Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    New Haven Pizza Place
    Too far to deliver

    New Haven Pizza Place

    4.7
    (205)
      •  
    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday - Monday
    11:00 AM - 07:30 PM
    Tuesday - Thursday
    11:00 AM - 08:30 PM
    Friday - Saturday
    11:00 AM - 09:30 PM
    ₩₩ • Italian • Pizza • Salads • Wings • Healthy • Family Friendly

    1377 New Haven Ave, Milford, CT 06460 • More


    • Picked for you

      • Mozzarella Classic Pizza Large

        $17.00
      • Mozzarella Classic cheese Pizza

        $11.75
      • Mashed Potato, Bacon, and Caramelized Onions Specialty Pizza Large

        $24.00
      • Pepperoni Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Mashed Potato, Bacon, and Caramelized Onions Specialty Pizza

        $18.00
    • Popular Pairs

      • Pepperoni Classic Pizza Large + 2 L Soda

        $23.75
      • Mozzarella Classic Pizza Large + Wings

        Mozzarella Classic Pizza Large. Served with Wings.
        $25.95
      • Mozzarella Classic cheese Pizza + Choice of Apps

        Mozzarella Classic cheese Pizza. Served with choice of Apps.
        $11.75
    • Salads

      • Garden Salad

        Romaine, spring mix, tomatoes, cucumbers, and red onions.
        $7.95
      • Caesar Salad

        $7.95
      • Antipasto

        Olives, pickled eggplant, stuffed peppers, marinated mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and mixed greens, roasted peppers, imported Italian olives.
        $10.95
    • Classics Pizza Small

      • Onions Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Spinach Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Mozzarella Classic cheese Pizza

        $11.75
      • Bacon Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Meatball Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Peppers Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Sausage Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Garlic Bread Classic Pizza

        White.
        $13.50
      • Hot Peppers Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Pepperoni Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • Mushroom Classic Pizza

        $13.50
      • New haven style plain Pizza

        Sauce, pecorino romano, and garlic
        $11.75
    • Specialty Pizzas Small

      • Shrimp and Garlic Specialty Pizza

        White.
        $19.00
      • BBQ Chicken Specialty Pizza

        $16.00
      • Margherita Specialty Pizza

        $18.00
      • Artichoke and Bacon Specialty Pizza

        With a splash of lemon.
        $16.50
      • Artichoke, Mushroom, Caramelized Onion, and Honey Goat Cheese Specialty Pizza

        $18.00
      • Eggplant Specialty Pizza

        Noonie's freshly homemade eggplant
        $16.00
      • sm. Lemon Chicken Specialty Pizza

        $18.00
      • Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza

        $16.00
      • sm. Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Specialty Pizza

        $18.00
      • The Don Specialty Pizza

        Sausage, bacon, pepperoni, peppers, and garlic.
        $18.00
      • Don Veggie Specialty Pizza

        Spinach, broccoli, mushroom, carmelized onions, and garlic.
        $18.00
      • Mashed Potato, Bacon, and Caramelized Onions Specialty Pizza

        $18.00
      • Fresh Tomato Specialty Pizza

        White. Fresh basil oil and garlic.
        $16.00
    • Classics Pizza Large

      • Hot Peppers Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Mozzarella Classic Pizza Large

        $17.00
      • New Haven Plain Traditional Classic Pizza Large

        Sauce, pecorino romano, and garlic! Note new haven place does not come with cheese
        $15.00
      • Mushroom Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Meatball Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Spinach Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Sausage Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Onions Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Pepperoni Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Garlic Bread Classic Pizza Large

        White.
        $19.50
      • Bacon Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
      • Peppers Classic Pizza Large

        $19.50
    • Specialty Pizzas Large

      • Artichoke and Bacon Specialty Pizza Large

        With a splash of lemon.
        $23.00
      • Lemon Chicken Specialty Pizza Large

        $24.00
      • Don Veggie Specialty Pizza Large

        Spinach, broccoli, mushroom, carmelized onions, and garlic.
        $24.00
      • Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza Large

        $22.00
      • Shrimp and Garlic Specialty Pizza Large

        White.
        $26.00
      • Artichoke, Mushroom, Caramelized Onion, and Honey Goat Cheese Specialty Pizza Large

        delicately saute artichoke,mushrooms with slow cooked caramelized onions, cooked perfectly with honey goat cheese and baked to perfection
        $25.50
      • Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Specialty Pizza Large

        $22.00
      • The Don Specialty Pizza Large

        Sausage, bacon, pepperoni, peppers, and garlic.
        $24.00
      • Fresh Tomato Specialty Pizza Large

        White. Fresh basil oil and garlic.
        $22.00
      • Margherita Specialty Pizza Large

        $24.00
      • BBQ Chicken Specialty Pizza Large

        $22.00
      • Eggplant Specialty Pizza Large

        $22.00
      • Mashed Potato, Bacon, and Caramelized Onions Specialty Pizza Large

        $24.00
    • Pizza by the Slice

      • Pepperoni Pizza Slice

        $3.00
      • Mozzarella Pizza Slice

        $3.00
    • Apps

      • Wings

        BBQ, Buffalo, teriyaki, and sweet chilli.
        $8.95
      • Mozzarella Sticks

        $8.95
      • Bruschetta

        $10.95
      • Side of meatballs

        Three large meatballs with homestyle Italian sauce topped with mozzarella cheese and pecorino Romano cheese with garlic bread
        $8.95
      • Garlic Bread

        $5.95
    • Drinks

      • Diet Coke®

        Diet Cola
        $4.25
      • 2 L Soda

        $4.25
      • Soda

        20 Oz
        $2.50
      • Foxon Park

        $2.50
      • Coca-Cola®

        Coca-Cola Soda
        $2.50
    • Desserts

      • Cannoli

        $4.00
      • Tiramisu

        $4.00
      • Mini cannoli

        Mini cannoli
        $1.50
    • Grinders

      • Eggplant parm grinder

        Freshly made Italian style eggplant, with homestyle marinara sauce on fresh Italian bread
        $10.95
      • Broccoli rabe and sausage grinder

        Fresh cooked broccoli rabe and Italian sausage on fresh Italian bread topped with mozzarella and Parmesan
        $10.95
      • Meatball parm grinder

        Authentic freshly made meatballs, homestyle Italian sauce on freshly Italian bread topped with mozzarella and Parmesan
        $10.95
      • Fresh Mozz & Tomato

        Fresh mozz,tomato, topped with roasted red peppers, red onions along with fresh basil oil & balsamic glaze
        $10.95
      • Chicken parm grinder

        Freshly prepared Italian style culets, home style marinara sauce on Italian bread covered with mozzarella and Parmesan
        $10.95
      • Sausage and pepper grinder

        Freshly made sausage and peppers, homestyle Italian sauce on fresh Italian bread topped with mozzarella and Parmesan
        $10.95
    • Dinners

      • Ravioli Dinner

        With side of garlic bread and side salad
        $12.95
      • Chicken Parm dinner

        With side of garlic bread and side salad
        $12.95
      • Stuffed Shells

        With side of garlic bread
        $12.95
      • Meatball Parm

        With side of garlic bread and side salad
        $12.95
      • Eggplant Parm dinner

        With side of garlic bread and side salad
        $12.95
    • Stuffed Breads

      • Small Stuffed Breads

        $11.95
      • Small Calzone

        $11.95
      • Large Stuffed Breads

        $17.95
      • Large Calzone

        $17.95