Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Browse by area
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner
    Too far to deliver

    Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner

    4.8
    (160)
      •  
    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Every Day
    10:00 AM - 10:30 PMCatering
    10:00 AM - 10:30 PMMenu
    ¢ • Jewish • Diner • Deli • Sandwich • Family Friendly

    548 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10016 • More


    • Picked for you

      • Stuffed Mushrooms Tray

        25 pieces per order.
        $49.95
      • German Chocolate Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • Seasonal Fruit Bowl Tray

        Deluxe selection of golden pineapple, honeydew, cantaloupe, seedless grapes and mixed berries. Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $59.50
      • Assorted Fresh Juices

        Apple, orange, tomato, grapefruit and cranberry juice. Mix and match. Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $49.50
      • Cobb Salad (Medium) (Serves 12-15)

        Grilled sliced chicken breast, avocado, crumbled blue cheese, bacon,, sliced egg & tomato on a bed of mixed greens. Choice of dressing on the side.
        $119.95
    • Catering 4 Foot & 6 Foot Hero Buffet Options

      • #1. The New Yorker 4 Foot or 6 Foot Hero Tray

        Traditional New York deli style corned beef pastrami, fresh sliced turkey, roast beef and kosher salami. Topped with coleslaw and Russian dressing. Includes a bowl of homemade potato salad, a bowl of our homemade creamy coleslaw and assorted pickles, peppers, tomatoes, and olives, mustard, Russian dressing and mayonnaise. Serves 15. Requires 24 hrs notice.
        $250.00
      • #2. The Mulberry Street 4 Foot or 6 Foot Hero Tray

        Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham, capicola, provolone, sliced tomatoes and lettuce, topped with red pimentos, oil and vinegar. Includes a bowl of homemade potato salad, a bowl of our homemade creamy coleslaw and assorted pickles, peppers, tomatoes, and olives, mustard, Russian dressing and mayonnaise. Serves 15. Requires 24 hrs notice.
        $250.00
      • #3. The All American 4 Foot or 6 Foot Hero Tray

        Prime roast beef, fresh roast turkey, boiled ham and Swiss cheese with lettuce, sliced tomatoes. Includes a bowl of homemade potato salad, a bowl of our homemade creamy coleslaw and assorted pickles, peppers, tomatoes, and olives, mustard, Russian dressing and mayonnaise. Serves 15. Requires 24 hrs notice.
        $250.00
    • Catering Sarge's Get Together Favorites

      • Classic Sandwich Party (5 Person Minimum)

        Assorted 9 oz. sandwiches on a decorative party platter-cut in thirds. Choice of sandwich or wrap. Includes decorated bowl of potato salad, a bowl of coleslaw, relish tray of assorted pickles, peppers, tomatoes and olives, mustard, mayonnaise and Russian dressing. Minimum 5. Serves 25–250 (5–50 people per quantity). Requires 3 hrs notice.
        $109.75
      • Junior Sandwich Party (5 Person Minimum)

        Assorted 4.0 oz sandwiches on a decorative party platter-cut in thirds. Choice of sandwich or wrap. Includes decorated bowl of potato salad, a bowl of coleslaw, relish tray of assorted pickles, peppers, tomatoes and olives, mustard, mayonnaise and Russian dressing. Minimum 5. Serves 25–250 (5–50 people per quantity). Requires 3 hrs notice.
        $74.75
      • Cold Cut Buffet (5 Person Minimum)

        Beautifully decorated trays of assorted sliced meats. Includes choice meats on a platter, a decorated bowl of potato salad, bowl of coleslaw, relish tray of assorted pickles, peppers tomatoes and olives, rye bread, dinner rolls, mustard, mayonnaise and Russian dressing. Minimum 5. Serves 25–250 (5–50 people per quantity). Requires 3 hrs notice.
        $119.75
      • Roll-A-Rama (5 Person Minimum)

        Tray of assorted sandwiches on our luncheon size Vienna rolls. Choose from meats and salads. Decorated bowl of potato salad, a bowl of coleslaw, relish trays of assorted pickles, peppers, tomatoes and olives, mustard, mayonnaise and Russian dressing. Minimum 5. Serves 25–250 (5–50 people per quantity). Requires 3 hrs notice.
        $109.75
      • Hot Dogs with the Fixings (1 Dozen)

