12" Pizza
                        Cauliflower crust.
                      • Grandma Pizza
                        Thin crust, pan-cooked topped with chunky tomato sauce, fresh garlic, oregano, mozzarella, and Romano cheese.
                      • 10" Gluten-Free Pizza
                        Gluten-free pizza crust.
                      • 12" Ultra-Thin Pizza
                        Ultra-thin pizza crust available in whole wheat or white.
                      • topping
                        pizza topping
                    • Gourmet Pizza
                        • Everything Pizza
                          Sausage, meatball, pepperoni, peppers, onions, mushrooms, and extra cheese.
                        • Buffalo Chicken Pizza
                          Chicken, buffalo sauce, mozzarella, Cheddar, and ranch drizzle.
                        • BBQ Chicken Pizza
                          Chicken, BBQ sauce, mozzarella, Cheddar, and BBQ drizzle.
                        • Chicken Ranch Pizza
                          Chicken, bacon, tomato, ranch dressing, mozzarella, Cheddar, and ranch drizzle.
                        • Chicken Parm Pizza
                          Chicken, pomodoro sauce, and mozzarella.
                        • Chicken Marsala Pizza
                          Chicken, mushrooms, marsala wine, demi-glaze, and mozzarella.
                        • Chicken Francese Pizza
                          Chicken, lemon, white wine, and mozzarella.
                        • Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
                          Sliced Philly meat, sauteed onions, peppers, mushrooms, and mozzarella.
                        • Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza
                          Chicken, pink vodka sauce, and mozzarella.
                        • Crispino Pizza
                          Thin pan-cooked, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, balsamic glaze, and basil pesto.
                        • Tomato Basil Pizza
                          Crushed plum tomato, fresh garlic, basil, and mozzarella.
                        • Salad Pizza
                          Blend romaine and iceberg lettuce, grape tomato, cucumber, red onion, roasted peppers, olives, shredded carrots, and mozzarella.
                        • Vegetable Supreme
                          Spinach, broccoli, onions, peppers, mushrooms, eggplant, marinara sauce, and mozzarella.
                        • Meat Supreme
                          Pepperoni, meatballs, sausage, bacon, tomato sauce, and mozzarella.
                        • Mama Mia Pizza
                          Grilled chicken, tomato, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic drizzle, and fresh basil.
                        • Baked Penne Pizza
                          Penne pasta, pomodoro sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella.
                        • Margarita Pizza
                          Margarita fresh mozzarella cheese. Plum tomato sauce and fresh basil.
                        • White Pizza
                          Seasoned ricotta, garlic-infused oil, mozzarella, and pecorino Romano cheese.
                      • Pizzette
                          • Seafood Oreganata Pizzette
                            Shrimp and clams in our famous scampi sauce topped with fresh mozzarella and seasoned bread crumbs.
                          • Margherita Pizzette
                            Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, and olive oil.
                          • Fra Diavolo Pizzette
                            Fra Diavolo plum tomato sauce, crumbled sausage, cherry peppers, and fresh mozzarella.
                          • Veggietini Pizzette
                            Plum tomato sauce, spinach, broccoli, onions, mushrooms, roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella.
                          • Quattro Stagioni Pizzette
                            Plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, topped with 1/4 artichokes, 1/4 olives, 1/4 prosciutto, and 1/4 mushrooms.
                          • Alla Melezana Pizzette
                            Tomato sauce, breaded eggplant, ricotta, and fresh mozzarella.
                          • Rustica Pizzette
                            Plum tomato sauce, pepperoni, olives, diced tomato, roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella.
                          • Bianco Pizzette
                            Creamy ricotta, pecorino Romano, fresh mozzarella, and garlic-infused olive oil.
                          • Porto Pollo Pizzette
                            Plum tomato sauce, pesto, grilled chicken, Portobello mushroom, and fresh mozzarella.
                          • Arthur Avenue Pizzette
                            Arthur red or white, broccoli rabe, Italian sausage, fresh mozzarella.
                        • Al Fresco
                            • Chicken Caesar
                              Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, shaved Romano cheese, and Caesar dressing.
