Skip to content
Postmates Home
Hungry? You're in the right placeHungry? You're in the right place

Pizza Delivery in Shirley

    1. United States
    2. New York
    3. Shirley
    4. Pizza

    Pizza Delivery in Shirley


    Carnival Restaurant

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Carnival Restaurant

    $$$
     
    4.7

    Joe's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Joe's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    $
     
    4.5

    Nonna's Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Nonna's Pizzeria

    $
     
    4.7

    Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    Selden Restaurant Pizza & Gyros

    $$
     
    4.7

    Medford Pastaria (Horseblock Rd)

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Medford Pastaria (Horseblock Rd)

     
    4.6

    QuickChek - Store 141

    Too far to deliver

    QuickChek - Store 141

    13.1 mi
      •  $
     
    4.4

    Pizza Stop

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Pizza Stop

    $
     
    4.4

    Carlo's Pizza Shirley

    Opens at 10:30 AM

    Carlo's Pizza Shirley

    $$
     
    4.8

    Edesia Restaurant & Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Edesia Restaurant & Pizzeria

    $
     
    4.9

    Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Nesconset Pizza & Pasta

     
    4.6

    Mamma Lombardis

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Mamma Lombardis

    $
     
    4.6

    Pizzaiolo

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Pizzaiolo

     
    4.9

    Fratelli's Restaurant & Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:30 AM

    Fratelli's Restaurant & Pizzeria

     
    4.4

    Spaceship Pizza

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Spaceship Pizza

     
    3.7

    Medford's Pizza and Deli

    Opens at 6:00 AM

    Medford's Pizza and Deli

     
    4.8

    Barrila's Pastaria Ristorante

    Opens at 12:00 PM

    Barrila's Pastaria Ristorante

     
    4.0

    La Grova Ristorante and Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    La Grova Ristorante and Pizzeria

    $
     
    4.8

    Brooklyn Calzones (287 Second Ave)

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Brooklyn Calzones (287 Second Ave)

    $$
     
    3.9

    Poppop's Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Poppop's Pizzeria

     
    New

    Francescas Pizza

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    Francescas Pizza

    $
     
    4.7

    Portion Kitchen

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Portion Kitchen

     
    New

    Brezza Pizza Kitchen

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Brezza Pizza Kitchen

    $$
     
    4.7

    7-Eleven (449 William Floyd Pkwy)

    Spend $20, Save $4

    7-Eleven (449 William Floyd Pkwy)

    10–30 min
      •  $
     
    4.3

    CAFE GIA

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    CAFE GIA

     
    4.8

    Domino's Pizza (Ste D, 1265 Montauk Hwy)

    Opens at 10:30 AM

    Domino's Pizza (Ste D, 1265 Montauk Hwy)

    $
     
    4.2

    La Slice Pizzeria

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    La Slice Pizzeria

    $
     
    4.7

    Greek Islands Restaurant

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Greek Islands Restaurant

    $
     
    4.6

    Pelligrino Pizza

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Pelligrino Pizza

    $
     
    4.6

    Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza (Bohemia)

    Opens at 10:45 AM

    Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza (Bohemia)

    $
     
    4.7

    Uncle Joe's Famous Pizzeria (formerly Papa Nick's Pizza)

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Uncle Joe's Famous Pizzeria (formerly Papa Nick's Pizza)

     
    New

    Taco Express Plus

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Taco Express Plus

    $
     
    4.3

    Maria's Pizza & Bistro

    Opens at 8:30 AM

    Maria's Pizza & Bistro

    $
     
    4.9

    FUNCHOS - Riverhead

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    FUNCHOS - Riverhead

    $
     
    4.4

    Francesco's Trattoria

    Opens at 12:00 PM

    Francesco's Trattoria

     
    3.8

    Pasqually's Pizza & Wings P496 (121 Sunrise Hwy)

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Pasqually's Pizza & Wings P496 (121 Sunrise Hwy)

    $
     
    New

    ZONA OUT-EAST DINER

    Opens at 8:00 AM

    ZONA OUT-EAST DINER

     
    4.7

    Savarona Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:30 AM

    Savarona Pizzeria

     
    4.9

    Alfredo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Opens at 10:30 AM

    Alfredo's Pizzeria & Restaurant

    $
     
    4.8

    Middle island pizza

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Middle island pizza

    $
     
    4.7

    Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Hauppauge

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Mama's Brick Oven Pizzeria - Hauppauge

    $$$
     
    New

    Taco Island Tex-mex

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Taco Island Tex-mex

    $
     
    4.7

    D'Matteos Pizza & Grill

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    D'Matteos Pizza & Grill

     
    4.2

    Caffe Amici

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Caffe Amici

     
    4.7

    Chuck E. Cheese (121 Sunrise Hwy)

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Chuck E. Cheese (121 Sunrise Hwy)

    $
     
    New

    Hero haven and more

    Opens at 9:00 AM

    Hero haven and more

    $
     
    4.5

    Nino's Pizzeria Pasta & Heros

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Nino's Pizzeria Pasta & Heros

     
    4.7

    Giovanni’s Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Giovanni’s Pizzeria

