Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    331 Ny-25a, Mount Sinai, NY 11766
    Sunday
    07:00 AM - 02:00 PMMenu
    Monday - Friday
    07:00 AM - 02:00 PMMenu
    07:00 AM - 02:15 PMMenu
    Saturday
    07:00 AM - 02:00 PMMenu

    MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY

    4.6 (86 ratings) • Breakfast and Brunch • $
      •  More info
    331 Ny-25a, Mount Sinai, NY 11766
    Tap for hours, info, and more
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    $ • Breakfast and Brunch • American • Sandwiches • Group Friendly
    • Picked for you
        • Iced Coffee
        • Home Fries
          Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES"
        • Plain Cream Cheese Bagel
        • Butter Bagel
        • Two Eggs, Bacon and American Cheese on a Bagel
      • Salad Sandwiches
          • Tuna Salad Sandwich
          • Chicken Salad Sandwich
          • Egg Salad Sandwich
        • Fresh Egg Sandwiches
          • Two Eggs and Bacon on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Ham and Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs and American Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs and Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs and Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs and Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Bacon and American Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Bacon and Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Bacon and Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Bacon and Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs and Sausage on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Sausage and American Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Sausage and Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Sausage and Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Sausage and Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs and Ham on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Ham and American Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Ham and Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Ham and Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs and Turkey on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey and American Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey and Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey and Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey and Pepperjack Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey and Bacon on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey Bacon and American Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey Bacon and Swiss Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey Bacon and Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel
          • Two Eggs, Turkey Bacon and Pepperjack Cheese on a Roll
          • HUNGRY DUDE
            3 eggs, Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Cheese on a HER0
        • DELI
            • DELI Sandwiches
              Fresh Sliced, made custom to order. :) let us know how you like it.
            • Sliced Nova Lox-1/2lb
              Sliced Lox by the 1/2lb.
          • Cream Cheese
              • 1/2 Lb Plain Cream Cheese
                43467
              • 1/2 Lb Veggie Cream Cheese
                1/2 lb.
              • 1/2 Lb Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese
                1/2 lb.
              • 1/2 Lb Scallion Cream Cheese
                1/2 lb.
              • 1/2 Lb Strawberry Cream Cheese
                1/2 lb.
              • 1/2 Lb Olive Cream Cheese
                1/2 lb.
              • 1/2 Lb Butter
            • GROUP DEALS & Catering
                • Dozen Bagels & Spreads
                  12 bagels of your choice & 1/2 LB of cream cheese
                • Tray of Scrambled Eggs
                  Scrambled eggs for a group, (8x10 Party Tray)
                • Coffee 2 GO
                  Box-Of-Coffee serves 10-15 includes Milk, Stirrers & Sweeteners
                • Tray of Home Fries
                  Our soon-to-be-famous Home Fries! (8x10 Party Tray)
                • Tray of BACON
                  Real, Delicious, Thick sliced Farmhouse Bacon. (appx 25+ slices)
                • Tray of Sausage Pattys
                  Tray of Sausage Pattys (12+ pcs)
                • 1/2 GAL PURE PREMIUM OJ
                • LARGE TUB OF PLAIN CREAM CHEESE
                  1+LB SPREADS BUTTER/CC
              • Salad
                  • 1/2 Lb Chicken Salad
                    Fresh All White Meat.
                  • 1/2 Lb Tuna Salad
                    Fresh All White Meat.
                  • 1/2 Lb Egg Salad
                    Made From Whole Fresh Eggs.
                • Hot+Fresh+Sides
                  • BLT
                  • Omlettes
                  • Home Fries
                    Our Soon-To-Be Famous Home Fries "CRISPY POTATO CUBES"
                  • BACON SIDE
                    Two Strips of our thick-sliced Fresh Farmhouse Bacon
                  • SAUSAGE PATTY SIDE
                  • TURKEY-BACON SIDE
                    2 Slices of Premium Turkey Bacon
                • Bagels & Spreads
                    • Butter Bagel
                    • Jelly Bagel
                    • Plain Cream Cheese Bagel
                    • Veggie Cream Cheese Bagel
                    • Scallion Cream Cheese Bagel
                    • Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese Bagel
                    • Strawberry Cream Cheese Bagel
                    • Olive Cream Cheese Bagel
                    • Jalapeno Cream Cheese Bagel
                    • Jelly & Plain Cream Cheese
                    • 1 Dozen Assorted Bagels
                      Please let us know your favorites, otherwise we will assort them for you :)
                    • Plain bagel
                      Specify type in notes
                  • Creamer
                      • Quart 1/2 and 1/2
                      • French Vanilla Creamer
                      • Hazelnut Creamer
                      • Caramel Macchiato Creamer
                      • Half Gallon Whole Milk
                    • Bottle Beverages
                        • Snapple Lemon Iced Tea 16oz
                        • Snapple Raspberry Iced Tea 16oz
                        • Snapple Peach Iced Tea 16oz
                        • Seltzer/Club Soda 20oz
                          Hal's
                        • Pepsi 20oz
                        • Diet Pepsi 20oz
                        • Cherry Pepsi 20oz
                          wild cherry pepsi
                        • Cream Soda 20oz
                        • Mountain Dew 20oz
                        • Mountain Dew BLUE 20oz
                          BLUE
                        • Gatorade 20oz GREEN
                          Lemon -Lime Green
                        • Gatorade 20oz BLUE
                          cool blue
                        • Gatorade 20oz ORANGE
                          orange
                        • Gatorade 20oz RED
                        • Nesquick - Chocolate
                        • Nesquick - Strawberry Banana
                        • Nesquick - Strawberry
                        • Simply OJ
                          12oz
                        • Tropicana OJ - 12oz Pure Premium
                        • Tropicana APPLE Juice
                          12oz
                        • Tropicana GRAPE Juice
                          12oz
                        • Tropicana CRANBERRY Juice
                        • V8 100% Veggi Juice
                          12oz
                        • Tropicana OJ+CALCIUM CLASSIC 12 oz.
                        • Ginger Ale 20oz
                          Hal's Ginger Ale
                        • Poland Spring Water
                          16.9 oz.
                        • RED BULL
                          8.4oz can
                        • Root Beer 20oz
                        • Yoo Hoo Bottle
                      • Beverages
                          • Hot Coffee
                          • Hot Tea
                          • Iced Coffee
                          • Deli Iced Tea 
                          • Unsweetened Iced Tea
                          • Peach Iced Tea
                          • Pink Lemonade
                          • Pink Lemonade
                          • 1/2 lb Salami
                        • Bakery
                            • Small Chocolate Chip Cookie
                              Fresh Baked Chocolate Chip Cookie
                            • Corn Muffin
                            • Blueberry Muffin
                            • Chocolate Chip Muffin
                            • Banana Chip Muffin
                            • Double Chocolate Muffin
                            • Apple Turnover
                            • Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie LARGE
                            • Black & White Cookie
                              traditional back & white cookie
                            • Crossant
                            • Cheese Danish
                            • Milano Cookie LARGE
                            • Linzer Tart LARGE
                            • XL Cinnamon Bun/Cinnamon Twist
                          • SLICED LOX SANDWICH
                              • Sliced Lox/Cream Cheese/Onion/Tomato
                                Generous portion of sliced lox with fixins
                                Please specify type of bagel
                            • Boar's Head Sliced Cold Cuts
                                • 1/2 lb Turkey Breast
                                  Please Specify:
                                  Oven Gold
                                  Honey Maple
                                  Cracked Pepper
                                • 1/2 lb Roast Beef
                                • 1/2 lb Bologna
                                • 1/2lb Cheese
                                  Please Specify
                                  American
                                  Pepper Jack
                                  Cheddar
                                  Swiss
                                  Muenster
                                  Mozzarella
                                • 1/2 lb Pepperoni
                              Frequently asked questions

