Skip to content
Hungry? You're in the right placeHungry? You're in the right place

Pizza Delivery in East Setauket

    1. United States
    2. New York
    3. East Setauket
    4. Pizza

    Pizza Delivery in East Setauket


    Subway (18 Woods Corner Rd)

    Spend $30, Save $5

    Subway (18 Woods Corner Rd)

    10–25 min
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Five Star Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Five Star Pizza

    17.9 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Brooklyn Calzones (25 Gibbs Rd)

    Too far to deliver

    Brooklyn Calzones (25 Gibbs Rd)

    5.5 mi
      •  $$
     
    New

    Gourmet Burger Bistro

    Gourmet Burger Bistro

    25–40 min
     
    4.6

    Angela's Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Angela's Pizza

    14.2 mi
     
    4.8

    Target (South Setauket)

    Save on Select Items

    Target (South Setauket)

    40–60 min
      •  $$
     
    4.9

    7-Eleven (1001 Route 25A)

    Save on Select Items

    7-Eleven (1001 Route 25A)

    15–35 min
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Michael Anthony's Pizzeria and Restaurant

    Too far to deliver

    Michael Anthony's Pizzeria and Restaurant

    4.7 mi
      •  $
     
    4.6

    The Bench Bar & Grill

    Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    The Bench Bar & Grill

    25–40 min
      •  $$
     
    5.0

    Voulapitta

    Too far to deliver

    Voulapitta

    4.6 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.9

    Albert’s Pizza (Ronkonkoma)

    Too far to deliver

    Albert’s Pizza (Ronkonkoma)

    6.6 mi
     
    New

    Panera (4959 Nesconset Hwy )

    Panera (4959 Nesconset Hwy )

    20–35 min
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Anthony's Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Anthony's Pizza

    16.7 mi
     
    4.5

    Paisano's Pizza & Catering

    Paisano's Pizza & Catering

    55–75 min
     
    New

    Cheezon

    Too far to deliver

    Cheezon

    6.6 mi
     
    New

    Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace (Port Jefferson)

    Too far to deliver

    Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace (Port Jefferson)

    3.3 mi
      •  $
     
    4.9

    Stony Brook Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Stony Brook Pizza

    3.5 mi
     
    New

    Albert's Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Albert's Pizza

    11 mi
      •  $
     
    New

    Carnival Restaurant

    Carnival Restaurant

    25–40 min
      •  $$$
     
    4.9

    Pita & Pizza - Washington Ave

    Too far to deliver

    Pita & Pizza - Washington Ave

    11.6 mi
     
    4.8

    machi sushi

    Too far to deliver

    machi sushi

    5.9 mi
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Portion Kitchen

    Too far to deliver

    Portion Kitchen

    6.8 mi
     
    New

    Renzo’s Pizza & Restaurant

    Too far to deliver

    Renzo’s Pizza & Restaurant

    3.6 mi
     
    4.6

    Mito - Smith Haven

    Too far to deliver

    Mito - Smith Haven

    4.6 mi
     
    4.6

    Nishiki Hibachi & Sushi

    Too far to deliver

    Nishiki Hibachi & Sushi

    5 mi
     
    4.8

    Station Pizza & Brew

    Station Pizza & Brew

    25–40 min
      •  $
     
    New

    Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

    Too far to deliver

    Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

    5.1 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    Greek Islands Restaurant

    Too far to deliver

    Greek Islands Restaurant

    8 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Boom Boom Soups Salad & Sandwiches

    Too far to deliver

    Boom Boom Soups Salad & Sandwiches

    6.6 mi
      •  $
     
    4.6

    Walgreens (226 Route 25A)

    Save on Select Items

    Walgreens (226 Route 25A)

    25–45 min
      •  $
     
    New

    Gino's of Nesconset

    Too far to deliver

    Gino's of Nesconset

    6.9 mi
     
    4.7

    Bella Roma

    Too far to deliver

    Bella Roma

    6.9 mi
     
    4.8

    QuickChek - Store 141

    Too far to deliver

    QuickChek - Store 141

    4.7 mi
      •  $
     
    4.4

    The Pie - Coal Fired Pizza

    The Pie - Coal Fired Pizza

    45–65 min
     
    5.0

    Buona Sera Ristorante Pizzeria

    Too far to deliver

    Buona Sera Ristorante Pizzeria

    6.7 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    Zara Pizza - Selden

    Too far to deliver

    Zara Pizza - Selden

    3.7 mi
     
    4.8

    Island Lake Diner

    Too far to deliver

    Island Lake Diner

    6.6 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Original Brooklyn Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Original Brooklyn Pizza

    10.5 mi
     
    4.9

    Setauket Village Restaurant Diner

    Setauket Village Restaurant Diner

    10–25 min
      •  $
     
    New

    Caffe Amici

    Too far to deliver

    Caffe Amici

    4.9 mi
     
    4.8

    Kira Sushi

    Too far to deliver

    Kira Sushi

    6.6 mi
     
    4.6

    Chicos Tex Mex (30NY)

    $0 Delivery Fee (Spend $10)

    Chicos Tex Mex (30NY)

    15–30 min
     
    5.0

    Ideal Food Basket (500 New York 112)

    Offers available

    Ideal Food Basket (500 New York 112)

    40–60 min
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    Lake Grove Diner

    Too far to deliver

    Lake Grove Diner

    3.8 mi
      •  $
     
    4.9

    CVS (682 Route 25A)

    Save on Select Items

    CVS (682 Route 25A)