                            • Chicken Club
                              Breaded or grilled chicken, provolone cheese. Lettuce and tomato. Served with house tomato vinaigrette.
                            • Chicken Portobello
                              Panko chicken cutlet, Portobello mushrooms. Melted mozzarella, tomato, and roasted peppers. Served with balsamic vinaigrette.
                            • Chicken Roma
                              Grilled chicken, sweet marinara sauce, melted fresh mozzarella, and pesto drizzle.
                            • Eggplant Mediterraneo
                              Breaded eggplant, sliced tomato, and melted mozzarella. Served with pomodoro dipping sauce.
                            • Chicken Balsamico
                              Grilled balsamic chicken, sliced tomato, red onions, fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, and balsamic vinaigrette.
                            • Italiano
                              Salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone, and lettuce. Tomato, onions, and roasted peppers. Served with house tomato vinaigrette.
                            • Portobello Delight
                              Portobello mushroom, tomato, roasted peppers, melted mozzarella, and pesto drizzle. Served with balsamic vinaigrette.
                            • Mamma Mia
                              Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, and roasted peppers. Served with house tomato vinaigrette.
                            • Little Italy
                              Thin sliced imported prosciutto, sliced tomato, fresh mozzarella, and basil. Served with balsamic vinaigrette.
                            • Parma
                              Thin sliced prosciutto Cotto smoked ham and melted mozzarella. Sauteed onions and peppers. Served with pomodoro dipping.
                            • Turkey Bruschetta
                              Turkey, sliced tomato, red onions, basil, and melted provolone. Served with pesto aioli.
                            • Americana
                              Sliced ham, turkey, bacon, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, red onion, and honey mustard.
                            • Turkey Club
                              Sliced turkey, sharp provolone, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
                            • Bella Donna
                              Breaded eggplant, broccoli rabe, and sliced tomato. Fresh mozzarella with balsamic vinaigrette.
                            • Milano
                              Panko crusted chicken, sliced tomato, red onions. Fresh mozzarella, mixed greens, and pesto aioli.
                            • Gallo
                              Breaded chicken cutlet, sliced tomato, ricotta cheese, pesto drizzle, and mixed greens.
                            • Flank Steak
                              Grilled marinated flank steak, onions, and mushrooms, and melted provolone. Served with teriyaki dipping sauce.
                          • Specialty Items
                              • Rice Ball
                                Seasoned rice with ground beef, peas, sauce, and cheese in the middle.
                              • Parm Roll
                                Tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.
                              • Eggplant Roll
                                Breaded eggplant, ricotta, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
                              • Sausage, Pepper, and Onion Roll
                                Sliced sausage, sauteed with peppers and onions, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
                              • Calzone
                                With seasoned ricotta and mozzarella cheese.
                              • Sausage and Pepperoni Stromboli
                                Sliced sweet Italian sausage, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese.
                              • Spinach and Broccoli Roll
                                Chopped spinach, fresh broccoli florets, and mozzarella cheese.
                              • Capellini Cake
                                Capellini pasta, ricotta, mozzarella, and pecorino Romano cheese. Served with pomodoro sauce.
                              • Spinach and Ricotta Roll
                                Chopped spinach, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese.
                              • Buffalo Knots
                                Our homemade garlic knots tossed with our signature buffalo sauce.
                              • Italian Sliders
                                Choice of meatball parm, chicken parm, fresh mozzarella, and tomato.
                              • Cinna Knots
                                Deep-fried pizza dough covered in sugar and cinnamon drizzled with chocolate syrup.
                              • Garlic Knots
                            • Eggplant
                                • Eggplant Parmigiana
                                  Breaded eggplant, pomodoro sauce, and melted mozzarella.
                                • Eggplant Rollatini
                                  2 eggplant rolled with ricotta, mozzarella cheese, pomodoro sauce, and melted mozzarella.
                                • Eggplant Napoletano
                                  Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and plum tomato sauce.
                              • Chicken
                                  • Chicken Parmigiana
                                    Breaded chicken, pomodoro sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
                                  • Chicken Francese
                                    Egg battered chicken and lemon white wine sauce.