        On the side: sauerkraut, sarge's onion sauce, relish, mustard & ketchup.
        $65.95
      • Mini Potato Knishes (25)

        24 hour notice required. We make them from scratch...
        $29.95
      • Wings by Ten (10) Mouth Watering Chicken Wings

        (10) mouth watering chicken wings (best in New York) served with bleu cheese & celery.
        $15.95
    • Catering Continental Favorites

      • Cornish Hens Tray

        Comes with fruited stuffing. Minimum 5.
        $74.75
      • Poached Salmon Tray

        Comes with dill sauce. Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $94.75
      • Rack of Lamb with Mint Jelly Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 35 (7 people per quantity).
        $124.75
      • Eggplant Parmigiana Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $94.75
      • Chicken Parmigiana Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $99.75
      • Lemon Garlic Chicken Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $99.75
      • Balsamic Chicken Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $99.75
      • Chicken Masala Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $99.75
      • Barbeque Ribs Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $109.75
      • Southern Fried Chicken Tray

        Minimum 5. Serves 30 (6 people per quantity).
        $94.75
      • Half Roast Chicken Tray

        Minimum 5.
        $94.75
      • Boneless Prime Rib

        $299.95
      • Roast Turkeys (Raw Weight)

        Served with cranberry sauce and dressing. Minimum 12. Requires 48 hrs notice.
        $95.40
    • Catering Sarge's Sides

      • Mashed Potatoes Tray

        $34.95
      • Candied Sweets Tray

        $34.95
      • Homemade Stuffing Tray

        $34.95
      • Roasted Potatoes Tray

        $34.95
      • Crinkle Cut French Fries Tray

        $34.95
      • Slow Cooked Baked Beans Tray

        Slow cooked to perfection, an old school deli favorite.
        $34.95
      • Home Fries Tray

        $34.95
      • Corn on the Cob Tray

        $34.95
      • Broccoli Tray

        $34.95
      • Peas and Carrots Tray

        $34.95
      • String Beans Tray

        $34.95
      • Homemade Creamy Coleslaw Tray

        $34.95
      • Homemade Potato Salad Tray

        $34.95
      • Homemade Macaroni Salad Tray

        $34.95
      • Creamed Spinach Tray

        $37.95
      • Mac and Cheese Tray

        $37.95
      • String Beans Almandine Tray

        $37.95
      • 1lb. Stuffed Derma

        $9.95
      • Quart Small Pickles

        $9.95
      • Large Pickle

        $2.50
    • Catering Sarge's Homemade Cheese Cake's

      • Plain Whole Cheesecake

        $39.95
      • Fresh Strawberry Whole Cheesecake

        $47.95
      • Peanut Butter Chocolate Whole Cheesecake

        $64.95
      • Oreo Whole Cheesecake

        $64.95
    • Catering Desserts

      • 1 Dozen Large Black and White Cookies Plattered

        12 cookies displayed on a platter (specify if you want the cookie left whole or cut in 4's).
        $57.95
      • 1 Dozen Large Chocolate Chip Cookie's

        12 cookies displayed on a platter (specify if you want the cookie left whole or cut in 4's).
        $47.95
      • 1 Dozen Linzer Tart's (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $47.95
      • Platter of All Butter Pound Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $62.95
      • Platter of Marble Nut Halvah

        $81.95
      • 1 Dozen Napoleon's (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $71.95
      • 1 Dozen Chocolate Eclair (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $71.95
      • Apple Strudel Log (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $29.95
      • Apple Crumb Pie (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $34.95
      • Banana Cream Pie (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $40.95
      • Chocolate Cream Pie (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $40.95
      • Pecan Pie (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $40.95
      • 7 Layer Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • Chocolate Mousse Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • Strawberry Shortcake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • German Chocolate Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • Red Velvet Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • Carrot Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • Chocolate Fudge Cake (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $64.95
      • Platter of Brownies and Blondies (24 Hour Notice Required)

