Skip to content
Postmates Home
    Sign in
    Too far to deliver

    Location and hours

    4082 Nesconset Hwy, East Setauket, NY 11733
    Sunday - Thursday
    10:00 AM - 9:45 PM
    Friday - Saturday
    9:30 AM - 9:45 PM

    Setauket Pastaria

    4.7 (67 ratings) • Pizza • $
      •  More info
    4082 Nesconset Hwy, East Setauket, NY 11733
    Enter your address above to see fees, and delivery + pickup estimates.
    $ • Pizza • Seafood • Salads • Pasta

    • Picked for you

      • Large Pizza (16 ")
        Quick view
      • Create Your Own Personal Pie (12")
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Vodka Sauce
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • House Salad
        Served with mozzarella, and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Cutlet Hero
        Quick view

    • Appetizers

      • Baked Clams (6 pcs)
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Clams Casino (6 pcs)
        Quick view
      • Shrimp Cocktail (5 pcs)
        Served with cocktail sauce.
        Quick view
      • Fried Shrimp (5 pcs)
        Served with tomato sauce.
        Quick view
      • Mussels with Marinara Sauce
        Quick view
      • Fried Ravioli (5 pcs)
        Served with tomato sauce.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • French Fries
        Served with ketchup.
        Quick view
      • Mozzarella Carrozza
        Served with marinara sauce.
        Quick view
      • Zucchini Sticks
        Served with tomato sauce.
        Quick view
      • Bruschetta (4 pcs)
        Quick view
      • Spinach and Mushrooms
        Sautéed in garlic and oil.
        Quick view
      • Maryland Crab Cakes (2 pcs)
        Served with tartar sauce.
        Quick view
      • Little Necks (6 pcs)
        Quick view
      • Hot Antipasto
        Eggplant rollatini, baked clams, stuffed mushrooms, artichokes, and shrimp.
        Quick view
      • Shrimp Scampi (5 pcs)
        Quick view
      • Fried Calamari
        Served with marinara sauce.
        Quick view
      • Mussels with White Sauce
        Quick view
      • Beer Battered Onion Rings
        Served with ketchup.
        Quick view
      • Mozzarella Sticks (6 pcs)
        Served with tomato sauce.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Stuffed Mushrooms (6 pcs)
        Quick view
      • Chicken Fingers (5 pcs)
        Served with honey mustard, French fries, and ketchup.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Eggplant Rollatini
        Quick view
      • Buffalo Wings (12 pcs)
        Served with blue cheese.
        Popular
        Quick view

    • Gluten-Free Appetizers

      • Gluten-Free Clams Casino (6 pcs)
        Whole clams, roasted pepper, and bacon.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Mussels
        Bowl of steamed mussels.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Fried Calamari
        Breaded and fried with marinara.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Cold Antipasto
        Assortment of Italian meats, cheeses, and olives.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Shrimp Cocktail (5 Large)
        Shrimp with cocktail sauce.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Cherry Pepper Calamari
        Fried calamari with cherry and jalapeno pepper in marinara sauce.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view

    • Soups

      • Pasta Fagioli Soup
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Stratchatelli Soup
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Minestrone Soup
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • French Onion Soup
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Soup
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Tortellini Soup
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view

    • Salads

      • Antipasta Salad
        Cold with salami, ham, provolone, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, pepperoni, soppressata, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Italian Salad
        Served with mozzarella cheese and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Greek Salad
        Served with feta cheese and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Calamari Salad
        Lettuce, celery, lemons, and onions. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Bosc Pear Salad
        Served with Gorgonzola cheese and raspberry vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Small Side Salad
        Served with a small side. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • House Salad
        Served with mozzarella, and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Caesar Salad
        Served with Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Fresh Mozzarella and Tomatoes Salad
        Served with roasted peppers and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Spinach Salad
        Warm with bacon, red onions, mushrooms, and balsamic vinaigrette.
        Quick view
      • Cold Seafood Salad
        Mussels, calamari, shrimp, scallops, and scungilli. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view

    • Gluten-Free Salad

      • Gluten-Free House Salad
        Mixed greens, tomatoes, olives, cucumbers, and red onion.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Greek Salad
        Classic Greek with olives, feta, cucumbers, and tomatoes.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Warm Spinach Salad
        Spinach, bacon, mushrooms, and red onion.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Caramelized Bosc Pear Salad
        Gorgonzola, glazed walnuts, and mixed greens in raspberry vinaigrette.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Classic Caesar Salad
        Classic Caesar with Parmesan.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Insalata Caprese Salad
        Fresh mozzarella, tomato, and roasted red pepper salad.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Insalata All' Italiana Salad
        Mesclun salad with mozzarella cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes, and red onion.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view