    20–40 min
      •  $
     
    New

    PJ Sushi Teriyaki

    PJ Sushi Teriyaki

    25–40 min
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Setauket Pastaria

    Spend $30, Save $8

    Setauket Pastaria

    35–55 min
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Applebee's (Farmingville)

    Too far to deliver

    Applebee's (Farmingville)

    8.2 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.6

    A&A Sushi House

    Too far to deliver

    A&A Sushi House

    8.7 mi
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Taco Island Tex-mex

    Too far to deliver

    Taco Island Tex-mex

    3.7 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Sweet n' Savory Crepe of Port Jefferson

    Sweet n' Savory Crepe of Port Jefferson

    20–35 min
     
    New

    Luigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Luigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    20–35 min
      •  $
     
    4.5

    Portofino Pizza Huntington Village

    Too far to deliver

    Portofino Pizza Huntington Village

    17.4 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.6

    Dragos Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Dragos Pizza

    8 mi
     
    4.6

    Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

    Too far to deliver

    Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

    6.8 mi
     
    New

    Wild Ginger Smithtown

    Too far to deliver

    Wild Ginger Smithtown

    6.8 mi
     
    4.7

    Middle island pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Middle island pizza

    8.5 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Junior's Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Junior's Pizza

    16.7 mi
      •  $$
     
    New

    Amici Restaurant (Mt Sinai, NY)

    Too far to deliver

    Amici Restaurant (Mt Sinai, NY)

    4 mi
     
    4.6

    Old Town Pizza Port Jefferson

    Too far to deliver

    Old Town Pizza Port Jefferson

    3.5 mi
     
    4.8

    Taco Bell (4833 Nesconset Hwy)

    Free Item (Spend $22)

    Taco Bell (4833 Nesconset Hwy)

    15–30 min
      •  $
     
    4.4

    Old City Public House (Portion Rd)

    Too far to deliver

    Old City Public House (Portion Rd)

    6.9 mi
     
    4.6

    Millennium Diner

    Too far to deliver

    Millennium Diner

    6.6 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    O Sole Mio

    Too far to deliver

    O Sole Mio

    3.8 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.7

    Mile High Wings

    Buy 1, Get 1 Free

    Mile High Wings

    20–35 min
     
    New

    Amore Pizza

    Too far to deliver

    Amore Pizza

    12.1 mi
     
    4.5

    Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grill

    Too far to deliver

    Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grill

    5.2 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    FIGARI'S WINE & LIQUOR

    Too far to deliver

    FIGARI'S WINE & LIQUOR

    6.7 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.9

    Homerun Heros

    Too far to deliver

    Homerun Heros

    5 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.5

    Umberto's of Lake Grove

    Too far to deliver

    Umberto's of Lake Grove

    4.4 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    Seaport Diner

    Seaport Diner

    20–35 min
     
    4.7

    Waverly Liquors

    Waverly Liquors

    15–35 min
     
    4.9

    Chili's Grill & Bar (280 Pond Path)

    Chili's Grill & Bar (280 Pond Path)

    25–40 min
      •  $$
     
    4.6

    Holbrook Diner

    Too far to deliver

    Holbrook Diner

    8.4 mi
      •  $
     
    4.7

    Hauppauge Palace Diner

    Too far to deliver

    Hauppauge Palace Diner

    8.3 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.8

    Alfredo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Too far to deliver

    Alfredo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    11 mi
      •  $
     
    4.8

    BLD's Restaurant

    Too far to deliver

    BLD's Restaurant

    7.4 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.8

    Red Lobster (2220 Nesconset Highway)

    Too far to deliver

    Red Lobster (2220 Nesconset Highway)

    3.9 mi
      •  $$
     
    4.4

    Via Pizza

    Via Pizza

    25–40 min
     
    4.7

    Joey Z's / ZPita

    Joey Z's / ZPita

    30–45 min
      •  $$
     
    New

    Order Postmates in East Setauket

    The best Pizza - it’s out there, it’s probably nearby, you want it, and we have it. You want it delivered. We get it. Maybe, you want it in the morning, in the evening, or late at night when you’re in the office on a rainy day. Satisfying your craving for Pizza does not have to be hard. We want to help, and that is why Postmates is always ready to get you Pizza at any time, when you want it, right at your door.


    Frequently asked questions

    Does Postmates offer delivery from Pizza spots in East Setauket?

    You can order Pizza delivery in East Setauket with Postmates. Try one of the most popular spots in town, like Setauket Pastaria and Luigi’s Pizzeria & Restaurant.

    What are the most popular Pizza spots that deliver in East Setauket?

    Stores in your area don’t have many ratings. For Pizza delivery in East Setauket, consider one of the following spots: Setauket Pastaria, Luigi’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, and Mile High Wings.

    How many Pizza spots are available in East Setauket?

    East Setauket has a number of Pizza places offering delivery with Postmates.

    Which Pizza spots offer free delivery in East Setauket?

    Delivery fees can vary depending on where you are. Enter your delivery address to see which Pizza spots offer free delivery to your location.

    Where can I get late-night Pizza delivery in East Setauket?

    Some Pizza spots that are open late include: Setauket Pastaria. You can order Pizza delivery until 9pm in East Setauket.

    Which Pizza spots in East Setauket offer order pickup near me?

    If you’re in East Setauket, there are a number of Pizza spots that offer pickup on Postmates. Open Postmates and tap ‘Pickup’ to see options.

    What are the best Pizza items that I can order for delivery in East Setauket?

    Some of the suggested items for Pizza delivery are: Deep Dish Pizza, White Pizza, and Chicago Pizza.