        $79.95
      • 1 Dozen Mini Italian Pastries (24 Hour Notice Required)

        Requires 24 hrs notice.
        $29.95
      • 1 Dozen Petit-fours (24 Hour Notice Required)

        Requires 24 hrs notice.
        $37.95
      • Bakery Cookies (1 Pound) (24 Hour Notice Required)

        Requires 24 hrs notice.
        $17.95
      • Homemade Ruggelach (1 Pound)

        $17.95
      • Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies

        Individual serve. Box of 10.
        $69.95
    • Catering Fabulous Buffalo Wings

      • Herd of Buffalo

        100 Wings. Served with blue cheese dressing and celery.
        $119.95
      • Fabulous Buffalo Wings

        Served with blue cheese dressing and celery.
        $79.95
      • Wings by Ten

        10 wings (best in New York) served with bleu cheese dressing & celery.
        $15.95
      • 60 Piece Flock of Wings

        $79.95
      • 100 Piece Herd of Buffalo Wings

        $119.95
    • Catering | Classic Sarge's Favorites

      • Sarge's Slamm'in Sliders (1 Dozen)

        Served with melted American cheese and sauteed onions upon request.
        $39.95
      • Hot Dogs with the Fixings (1 Dozen)

        On the side: sauerkraut, sarge's onion sauce, relish, mustard & ketchup add on potato and coleslaw, chili and cheese, pastrami and pickles.
        $53.95
      • Chicken Tenders (25)

        Served with honey mustard dipping sauce.
        $29.95
      • Sarge's Famous Swedish Meatballs (25 Meatballs in our Sweet & Sour Sauce)

        $34.95
      • Colossal Chilled Gulf Shrimp Cocktail Platter

        (25 jumbo gulf shrimp) served with cocktail sauce & fresh lemon wedges.
        $106.95
      • 1 Full Rack Mouth Watering St. Louis Ribs

        Slow cooked to perfection.
        $28.45
      • Franks & Beans Casserole with Sauerkraut (24 Hour Notice Required)

        Choose from 2 tray sizes (small or large).
        $49.95
      • 1 Doz. Sarge's Slamm'in Sliders

        $42.95
    • Catering Breakfast

      • Continental Breakfast Tray

        An arrangement of freshly baked miniature pastries: muffins, bagels, croissants and danish. Garnished with strawberries, butter, cream cheese and preserves. Choice of juice. Box of coffee or tea. Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity). Requires 48 hrs notice.
        $129.50
      • Smoked Salmon Package (10 Person Minimum)

        An elegant display of freshly hand sliced smoked salmon, beautifully placed on a platter with plain, scallion and vegetable cream cheese, Bermuda onion, tomatoes, black and green olives. Accompanied by a tray of assorted bagels. Choice of juice. Box of coffee or tea. Minimum 10. Serves 100–500 (10–50 people per quantity). Requires 3 hrs notice.
        $219.50
      • Hot Breakfast Combo Tray

        Scrambled eggs, home fried potatoes. your choice of challah French toast or buttermilk pancakes. Your choice of breakfast sausage links or bacon. Choice of rye, white or whole wheat toast. Choice of juice. Box of coffee or tea. Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $179.50
    • Catering Additions To Your

      • Seasonal Fruit Bowl Tray

        Deluxe selection of golden pineapple, honeydew, cantaloupe, seedless grapes and mixed berries. Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $59.50
      • Assorted Bagel Platter (10 Person Minimum)

        An assortment of bagels and bialys, accompanied by plain, vegetable and scallion cream cheese and butter. Minimum 10. Serves 100–500 (10–50 people per quantity). Requires 6 hrs notice.
        $49.50
      • Assorted Fresh Juices

        Apple, orange, tomato, grapefruit and cranberry juice. Mix and match. Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $49.50
      • Freshly Ground Columbian House Blend Coffee

        Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $39.50
      • Fresh Decaffeinated Coffee

        Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $39.50
      • Hot Tea

        Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $39.50
      • Flavored Herbal Tea

        Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $39.50
      • Hot Chocolate

        Minimum 10. Serves 120 (12 people per quantity).
        $39.50
    • Catering Cold Hors D' Oeuvres

