Skip to content
Postmates Home
Hungry? You're in the right placeHungry? You're in the right place

American Delivery in Bay Shore

    1. United States
    2. New York
    3. Bay Shore
    4. American Food

    American Food Delivery in Bay Shore


    American Crepe Company (Lake Ronkonkoma)

    $0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

    American Crepe Company (Lake Ronkonkoma)

    50–65 min
      •  $
     
    New

    KTO Cuisine

    KTO Cuisine

    20–35 min
      •  $
     
    4.5

    American Standard - Whiskey Bar & Grill (W Main St)

    Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    American Standard - Whiskey Bar & Grill (W Main St)

    15–30 min
     
    4.6

    Buseto Pizza & Restaurant

    Buseto Pizza & Restaurant

    20–35 min
     
    4.6

    Sayville Athletic Club

    Sayville Athletic Club

    40–55 min
     
    4.7

    Philly Cheez (1912)

    3 Offers Available

    Philly Cheez (1912)

    25–45 min
      •  
    $4.99 Delivery Fee
     
    3.6

    Tio’s Shop Chicken

    Tio’s Shop Chicken

    30–45 min
     
    New

    KFC - Bay Shore

    Save on Select Items

    KFC - Bay Shore

    10–20 min
      •  $$
     
    4.4

    It's Just Wings (2020 Sunrise Hwy)

    It's Just Wings (2020 Sunrise Hwy)

    20–35 min
      •  $$
     
    4.2

    La Cantinita

    La Cantinita

    50–65 min
     
    5.0

    Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille (Bayshore)

    Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille (Bayshore)

    15–30 min
     
    4.6

    Buster's American Kitchen (Islandia)

    Buster's American Kitchen (Islandia)

    40–55 min
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    Doctor Cuisine

    Doctor Cuisine

    45–60 min
     
    4.4

    Deli Gusto Latino

    Top Offer • 30% off (Spend $15)

    Deli Gusto Latino

    40–55 min
     
    New

    Super's Cafe

    Super's Cafe

    60–75 min
     
    New

    Taquero Mucho

    Taquero Mucho

    25–40 min
     
    New

    Capriotti's Sandwich Shop (NY100268)

    Top Offer • Spend $20, Save $5

    Capriotti's Sandwich Shop (NY100268)

    50–65 min
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Amore Pizzeria & Fine Food

    Amore Pizzeria & Fine Food

    35–55 min
      •  
    $2 Delivery Fee
      •  $
     
    4.5

    Guac Shop - Commack

    Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

    Guac Shop - Commack

    35–50 min
     
    4.3

    The 3rd Rail

    The 3rd Rail

    55–70 min
      •  $$
     
    4.3

    Bayberry

    Bayberry

    15–30 min
      •  $$
     
    New

    bella vista pizza & pasta

    bella vista pizza & pasta

    50–65 min
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Wild Wild Wings (1070 Middle Country Rd)

    Spend $15, Save $3

    Wild Wild Wings (1070 Middle Country Rd)

    65–80 min
      •  $
     
    4.2

    KPOT (Bay Shore)

    KPOT (Bay Shore)

    20–35 min
      •  $$
     
    4.3

    Crispino's Pizza

    Crispino's Pizza

    30–50 min
      •  
    $2 Delivery Fee
     
    New

    Long Island Coffee Company (Lake Ronkonkoma)

    $0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

    Long Island Coffee Company (Lake Ronkonkoma)

    55–70 min
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Hootie's Burger Bar (Farmingdale)

    Hootie's Burger Bar (Farmingdale)

    55–70 min
      •  $$
     
    New

    Cabo Fresh Centereach

    Spend $45, Save $10

    Cabo Fresh Centereach

    50–65 min
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria - North Babylon

    Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria - North Babylon

    30–45 min
     
    New

    IMC Restaurant & Bar

    IMC Restaurant & Bar

    60–75 min
     
    4.9

    Popeyes - Bay Shore

    2 Offers Available

    Popeyes - Bay Shore

    15–30 min
      •  $$
     
    4.4

    Katty's Mac & Cheese

    Top Offer • Spend $40, Save $11

    Katty's Mac & Cheese

    65–80 min
     
    4.6

    Brunello's Pizza & Pasta

    Brunello's Pizza & Pasta

    35–50 min
     
    New

    Elsie Lane Wing House - Huntington

    Elsie Lane Wing House - Huntington

    55–70 min
     
    4.7

    The Harp & Hound

    The Harp & Hound

    15–30 min
      •  $$
     
    New

    Cafe Latino Deli & Restaurant

    3 Offers Available

    Cafe Latino Deli & Restaurant

    40–55 min
     
    4.9

    Dirty Taco + Tequila - Smithtown

    Dirty Taco + Tequila - Smithtown

    50–65 min
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Subway (1735 Union Blvd)

    Subway (1735 Union Blvd)

    10–20 min
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Griddlerz - Plainview

    Griddlerz - Plainview

    65–80 min
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    Hispano American Restaurant

    Hispano American Restaurant

    40–55 min
     
    New

    Kick'N Chicken LI (Huntington)

    Kick'N Chicken LI (Huntington)

    55–70 min
      •  $
     
    4.3

    Viva El Taco

    Viva El Taco

    60–75 min
     
    New

    The Burger (17)

    Top Offer • 2 Offers Available

    The Burger (17)

    40–55 min
     
    3.5

    Milano Bean Cafe - Bay Shore

    Milano Bean Cafe - Bay Shore

    10–20 min
      •  $$
     
    New

    Dunkin' (529 E. Main St)

    Spend $15, Save $5

    Dunkin' (529 E. Main St)

