Sign in
Top categories
Popular dishes
Popular cities
Explore by state
Popular brands
Skip to content
Postmates Home
    The Pizzeria of Lake Grove
    Too far to deliver

    The Pizzeria of Lake Grove

    View delivery time and booking fee.

    Location and hours

    Sunday
    12:00 PM - 06:00 PM
    Monday - Thursday
    11:00 AM - 07:00 PM
    Friday - Saturday
    10:00 AM - 08:00 PM
    Pizza • American • Italian

    606 Montauk Highway, West Sayville, NY 11796 • More


    • Picked for you

      • Pizza Pies

        $17.95
      • Wings

        $10.95
      • Meatball Burrata Pie

        Meatballs, burrata, basil, and red sauce.
        $24.95
      • The Bayport Pie

        Our sweet red sauce on olive oil crust with fresh mozz.
        $24.95
      • Bruschetta Pie

        Balsamic crust, cherry tomatoes, burrata, and glaze.
        $24.95
    • Small Bites

      • Garlic Knots

        $0.40
      • Buffalo Knots

        $0.40
      • Pepperoni Pinwheel

        $2.95
      • Veggie Pinwheel

        $2.95
      • Rice Ball

        $2.95
      • Garlic Bread With Mozz

        $3.95
      • Chicken Roll

        $7.95
      • Mozzarella Sticks

        $7.95
      • Fried Ravioli

        $9.95
      • Meatballs

        $8.95
      • Wings

        $10.95
    • Greens

      • House

        Mixed field greens, cherry tomatoes, red onion, cucumbers, freshly made croutons, and mozz cheese.
        $9.95
      • Caesar

        Romain, shaved parmesan cheese, parm crisps, and croutons.
        $9.95
      • The Salad

        Field greens, honey crisp apple sticks, cherry tomatoes, croutons, candied pecans, parm crisps, and cheddar cheese.
        $12.95
      • Skip the Carbs

        Mixed field greens, cherry tomatoes, toasted pine nuts, parm crisps, pearls of mozzarella.
        $11.95
    • Pizza Pies

      • Pizza Pies

        $17.95
    • Between Bread

      • Parmigiana Hero

        Chicken, eggplant, meatball, or shrimp parm hero.
        $9.95
      • The Hero

        Meatball or chicken with burrata, fresh basil, EVOO, and shaved parm.
        $11.95
      • Prosciutto Street Sandwich

        Prosciutto, fresh mozz, tomato, basil, olive oil on freshly made focaccia.
        $9.95
      • Pesto Chicken

        Freshly made focaccia with grilled chicken, pesto, fresh mozz, and roasted peppers.
        $9.95
    • Speciality Pies

      • The Bayport Pie

        Our sweet red sauce on olive oil crust with fresh mozz.
        $24.95
      • Upside Down Pie

        Fresh mozz under our sweet sauce on Sicilian crust.
        $24.95
      • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie

        Pronounced CBR.
        $24.95
      • Detroit Pie

        Crispy multi-cheese crust, straight from the motor city.
        $19.95
      • The Honey Pep Pie

        Sicilian with pepperoni and mike’s hot honey drizzle.
        $24.95
      • White Pie

        Ricotta, mascarpone, mozz, and truffle oil.
        $24.95
      • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

        Wings and pizza, it’s a good thing.
        $24.95
      • Thai Chili Pie

        Thai chili sauce on pizza yes, trust us.
        $24.95
      • Bruschetta Pie

        Balsamic crust, cherry tomatoes, burrata, and glaze.
        $24.95
      • Vodka Margherita Pie

        Olive oil crust topped with fresh mozz and vodka sauce.
        $24.95
      • Meatball Burrata Pie

        Meatballs, burrata, basil, and red sauce.
        $24.95
      • Nonna's Non-dairy Pie

        Olive oil crust, veggies, and red sauce.
        $24.95
      • Gluten Free Personal Pie

        $12.95
        Gluten-Free
    • Pasta

      • Baked Ziti Pasta

        $15.95
      • Penne Vodka Pasta

        $15.95
      • Pasta With Broccoli & Garlic Oil

        $15.95
      • Pasta With Meatballs

        $15.95
      • Spicy Rigatoni Pasta

        $15.95
        Spicy
      • Tri-color Tortellini in Alfredo Sauce Pasta

        $15.95
    • Dinner

      • Parmigiana

        Chicken, eggplant, meatball, or shrimp with red sauce or vodka sauce.
        $19.95
      • The Pizzeria Chicken

        Chicken cutlet topped with arugula, cherry tomatoes, and balsamic glaze.
        $19.95
      • Chicken Francese

        $19.95
      • Chicken Marsala

        $19.95