      • Colossal Gulf Shrimp Tray

        Served on a decorated tray with cocktail sauce and lemon wedges. Minimum 15. Serves 255 (17 people per quantity).
        $74.25
      • Chopped Chicken Liver Mold

        Comes with cocktail bread.
        $29.95
      • Crudite Tray

        Comes with fresh garden vegetable dip.
        $79.95
      • Assorted Cheese Platter Tray

        Small cubes of cheese served with bread sticks and crackers.
        $109.95
      • Assorted Fruit and Cheese Platter Tray

        Comes with bread sticks and crackers.
        $109.95
      • Assorted Fresh Fruit Platter Tray

        $109.95
      • Assorted Sliced Cheese Platter

        3 lbs. of sliced cheese (Choose up to 6 selections).
        $44.95
    • Catering Hot Hors D' Oeuvres

      • Franks In A Blanket Tray (Homemade)

        25 pieces per order.
        $29.95
      • Miniature Potato Knishes Tray (Homemade)

        25 pieces per order.
        $29.95
      • Miniature Egg Rolls Tray

        25 pieces per order.
        $29.95
      • Swedish Meatballs Tray

        Sweet and sour sauce. 25 pieces per order.
        $39.95
      • Miniature Barbecued Spare Ribs Tray

        25 pieces per order.
        $49.95
      • Miniature Potato Pancakes Tray (Homemade)

        Comes with apple sauce. 25 pieces per order.
        $34.95
      • Miniature Spinach and Feta Puffs Tray

        25 pieces per order.
        $34.95
      • Chicken Tenders Tray (Homemade)

        25 pieces per order. Comes with honey mustard & Barbecue sauce).
        $34.95
      • Mozzarella Sticks Tray (Homemade)

        25 pieces per order. Comes with tomato sauce.
        $43.95
      • Stuffed Mushrooms Tray

        25 pieces per order.
        $49.95
      • Miniature Stuffed Cabbage Tray

        25 pieces per order.
        $64.95
      • Bronx Sliders Tray (Minimum Order of 10)

        Comes with or without American cheese and sauteed onions. Minimum 10. Serves 100–1000 (10–100 people per quantity). Requires 1 hr notice.
        $39.50
      • Fried Fantail Shrimp Tray

        Minimum 10.
        $55.00
      • 1 Dozen Hot Dogs with Fixings

        On the side: sauerkraut, sarge's hot dog onion sauce, relish, mustard and ketchup.
        $65.95
      • Loaded Baked Potato Bar Tray

        Includes 5 large russet baked potatoes, homemade chili, homemade bacon bits, shredded cheddar cheese, broccoli, sour cream and chives. Serves 5.
        $59.95
    • Catering Assorted Salad Buffet

      • #1 Assorted Salad Buffet (10 Person Minimum)

        Tuna salad, chicken salad, and egg salad. Includes platter of lettuce and sliced tomato, rye bread and dinner rolls. Minimum 10. Serves 100–500 (10–50 people per quantity). Requires 3 hrs notice.
        $139.50
      • #2 Assorted Salad Buffet (5 Person Minimum)

        Pick any 3 of 6 salads: Tuna salad, chicken salad, egg salad, baked salmon salad, whitefish salad or shrimp salad (includes platter of lettuce and sliced tomato, rye bread and dinner rolls. Minimum 10. Serves 100–500 (10–50 people per quantity). Requires 3 hrs notice.
        $159.50
    • Catering Assorted Cold Uptown Salads

      • Tossed Green Salad

        Romaine and iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, carrots and spring mix.
        $64.95
      • Caesar Salad

        Romaine lettuce, croutons, grated parmigiana and creamy caesar dressing.
        $84.95
      • Chopped Salad

        Iceberg romaine, radicchio, cucumber, tomato, green onions, chickpeas and roasted corn.
        $84.95
      • Spinach Salad

        Comes with chopped bacon, fresh mushrooms, and finely grated hard-boiled eggs.
        $84.95
      • Greek Salad