                              What is the address of MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY in Mount Sinai?

                              MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY is located at: 331 NY-25A , Mount Sinai

                              Is the menu for MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY available online?

                              Yes, you can access the menu for MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY online on Postmates. Follow the link to see the full menu available for delivery and pickup.

                              What are the most popular items on the MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY menu?

                              The most ordered items from MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY are: DELI Sandwiches, Two Eggs, Bacon and American Cheese on a Bagel, Two Eggs and American Cheese on a Bagel.

                              Does MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY offer delivery in Mount Sinai?

                              Yes, MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY offers delivery in Mount Sinai via Postmates. Enter your delivery address to see if you are within the MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY delivery radius, then place your order.

                              Can I get free delivery from MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY?

                              Delivery fees for MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY vary. Just enter your delivery address to see the delivery fee for your location. You could always get free delivery from MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY with Postmates Unlimited.

                              Can I pick up my order from MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY?

                              Postmates offers pickup from many restaurants in your city. To see if you can pick up your order from MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY, add items to your cart and look for the ‘pickup’ option at checkout.

                              Can I schedule a delivery order from MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY?

                              Some restaurants on Postmates allow you to schedule a delivery to show up at your location when you want it. At checkout, look for the option to select a delivery time. If it’s there, that means you can schedule your delivery from MT SINAI BAGELS YOUR WAY.