    • Heros

      • Meatball Hero
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Sausage and Peppers Hero
        Quick view
      • Veal Cutlet Hero
        Quick view
      • Veal and Mushrooms Hero
        Quick view
      • Potato and Egg Hero
        Served with ketchup.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Cutlet Hero with Lettuce and Tomato
        Mayonnaise or dressing.
        Quick view
      • Eggplant Hero
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Salami and Provolone Hero
        Lettuce, tomato, and balsamic vinaigrette.
        Quick view
      • Fresh Mozzarella and Prosciutto Hero
        Served on garlic bread.
        Quick view
      • Italian Combo Hero
        Salami, provolone, pepperoni, soppresatta, ham, lettuce, tomato, and balsamic vinaigrette.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Meatball and Mushrooms Hero
        Quick view
      • Sausage Hero
        Quick view
      • Veal and Peppers Hero
        Quick view
      • Pepper and Egg Hero
        Served with ketchup.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Cutlet Hero
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Grilled Chicken Hero with Lettuce and Tomato
        Mayonnaise or dressing.
        Quick view
      • Shrimp Hero
        Quick view
      • Cheese Steak Hero
        Served with peppers and onions.
        Quick view
      • Fresh Mozzarella Hero
        Served roasted peppers on garlic bread.
        Quick view

    • Create Your Own Personal Pie

      • Create Your Own Personal Pie (12")
        Popular
        Quick view

    • Pizza

    • Pizza by the Slice

    • Specialty Pies

    • Gluten-Free Pizza

    • Pasta Specials

      • Baked Ziti with Ricotta
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Baked Ziti with Meatballs (2 pcs)
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Baked Ravioli (6 pcs)
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Baked Stuffed Shells (4 pcs)
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Fettuccini Alfredo with Broccoli
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Fettuccini with Broccoli, Garlic, and Oil
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Cavatelli
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Baked Ziti with Sausage (2 pcs)
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Baked Lasagna
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Baked Manicotti (3 pcs)
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Fettuccini Alfredo
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Fettuccini Alfredo with Shrimp (5 pcs)
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Penne Alla Vodka with Shrimp (5 pcs)
        Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view
      • Gnocchi
        Ala Napolitano with fresh mozzarella. Served with Italian bread and butter.
        Quick view

    • Pastaria Pasta

      • Pasta with Tomato Sauce
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Bolognese
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Clam Sauce
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Garlic and Oil
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Puttanesca
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Meatballs (2 pcs)
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Broccoli Garlic and Oil
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Calamari
        Marinara. Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Marinara Sauce
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Meat Sauce
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Butter Sauce
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Carbonara
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Primavera
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Sweet Italian Sausage (2 pcs)
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Vodka Sauce
        Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Pasta with Frutti di Mare
        Clams, mussels, calamari, shrimp, scallops, and lobster tail. Served with pasta, Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view

    • Gluten-Free Pasta

      • Gluten-Free Pasta Marinara
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Pasta Carbonara
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Pasta Alla Vodka
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Pasta Puttanesca
        Tomatoes, capers, olives, artichokes, and garlic.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Pasta Alfredo
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Pasta Bolognese
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Pasta Filetto di Pomodoro
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Baked Ziti
        Gluten Free
        Quick view

    • Pastaria Delights

    • Vegetable

      • Eggplant Parmigiana
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Eggplant Rollatini
        Served with prosciutto. Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view

    • Gluten-Free Veal and Beef

      • Gluten-Free Veal Parmigiana
        Breaded veal cutlet with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Veal Saltimbocca
        Sautéed veal and prosciutto over a bed of spinach with a sliced hard-boiled egg in marsala sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Veal Francaise
        Veal sautéed in a zesty white wine lemon butter sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Veal Sorrentino
        Sautéed with sliced prosciutto and eggplant topped with mozzarella in marsala wine sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Char Broiled Filet Mignon (8 oz)
        Filet mignon with gravy sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Veal Picatta
        Sautéed with artichoke hearts in a tangy lemon caper sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Veal Marsala
        Sautéed in a marsala wine sauce and mushrooms. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Veal Pizzaiola
        Sautéed with peppers, mushrooms, and onion in a light pomodoro sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Blackened Rib Eye with Gorgonzola (12 oz)
        Rib eye with gravy sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view

    • Veal

      • Veal Parmigiana
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Veal Marsala with Mushrooms
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Veal and Peppers
        Served with onion. Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Veal Francese
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view

    • Gluten-Free Eggplant

      • Gluten-Free Eggplant Parmigiana
        Breaded eggplant, tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Eggplant Rollatini
        Thin-sliced, rolled in prosciutto, and stuffed with ricotta. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view

    • Chicken

      • Chicken Marsala with Mushrooms
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Francese
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Chicken Sorrentino
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Scarpiello
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Chicken Rollatini
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Chicken Cacciatore
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view