        Grape leaves, feta cheese, black olives and anchovies on a bed of mixed greens in our mediterranean dressing.
        $94.95
      • Pasta Primavera

        Fuseli pasta, broccoli, peas, and carrots mixed in a house dressing.
        $84.95
      • Grilled Vegetables

        Eggplant, zucchini, peppers, onion, and mushrooms in house dressing.
        $84.95
      • Cobb Salad

        Grilled chicken breast, avocado, crumbled blue cheese, bacon, sliced egg and tomato on mixed greens.
        $94.95
      • Cobb Salad (Large) (Serves 18-20)

        Grilled sliced chicken breast, avocado, crumbled blue cheese, bacon,, sliced egg & tomato on a bed of mixed greens. Choice of dressing on the side.
        $149.95
      • Cobb Salad (Medium) (Serves 12-15)

        Grilled sliced chicken breast, avocado, crumbled blue cheese, bacon,, sliced egg & tomato on a bed of mixed greens. Choice of dressing on the side.
        $119.95
      • Greek Salad (Large) (Serves 18-20)

        Includes grape leaves, feta cheese, black olives & anchovies on a bed of mixed greens. On the side: our own mediterranean dressing.
        $149.95
      • Greek Salad (Medium) (Serves 12-15)

        Includes grape leaves, feta cheese, black olives & anchovies on a bed of mixed greens. On the side: our own mediterranean dressing.
        $129.95
      • Grilled Vegetables (Large) (Serves 18-20)

        Eggplant, zucchini, peppers, onions & portobello mushrooms with our own house dressing.
        $129.95
      • Grilled Vegetables (Medium) (Serves 12-15)

        Eggplant, zucchini, peppers, onions & portobello mushrooms with our own house dressing.
        $112.95
      • Pasta Primavera (Large) (Serves 18-20) Must Have 24 Hours Notice

        Fusilli pasta, broccoli, peas & carrots tossed in our own homemade house dressing.
        $129.95
      • Pasta Primavera (Medium) (Serves 12-15) Must Have 24 Hours Notice

        Fusilli pasta, broccoli, peas & carrots tossed in our own homemade house dressing.
        $112.95
      • Spinach Salad (Large) (Serves 18-20)

        Includes chopped bacon, fresh mushrooms & finely grated hard-boiled eggs (balsamic dressing on the side).
        $129.95
      • Spinach Salad (Medium) (Serves 12-15)

        Includes chopped bacon, fresh mushrooms & finely grated hard-boiled eggs (balsamic dressing on the side).
        $112.95
      • Tossed Green Salad (Large) (Serves 18-20)

        Romaine, iceberg & spring mix lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers & carrots. Choice of dressings on the side.
        $109.95
      • Tossed Green Salad (Medium) (Serves 12-15)

        Romaine, iceberg & spring mix lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers & carrots. Choice of dressings on the side.
        $89.95
      • Traditional Caesar Salad (Large) (Serves 18-20)

        Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, & grated Parmigiana. On the side: our own creamy caesar dressing.
        $129.95
      • Traditional Caesar Salad (Medium) (Serves 12-15)

        Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, & grated parmigiana. On the side: Our own creamy Caesar dressing.
        $112.95
    • Catering Sarge's Traditional Specialties

      • Kasha Varnishkas Tray

        $39.95
      • Noodle Kugel Tray

        $39.95
      • Franks and Beans Casserole Tray

        Comes with sauerkraut.
        $49.95
      • 2 Piece Cheese Blintzes Tray

        Served with apple sauce and sour cream. Minimum 5.
        $49.75
      • 3 Piece Potato Pirogen Tray

        Served with sour cream and sauteed onions. Minimum 5.
        $49.75
      • 1 Piece Stuffed Cabbage Tray

        Minimum 5.
        $49.75
      • Corned Beef and Cabbage Tray

        Comes with boiled potato. Minimum 5.
        $119.75
      • Brisket with Gravy Tray

        Minimum 5.
        $79.75
      • Roast Chicken Tray

        1/2 chicken per person. Minimum 5.
        $74.75
      • Large Ceremonial Challah (48 Hour Notice Required)

        $69.95
    Spend $30, Save $8