                                  • Chicken Bella Napoli
                                    Chicken Francese style, spinach, pomodorini, chardonnay wine sauce, and melted mozzarella.
                                  • Chicken Marsala
                                    Chicken, mushrooms, shallots, scallions, and marsala demi-glaze.
                                  • Chicken Pizzaiola
                                    Chicken peppers, onions, fresh mushrooms, and sherry wine plum tomato sauce.
                                  • Chicken Milanese
                                    Panko-crusted pan-fried chicken cutlets topped with mesclun greens, grape tomato, red onion, and feta cheese.
                                  • Chicken Cutlet Carbonara
                                    Danko crusted chicken cutlets, Parmigiano cream sauce, pancetta, and peas.
                                  • Chicken Saltimbocca
                                    Chicken. Imported prosciutto, spinach, melted mozzarella, and Madeira wine sauce.
                                  • Chicken Picatta
                                    Chicken, artichoke, roasted peppers, and lemon white wine sauce.
                                  • Chicken Capri
                                    Balsamic marinated grilled chicken, fresh sliced mozzarella, and tomato drizzled with pesto and balsamic reduction, garnished with fire-roasted peppers.
                                  • Chicken Verdi
                                    Franchise style chicken, broccoli florets, melted mozzarella, and lemon white wine sauce.
                                  • Grilled Chicken Romano
                                    Grilled chicken, sweet marinara sauce, melted fresh mozzarella, and pesto drizzle.
                                  • Grilled Chicken Primavera
                                    Balsamic marinated grilled chicken topped with sauteed vegetables.
                                  • Grilled Balsamic Chicken
                                    Balsamic marinated grilled chicken served over broccoli rabe.
                                  • Grilled Chicken Semifreddo
                                    Balsamic marinated grilled chicken topped with chilled grape tomato salad.
                                  • Grilled Chicken Verdura
                                    Balsamic marinated grilled chicken topped with sauteed baby spinach, broccoli, and mushrooms.
                                • Veal
                                    • Veal Parmigiana
                                      Veal cutlet, pomodoro sauce, and mozzarella.
                                    • Veal Marsala
                                      Medallions of veal, mushrooms, scallions, scallops, and marsala demi-glaze.
                                    • Veal Pizzaiola
                                      Medallions of veal, peppers, onions, fresh mushrooms, and sherry plum tomato sauce.
                                    • Veal Saltimbocca
                                      Medallions of veal, imported prosciutto, spinach, melted mozzarella, and Madeira wine sauce.
                                    • Veal Francese
                                      Medallions of veal and lemon white wine sauce.
                                  • Seafood
                                      • Salmon Saporito
                                        Broiled Norwegian salmon, light creamy pink sauce, asparagus, and grape tomatoes.
                                      • Salmon Crostino
                                        Baked panko crusted salmon served over baby spinach and light creamy dill sauce.
                                      • Shrimp Parmigiana
                                        Breaded shrimp, pomodoro sauce, and mozzarella.
                                      • Shrimp Scampi
                                        Jumbo shrimp and julienned zucchini and garlic white wine sauce.
                                      • Shrimp Davinci
                                        Breaded shrimp, marsala demi-glaze, spinach, and melted mozzarella.
                                      • Shrimp and Scallop Oreganata
                                        Jumbo shrimp, bay scallops, garlic chardonnay sauce, and seasoned bread crumbs.
                                      • Shrimp Monachina
                                        Breaded jumbo shrimp, Portobello mushrooms, marsala wine sauce, and melted mozzarella.
                                    • Sides
                                        • Escarole and Beans
                                        • Broccoli Rabe
                                        • Sauteed Baby Spinach
                                        • Sauteed Broccoli Florets
                                        • Side of Meatballs (3)
                                        • Side of Sausage (3)
                                        • Side of Roasted Potatoes
                                        • Side of Chicken
                                          2 chicken cutlets grilled or fried.
                                        • Side of Mixed Vegetables
                                          Zucchini, squash, carrots, spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, garlic, and olive oil.
                                        • Side of Pasta
                                          Choice of pasta in butter or pomodoro sauce.