    10–20 min
      •  $
     
    4.5

    Harleys American Grille

    Harleys American Grille

    45–60 min
      •  $$
     
    4.9

    Jersey Mike's (2332 Hempstead Turnpike)

    20% off (Spend $15)

    Jersey Mike's (2332 Hempstead Turnpike)

    70–85 min
     
    4.6

    BLD's Restaurant

    BLD's Restaurant

    45–60 min
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    Pino's Pizza

    Pino's Pizza

    55–70 min
      •  $$
     
    4.3

    Domino's (55 3rd Ave)

    Top Offer • Free Item (Spend $9)

    Domino's (55 3rd Ave)

    30–50 min
      •  
    $1.49 Delivery Fee
      •  $
     
    4.3

    Big Al's Burgers

    Free Item (Spend $20)

    Big Al's Burgers

    65–80 min
     
    3.0

    Henley's Village Tavern

    Henley's Village Tavern

    20–35 min
      •  $$
     
    4.6

    Butera's Restaurant

    Butera's Restaurant

    15–30 min
     
    4.7

    Bang Bang Burritos - Bayshore

    Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    Bang Bang Burritos - Bayshore

    10–20 min
     
    4.6

    Burrito Palace and Grill (Lake Ronkonkoma)

    Burrito Palace and Grill (Lake Ronkonkoma)

    50–65 min
     
    4.9

    Union Blvd Deli

    Union Blvd Deli

    15–30 min
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Green Tea Restaurant - Szechuan & Dry Pot

    Free Item (Spend $35)

    Green Tea Restaurant - Szechuan & Dry Pot

    65–80 min
      •  $$
     
    4.8

    The Penny Pub

    Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    The Penny Pub

    15–30 min
      •  $
     
    4.5

    Food Bazaar (101 Wicks Rd)

    Offers available

    Food Bazaar (101 Wicks Rd)

    45–65 min
     
    4.6

    Texaquito

    Texaquito

    25–40 min
     
    4.5

    Mexican Grill 2000

    Mexican Grill 2000

    45–60 min
      •  $
     
    4.8

    La Bamba

    La Bamba

    50–65 min
     
    4.8

    Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

    2 Offers Available

    Blaze Pizza (1701 Sunrise Hwy)

    15–30 min
      •  $
     
    4.3

    La Gran Amazonia

    La Gran Amazonia

    50–65 min
     
    4.7

    Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

    Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

    15–30 min
      •  $$
     
    4.3

    Tap Room (Bayshore)

    Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    Tap Room (Bayshore)

    25–40 min
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Panera (1701 Sunrise Highway )

    Free Item (Spend $30)

    Panera (1701 Sunrise Highway )

    10–25 min
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Salvinos Pizza and Restaurant

    Salvinos Pizza and Restaurant

    70–85 min
     
    4.0

    Tito's Birrias and Grill

    Tito's Birrias and Grill

    25–40 min
      •  $
     
    5.0

    Roadtrip

    Roadtrip

    15–30 min
     
    New

    Pasaquina Deli

    Pasaquina Deli

    40–55 min
     
    New

    Villa Pizza

    Villa Pizza

    50–65 min
      •  $$
     
    4.6

    Sweet Spot Cafe

    20% off (Spend $15)

    Sweet Spot Cafe

    45–60 min
     
    4.9

    Pardon My Cheesesteak - 25 West Sunrise Highway

    Pardon My Cheesesteak - 25 West Sunrise Highway

    30–45 min
     
    4.0

    L.I. Wings-N-Things

    Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    L.I. Wings-N-Things

    65–80 min
     
    4.6

    Charleys Cheesesteak (161 Centereach Mall)

    Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    Charleys Cheesesteak (161 Centereach Mall)

    60–75 min
      •  $
     
    4.5

    Pupuseria San Francisco

    Pupuseria San Francisco

    45–60 min
     
    4.5

    Nunzio's Pizza Town

    Nunzio's Pizza Town

    30–45 min
     
    New

    Local Burger Co. - Bayshore

    Top Offer • Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    Local Burger Co. - Bayshore

    10–25 min
     
    4.8

    Bowl Market (5012 Express Drive South)

    Bowl Market (5012 Express Drive South)

    45–60 min
      •  $$
     
    4.3

    Order Postmates in Bay Shore

    The best American Food - it’s out there, it’s probably nearby, you want it, and we have it. You want it delivered. We get it. Maybe, you want it in the morning, in the evening, or late at night when you’re in the office on a rainy day. Satisfying your craving for American Food does not have to be hard. We want to help, and that is why Postmates is always ready to get you American Food at any time, when you want it, right at your door.


    Frequently asked questions

    Which American spots deliver with Postmates in Bay Shore?

    You can order American delivery in Bay Shore with Postmates. Try one of the most popular spots in town, like The Tap Room (Bayshore), Tullulah’s, and Chiddy’s Cheesesteaks - Bay Shore.

    What are the best American spots that deliver in Bay Shore?

    Stores in your area don’t have many ratings. For American delivery in Bay Shore, consider one of the following spots: Subway (585 Montauk Hwy), The Big Melt (630 Old Country Road), and Subway (1701 Sunrise Hwy).

    How many American spots are available in Bay Shore?

    Bay Shore has 70 American places offering delivery with Postmates.

    Which American spots offer free delivery in Bay Shore?

    Delivery fees can vary depending on where you are. Enter your delivery address to see which American spots offer free delivery to your location.

    What places can I pick up American from in Bay Shore?

    If you’re in Bay Shore, there are 70 American spots that offer pickup on Postmates. Open Postmates and tap ‘Pickup’ to see options.

    What are the best American items that I can order for delivery in Bay Shore?

    Some of the suggested items for American delivery are: Cornbread, Ribs, and Tater Tots.