     
    4.7

    Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

    Opens at 10:30 AM

    Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant

     
    4.7

    Stony Brook Pizza

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    Stony Brook Pizza

     
    4.7

    Bernie's Family Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Bernie's Family Pizzeria

     
    4.4

    KC's Pizza N Wings (Islip)

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    KC's Pizza N Wings (Islip)

     
    4.6

    Pazzo Ristorante and Wood Fired Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Pazzo Ristorante and Wood Fired Pizzeria

    $$
     
    4.5

    Speedway (525 WILLIAM FLOYD PKWY)

    2 Offers Available

    Speedway (525 WILLIAM FLOYD PKWY)

    10–30 min
      •  $
     
    4.5

    Rocco's Pizza And Pasta Riverhead

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Rocco's Pizza And Pasta Riverhead

     
    New

    Pine Grove Inn

    Opens Wednesday 11:00 AM

    Pine Grove Inn

    $$
     
    4.5

    Setauket Pastaria

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    Setauket Pastaria

    $
     
    4.6

    L'Anatra Pizza And Kitchen

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    L'Anatra Pizza And Kitchen

     
    4.9

    Panera (11 Commerce Drive )

    Opens at 7:00 AM

    Panera (11 Commerce Drive )

    $
     
    4.8

    Albert's Pizza

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    Albert's Pizza

    $
     
    4.0

    Umberto's of Sayville

    Opens at 11:30 AM

    Umberto's of Sayville

     
    4.7

    Brookhouse Pizza and Grill

    Opens at 6:30 AM

    Brookhouse Pizza and Grill

     
    4.9

    Italiano Pizza & Food Co.

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Italiano Pizza & Food Co.

    $
     
    5.0

    Savino’s Hideaway

    Opens at 12:00 PM

    Savino’s Hideaway

    $$
     
    4.7

    Old Town Pizza Port Jefferson

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    Old Town Pizza Port Jefferson

     
    4.6

    Bella Roma

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Bella Roma

     
    4.7

    Marco's Sicilian Pizza + Pasta (300 East Main Street)

    Opens at 10:00 AM

    Marco's Sicilian Pizza + Pasta (300 East Main Street)

     
    New

    Loco Lobster (Montauk)

    Opens Wednesday 11:00 AM

    Loco Lobster (Montauk)

    $
     
    4.7

    Carlo's Pizza of Holbrook

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Carlo's Pizza of Holbrook

    $
     
    4.7

    Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour (formerly Fusilli)

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Uncle Joe’s Pizza & Parlour (formerly Fusilli)

     
    New

    Giorgios

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Giorgios

    $
     
    4.8

    Taco island mexican cantina

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Taco island mexican cantina

     
    4.9

    Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Capellini Trattoria Pizzeria

     
    4.5

    Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Uncle Joe's Pizza & Parlour

     
    4.5

    Seacove Italian American Bar & Grill

    Opens Wednesday 12:00 PM

    Seacove Italian American Bar & Grill

    $$
     
    4.7

    One Stop Deli

    Closed

    One Stop Deli

    $
     
    4.5

    Restaurant Depot (1335 Lakeland Avenue)

    Opens at 6:00 AM

    Restaurant Depot (1335 Lakeland Avenue)

    $$
     
    New

    Pizza Corner - Medford

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Pizza Corner - Medford

    $
     
    4.6

    Brothers Four Pizza

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Brothers Four Pizza

     
    4.8

    Target (Medford)

    Opens at 8:00 AM

    Target (Medford)

    $$
     
    4.8

    Mama Lisa Restaurant

    Opens at 11:00 AM

    Mama Lisa Restaurant

    $
     
    4.6

    Order Postmates in Shirley

    The best Pizza - it’s out there, it’s probably nearby, you want it, and we have it. You want it delivered. We get it. Maybe, you want it in the morning, in the evening, or late at night when you’re in the office on a rainy day. Satisfying your craving for Pizza does not have to be hard. We want to help, and that is why Postmates is always ready to get you Pizza at any time, when you want it, right at your door.


    Frequently asked questions

    Which Pizza spots deliver with Postmates in Shirley?

    You can order Pizza delivery in Shirley with Postmates. Try one of the most popular spots in town, like Joe’s Pizzeria & Restaurant.

    What are the buzz-worthy Pizza spots on Postmates?

    Stores in your area don’t have many ratings. For Pizza delivery in Shirley, consider one of the following spots: Gerardo’s pizza & Pasta , Carlo’s Pizza Shirley, and Joe’s Pizzeria & Restaurant.

    How many Pizza spots are available in Shirley?

    If you’re in Shirley, there are a number of Pizza spots that could deliver to you with Postmates. Enter your delivery address to see which are available.

    Which Pizza spots offer free delivery in Shirley?

    Delivery fees can vary depending on where you are. Enter your delivery address to see which Pizza spots offer free delivery to your location.

    Which Pizza spots in Shirley offer order pickup near me?

    If you’re in Shirley, there are a number of Pizza spots that offer pickup on Postmates. Open Postmates and tap ‘Pickup’ to see options.

    What are the best Pizza items that I can order for delivery in Shirley?

    Some of the suggested items for Pizza delivery are: Thin Crust Pizza, Margherita Pizza, and Pesto Pizza.