    • Gluten-Free Chicken

      • Gluten-Free Chicken Parmigiana
        Breaded chicken breasts, tomato sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Marsala
        Sautéed chicken in a marsala wine sauce with mushrooms. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Francaise
        Chicken sautéed in a zesty white wine lemon butter sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Milanese
        Breaded cutlet over a field of mixed greens in a citrus dressing. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Venezia
        Sautéed chicken breast topped with prosciutto, asparagus, and melted mozzarella in a white wine sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Sorrentino
        Sautéed with sliced proscuitto and eggplant topped with mozzarella in marsala wine sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Rollatini
        Rolled with prosciutto and stuffed with ricotta in a mushroom sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Scarpariello
        Sliced chicken, potatoes, sausage, peppers, and onions in a sherry wine sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Chicken Cacciatore
        Chicken, onion, mushrooms, and peppers in a light pomodoro sauce. Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view

    • Shrimp

      • Shrimp Parmigiana
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Shrimp Francese
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Shrimp Fried Diavolo
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view
      • Shrimp Scampi
        Served with your choice of pasta, salad, or potatoes, vegetables, with Italian bread, and butter.
        Quick view

    • Gluten-Free Seafood

      • Gluten-Free Spaghetti in Clam Sauce
        Served with choice of side.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Salmon Oreganata
        Broiled and topped with seasoned bread crumbs.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Shrimp Scampi
        Shrimp in a white wine and lemon butter sauce.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Shrimp Fra Diavolo
        Shrimp in a spicy marinara sauce.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Frutti di Mare
        Lobster tail, shrimp, mussels, calamari, scallops scungilli, and clams in a marinara sauce.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Cold Seafood Salad
        Calamari, mussels, scallops, shrimp, and scungilli in a vinaigrette served over a bed of mixed greens.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Pistachio Encrusted Salmon
        Seasoned and broiled, topped with toasted pistachio, and horseradish sour cream.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Flounder Oreganata
        Broiled and topped with seasoned breadcrumbs.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Shrimp Parmigiana
        Breaded shrimp with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Seafood Scampi
        Shrimp, scallops, and lobster tail in a white wine lemon butter sauce.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view
      • Gluten-Free Calamari Fra Diavolo
        Calamari in a spicy tomato sauce.
        Gluten Free
        Quick view

    • Side Orders

    • Gluten-Free Side Dishes

    • Desserts

      • Cannoli
        Chocolate shell, cannoli cream, and powdered sugar.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Chocolate Tartufo
        Chocolate and vanilla gelato, with cherry, almond center, and coated in chocolate.
        Quick view
      • Chocolate Lava Cake
        Chocolate lava cake with 2 scoops vanilla ice cream.
        Popular
        Quick view
      • Rice Pudding
        Bowl of rice pudding.
        Quick view
      • Vanilla Ice Cream
        Bowl of vanilla ice cream.
        Quick view
      • Mini Cannoli
        Cannoli shell (no chocolate), cannoli cream, and powdered sugar.
        Quick view
      • Spumoni Tartufo
        Strawberry, pistachio, and chocolate gelato with pieces of hazelnut. Cherry center. Coated in chocolate.
        Quick view
      • New York Cheesecake
        One slice of New York cheesecake.
        Quick view
      • Tiramisu
        One slice of tiramisu cake.
        Quick view

    • Beverages

    Spend $40, Save $10

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the address of Setauket Pastaria in East Setauket?

    Setauket Pastaria is located at: 4082 Nesconset Hwy , East Setauket

    Is the menu for Setauket Pastaria available online?

    Yes, you can access the menu for Setauket Pastaria online on Postmates. Follow the link to see the full menu available for delivery and pickup.

    What are the most popular items on the Setauket Pastaria menu?

    The most ordered items from Setauket Pastaria are: Chicken Cutlet Hero, Specialty Pizza Slice, Sicilian Pizza Slice.

    Does Setauket Pastaria offer delivery in East Setauket?

    Yes, Setauket Pastaria offers delivery in East Setauket via Postmates. Enter your delivery address to see if you are within the Setauket Pastaria delivery radius, then place your order.

    Can I get free delivery from Setauket Pastaria?

    Delivery fees for Setauket Pastaria vary. Just enter your delivery address to see the delivery fee for your location. You could always get free delivery from Setauket Pastaria with Postmates Unlimited.

    Can I pick up my order from Setauket Pastaria?

    Postmates offers pickup from many restaurants in your city. To see if you can pick up your order from Setauket Pastaria, add items to your cart and look for the ‘pickup’ option at checkout.

    Can I schedule a delivery order from Setauket Pastaria?

    Some restaurants on Postmates allow you to schedule a delivery to show up at your location when you want it. At checkout, look for the option to select a delivery time. If it’s there, that means you can schedule your delivery from Setauket Pastaria.